SoR Revan, FE Malgus and HoT run a gauntlet
Top dogs of the TOR era run a gauntlet.
They are all at their peak. All others are also at their peak, unless specified otherwise.
Setting: Tatooine
No amp/prep time.
Who wins?
1. DoE Bane, Zannah and Kas'im
2. Durron, Jaina and Katarn
3. Krayt Reborn, Cade and Wyyrlok
4. Dooku, Mace and SoD Maul
5. RotJ Vader, Starkiller and TFU Shaak Ti
6. Plagueis, Tenebrous and Venamis
7. DE Sidious
Well obviously Zannah beats Revan and Bane beats Malgus. And vice versa. The HoT is much better than Kas'im but Kas'im is still good enough to last a decent amount of time. I suppose they might clear if she beats him before either of the other two fights finish but eh, the majority of team Bane is better.
Originally posted by Nephthys
Well obviously Zannah beats Revan and Bane beats Malgus. And vice versa.
Originally posted by Nephthys
The HoT is much better than Kas'im but Kas'im is still good enough to last a decent amount of time. I suppose they might clear if she beats him before either of the other two fights finish but eh, the majority of team Bane is better.
Yeah, but what if HoT goes up against Zannah or Bane. He's good enough to stall them while Revan/Malgus dominate Kas'im with the Force.
Revan can take Starkiller, Malgus is equal to or better than Vader and the Hero can beat Shaak Ti.
Revan can handle Marek's lightning and TK and can last in a duel against him well enough to win.
Malgus is basically Vader with lightning and without being crippled, but with less skill accolades and maybe worse strength.
And the Hero is stronger than Shaak Ti and more powerful overall.
Starkiller TKs frigates whilst tanking starship engines in orbit and is a miles better duelist than Revan. Vader is a better duelist than Malgus and is not overly outmatched in the Force as some believe, if Starkiller can only just defeat him despite his own vast powers then Malgus isn't accomplishing better or even the equal of that.
Shaak Ti is more than able to hold her own against HoT.
Vader has vastly superior telekinesis, skill, and physical strength to Malgus. But Ti just seems like a weak link to me, and would lose to any of the three for a majority. Shaak would lose faster to Hero due to being less skilled as a duelist, whereas, Vader/Malgus Revan/SK are all very close fights.
Originally posted by LadyKulvax
Starkiller TKs frigates whilst tanking starship engines in orbit and is a miles better duelist than Revan.
Starkiller is not unique at using his powers to influence movement of a Starship. Tulak Hord, Darth Nihilus and Darth Jadus have similar showings. To be honest, this is not a good argument. Starkiller's showings in this respect meant squat in a duel against Darth Vader.
Originally posted by LadyKulvax
Vader is a better duelist than Malgus and is not overly outmatched in the Force as some believe,
Originally posted by LadyKulvax
if Starkiller can only just defeat him despite his own vast powers then Malgus isn't accomplishing better or even the equal of that.
Originally posted by LadyKulvax
Shaak Ti is more than able to hold her own against HoT.
Hero of Tython have much superior accomplishments then Shaak Ti and is a prodigy with a lightsaber.
Originally posted by LadyKulvax
Starkiller TKs frigates whilst tanking starship engines in orbit and is a miles better duelist than Revan. Vader is a better duelist than Malgus and is not overly outmatched in the Force as some believe, if Starkiller can only just defeat him despite his own vast powers then Malgus isn't accomplishing better or even the equal of that.Shaak Ti is more than able to hold her own against HoT.
Revan TK's 4 powerful Force users at once, Starkiller had trouble with a single shadow guard. His feats are overexaggerated, he's probably only about Maul level. And Revan can reflect his lightning back at him easily and has numerous Force powers Marek doesn't.
Vader isn't outmatched, but Malgus' lightning is a decent advantage that gives him the win imo. It'll be enough to weaken Vader enough to beat him.