Mace Windu vs Supreme Overlord Shimrra

Started by carthage2 pages

Mace Windu vs Supreme Overlord Shimrra

Why not?

Battle takes place on neutral ground

Shimrra.

Shimrra.

That's a tough one.

Mace wins; no contest. This a neutral area, not like when Luke fought him in his throne, or whatever it was.

Luke also had to fight through a whole bunch of shit in order to reach Shimmra. Still, Luke had years of experience fighting Vong, which Mace won't have, and Shimmra's amphistaff might pose some problems.

Good fight.

Mace

Up

Shimrra.

Originally posted by SunRazer
Shimrra.

Mace takes this with little difficulty.

Unless he has to fight thru an entire citadel of vong warriors to get to the fight then has to fight a dozen slayers while in a room thats simultaneously throwing him around due to the malfunctioning world brain and having a dovin basal controlling the gravity in the room making just standing or moving difficult, and being completly exhausted like luke was when he faced shimmra.

LMAO ^

Y' know, that Luke is >>>>>> Windu?

Originally posted by Ursumeles
LMAO ^

Y' know, that Luke is >>>>>> Windu?

read the book. Understand the context. Come back when your better educated.

Originally posted by Raptor22
read the book. Understand the context. Come back when your better educated.

I know that Luke was exhausted. But I doubt it was to such an degree, that Mace would win easily against his equal.
Shimrra also oneshotted Jacen, and is a vast superior to Slayers.

Originally posted by Ursumeles
I know that Luke was exhausted. But I doubt it was to such an degree, that Mace would win easily against his equal.
Shimrra also oneshotted Jacen, and is a vast superior to Slayers.
your doubts r meaningless, facts matter. Luke was exhausted to the point that he had to call deeply on his force reserves just to throw some force lightning at a slayer. Something he's done before and since with complete ease. Yet here he had to call deeply on his reserves.

"Jacen could feel Luke call deeply on the reservoir that was the force. From lukes left hand gathered a blinding tangle of energy manipulated into being by the raw power of the force."

Addressed the jacen one shot in other thread. To sum up, its not a oneshot if the person getting hit is injured, exhausted, has taken several shot from others just before and gets thrown into the punch by an outside force.

Originally posted by Ursumeles
LMAO ^

Y' know, that Luke is >>>>>> Windu?


Novel Luke isn't >>>>>> novel Windu.

Originally posted by GM Yoda
Novel Luke isn't >>>>>> novel Windu.

"Novel" Luke? Wut? Also, yeah, TUF Luke is vastly superior to Windu, not talking about post-DN Luke.

Originally posted by Ursumeles
"Novel" Luke? Wut? Also, yeah, TUF Luke is vastly superior to Windu, not talking about post-DN Luke.
Luke Skywalker in the novels is a lot weaker than he is in the comics.

Originally posted by GM Yoda
Luke Skywalker in the novels is a lot weaker than he is in the comics.

In which comics, and in which Novels?
Also, his best feats copme from Novels, lol.

It makes no sense that a Vong warrior would be able to defeat a superhuman warrior that can jump dozens of meters in a single leap and break apart super battle droids with his fists, but somehow Shimrra challenges Jedi. I have no idea how, but hey, this is a universe where Cad Bane can fight Obi Wan.

Originally posted by The Ellimist
It makes no sense that a Vong warrior would be able to defeat a superhuman warrior that can jump dozens of meters in a single leap and break apart super battle droids with his fists, but somehow Shimrra challenges Jedi. I have no idea how, but hey, this is a universe where Cad Bane can fight Obi Wan.

Shimrra is very different from Normal Vong, tho.
Honestly, out off all supernational species in SW, the Vong are imho the ones with the best description/Idea/etc.