Greatest Death Ever

Started by Sin I AM4 pages

Originally posted by Henry_Pym
Gwen Stacey?

Can't believe she wasn't brought up.


You consider Gwen a memorable death?

Jean Grey needs a mention during the Phoenix Saga.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
You consider Gwen a memorable death?
That's one of the biggest deaths in comic history lol.

Originally posted by tkitna
Jean Grey needs a mention during the Phoenix Saga.

Was retconned being the actual Phoenix Force creating a perfect copy of Jean Grey while the real Jean Grey was healing somewhere(HOTMU).

Originally posted by Mindset
That's one of the biggest deaths in comic history lol.

meh

Originally posted by Sin I AM
meh
You'd have to read comics to understand the importance, I guess.

Originally posted by Juk3n
The family Red skull killed in Ultimate Avengers.

Cant be arsed to scan, basically a wife , a husband and a baby taken hostage, red skull tells wife to stab husband to death with scissors or he drops the baby out the window. Wife does it, Red Skull drops baby out the window, then henchmen proceed to rape the wife all night and then kill her.

Only one page in the book, but ****ing dark and sad shit.

If it makes you feel better, the wife is revealed to have survived. She was the Insect Queen during the Liberators invasion and she joined Fury's Black Ops squad as the reformed Red Wasp. In the aftermath of the Ultimate Red Skull story when he lies bedridden and helpless, she comes in and shoots him in the head.

Originally posted by ODG
If it makes you feel better, the wife is revealed to have survived. She was the Insect Queen during the Liberators invasion and she joined Fury's Black Ops squad as the reformed Red Wasp. In the aftermath of the Ultimate Red Skull story when he lies bedridden and helpless, she comes in and shoots him in the head.

As I was reading, I thought "why would that make ANYONE feel better?" Then I got to the end. Nice.

Not explicitly a death, as she didn't end up dying, but Kitty Pryde's at the time supposed death in the giant bullet at the tail end of Astonishing X-Men was very well executed and really got to me. The artistic depiction of her determination and pain juxtaposed to Emma's very real and rarely depicted sorrow was nothing short of "astonishing."

Originally posted by Insane Titan
Always liked Captain Marvells death with everyone stood around paying their respects.

👆

Originally posted by Igniz
Was retconned being the actual Phoenix Force creating a perfect copy of Jean Grey while the real Jean Grey was healing somewhere(HOTMU).

Yeah, but at the time it was a big deal, but your right.

Cap's death in the Earth X series, as he protects Marvell. It may have sullied with age some, but at the time, that one held more resonance with me than nearly any other death I'd read.

I'm sure I could come up with others, but it's late. I'll give it some thought.

I think everyone is starting to hit on a common note here: the death can't be cheapened by subsequent retcons.

And the Gwen Stacy and Jean Grey deaths unfortunately suffer from retcons.

I was thinking about Uncle Ben as it's very much a Greek tragedy in pulp comic form. But when you read Amazing Fantasy #15, it's off-panel and it isn't very well-foreshadowed or milked at all. I don't know if there's ever been a definitive re-telling of Uncle Ben's death.

For recent ones, I'ma go with my sig:

Originally posted by Henry_Pym
Gwen Stacey?

Can't believe she wasn't brought up.


She WAS brought up. On a web line. With a broken neck.

I'm going to hell for that one.

How about Odin dying,in the cleft that shut in the Surtur saga.back in about 87,that had me really upset.He said to his sons in my hands I give you the future,very sad.If you haven`t read it pick it up you younger fans!

1. The Death of Aztek-" Tell them I did my job"

2. The Death of Karate Kid

Originally posted by Digi
Cap's death in the Earth X series, as he protects Marvell. It may have sullied with age some, but at the time, that one held more resonance with me than nearly any other death I'd read.

I'm sure I could come up with others, but it's late. I'll give it some thought.

This is the WORST death in the history of comics!

Captain America, killed by MUTANT WEREWOLVES!!!

You disgust me!

This was from the Clone Saga i think.
Pete and Ben, one in the room one on the roof, both bawling...

I'd say Barry Allen but that really wasn't a death.

Because he came back, or some other reason?