Mace Windu vs Supreme Overlord Shimrra

Started by GM Yoda2 pages
GM Yoda Senior Member

Originally posted by Ursumeles
In which comics, and in which Novels?
Also, his best feats copme from Novels, lol.

One example: Luke Skywalker took down an Imperial Walker in the comics, but couldn't take down a single droideka single-handedly in Survivor's Quest.

Ursumeles Traitor

Originally posted by GM Yoda
One example: Luke Skywalker took down an Imperial Walker in the comics, but couldn't take down a single droideka single-handedly in Survivor's Quest.

LMFAO.
You use an low showing?
The Dovin Basal feat, ragdolling Caedus, or being described at the very essence of an immovable object who can't be moved by the black hole at the center of the galaxy, hell, maybe even throwing an Shuttle just by blinking at it is better than this feat.

GM Yoda Senior Member

Originally posted by Ursumeles
LMFAO.
You use an low showing?
The Dovin Basal feat
How much power does it require to manipulate a dovin basal? A dovin basal is after all a micro-black hole.
being described at the very essence of an immovable object who can't be moved by the black hole at the center of the galaxy
which is impossible.
maybe even throwing an Shuttle just by blinking at it is better than this feat
The impressiveness of this feat is dependent on the size of the shuttle.

And two of the above feats are not combat feats.

Ursumeles Traitor

Taking down an Imperial Walker isn´t a combat feat either.
Like I said, ragdolling Caedus.

GM Yoda Senior Member

Taking down an Imperial Walker isn´t a combat feat either.
By 'take down" I meant destroy/defeat.
Like I said, ragdolling Caedus.
One of the reasons why he could ragdoll Caedus was because Caedus was taken by surprise.
And what are Caedus' greatest feats in the novels?

Ursumeles Traitor

Originally posted by GM Yoda
By 'take down" I meant destroy/defeat.
One of the reasons why he could ragdoll Caedus was because Caedus was taken by surprise.
And what are Caedus' greatest feats in the novels?

Destroying Vaders fortress >>
Luke did this without gesturing, and Caedus couldn´t free himself.
Oneshotting Vergere, while enraged and nearly 15 years pre-prime, should be up there.

MythLord Diamond

Also collapsing a massive building is up there.

darthbane77 Senior Member

Shimrra

GM Yoda Senior Member

Destroying Vaders fortress
Which isn't a combat feat, unlike the situation where Luke had battled against the Imperial Walker. And Luke destroyed Vader's fortress by exploiting stress points of the structure of the fortress, not by raw power.
Oneshotting Vergere, while enraged and nearly 15 years pre-prime, should be up there.
And Jacen struggled against Aurra Sing.

MythLord Diamond
Originally posted by GM Yoda
Which isn't a combat feat, unlike the situation where Luke had battled against the Imperial Walker. And Luke destroyed Vader's fortress by exploiting stress points of the structure of the fortress, not by raw power.

Like it matters? He did it easily. And proof he simply exploited stress points? And even then, rebuilding said fortress and then later crushing it again to scatter it's pieces around a planet is more impressive than simply collapsing it.

Originally posted by GM Yoda
And Jacen struggled against Aurra Sing.

While holding back, being cheapshotted and exhausted? Context is important, you know.

GM Yoda Senior Member
Originally posted by MythLord
Like it matters? He did it easily. And proof he simply exploited stress points.

Extending his hands and his will, Luke found the points of greatest stress within the structure and pressed upon them, found the points of greatest fragility and sundered them.
The Ellimist The Shadow

You're missing the part where he still crushed it all to a swirl of dust, lifted all of that dust into the air at the same time, and threw it all into the sea.

cs_zoltan Senior Member
Originally posted by MythLord
While holding back, being cheapshotted and exhausted? Context is important, you know.

Lel

The Ellimist The Shadow
Originally posted by GM Yoda
Luke Skywalker in the novels is a lot weaker than he is in the comics.

His best feats; UnuThul, black holes, Vader's fortress, ragdolling Caedus, facing Abeloth, come from the novels.

GM Yoda Senior Member

Originally posted by The Ellimist
His best feats; UnuThul, black holes, Vader's fortress, ragdolling Caedus, facing Abeloth, come from the novels.
True, but by "weaker" I meant less proficient in combat.

GM Yoda Senior Member

Originally posted by The Ellimist
You're missing the part where he still crushed it all to a swirl of dust, lifted all of that dust into the air at the same time, and threw it all into the sea.
That's a really incredible feat in terms of raw power.

Deronn_solo King Yami

Mace Vaapad shits on him.