Superman vs Gauntlet EVERYONE CIS FREE

Originally posted by Stoic
I get that, but where is this soul? For me it seems like DS Sentry, Void, and Sentry are just cast off bodies, while Bob exist in some sort of null space as the puppeteer. I guess that we can look at it from different points of view? I'd really love for marvel to nail his powers down and make some sort of tangible sense. I've always thought of Sentry as an idea withing Bob's mind made solid while he disappeared into that white space that was visited by Emma, but now seeing the scans that you presented makes that idea less likely because we actually see Bob's physical body, unless that was also a construct of his making? Marvel should really attempt to make more sense of this character, because he's one of the more interesting ones out there.

If I am 100% honest I don't know. And I don't expect anyone on this board to give you a definitive answer because no such one exists.

You'd have to contact Paul Jenkins or Brian Michael Bendis to find this out. Nobody here knows.

The whole point is I think I see where your idea is coming from. It's like losing a piece to a 5000 piece puzzle and you have found that piece and now it fits.

I take the opinion that since as of now. There is a puzzle piece in that missing spot. But the puzzle piece is translucent. It isn't a full piece.

We have to look at what we see in the comics. In my opinion, what we see from Emma and Bob in the White Room is that that was created so that Bob could be calmed in times of crisis.

When one of his physical bodies is killed. Say like when Molecule Man obliterated him x times and when Morgana Le Fay dissipated him. There was nothing there. So where was this piece of ectoplasm?

I can't really say "It is in this place" (I know you aren't saying this to me).

We have to look at what is the most likely thing and for me at least is that it's floating around or near Sentry/Robert/Void to some extent. But exactly where I don't know.

But I see how the point you bring up is helpful to explain the missing puzzle piece.

We would have to assume that Bobs actual body itself is at least a psionic construct of himself at one point.

I don't think it always was since at one point he was a Homo Sapien in the purest sense. And even though he is still one as the Sentry. His whole being changed. It's a very interesting topic to discuss

(like you noted)

I just don't think many of the writers out there want to do it or just don't know enough about the character to do it.

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
If I am 100% honest I don't know. And I don't expect anyone on this board to give you a definitive answer because no such one exists.

You'd have to contact Paul Jenkins or Brian Michael Bendis to find this out. Nobody here knows.

The whole point is I think I see where your idea is coming from. It's like losing a piece to a 5000 piece puzzle and you have found that piece and now it fits.

I take the opinion that since as of now. There is a puzzle piece in that missing spot. But the puzzle piece is translucent. It isn't a full piece.

We have to look at what we see in the comics. In my opinion, what we see from Emma and Bob in the White Room is that that was created so that Bob could be calmed in times of crisis.

When one of his physical bodies is killed. Say like when Molecule Man obliterated him x times and when Morgana Le Fay dissipated him. There was nothing there. So where was this piece of ectoplasm?

I can't really say "It is in this place" (I know you aren't saying this to me).

We have to look at what is the most likely thing and for me at least is that it's floating around or near Sentry/Robert/Void to some extent. But exactly where I don't know.

But I see how the point you bring up is helpful to explain the missing puzzle piece.

We would have to assume that Bobs actual body itself is at least a psionic construct of himself at one point.

I don't think it always was since at one point he was a Homo Sapien in the purest sense. And even though he is still one as the Sentry. His whole being changed. It's a very interesting topic to discuss

(like you noted)

I just don't think many of the writers out there want to do it or just don't know enough about the character to do it.

Agreed. This is a little off topic, but if I were to write Sentry, I'd retcon several events. In order for him to make sense, I would actually have him create his own reality that he himself was the almighty (see The Matrix movie to get an idea). The Sentry, Void, DS Sentry, would be physical manifestations or cast off bodies/avatars that he would use to interact with the real world. They would be real, but not true biological beings, which would not be too far off from what we have now, and that is if what I am saying isn't exactly what they are doing or trying to portray. Anyway, back on topic; I have a difficult time believing that any character that can so easily over power Thor, and then throw him so hard that he ends up light years from where he is thrown, could be easily defeated. If Superman was able to win this fight, I don't think that he would be in any shape to do anything for a very long time.

Originally posted by One_Angry_Scot
I take the opinion that since as of now. There is a puzzle piece in that missing spot. But the puzzle piece is translucent. It isn't a full piece..

Originally posted by h1a8
Are you claiming that Sentry can't be sung out of existence? .

Pretty much. Look what happened with the Molecule Man and Morgan Le Fay.