Thor vs Hulk

Thor

Thor is more than strong enough to swing around Loki's weight, so DT is right, Thor is physically capable of replicating Hulk's attack. However swinging people around isn't really his style.

So while Thor could ragdoll Loki, he isn't likely to try.

^ Agreed. He'd be more likely to smack Loki down with Mjolnir.

Originally posted by Time-Immemorial
We never seen that type of fighting from Thor, I doubt he could rag doll him, He would need to use him hammer to stop him, thats just the way his powers work. Which is fine isn't it?

Literally just said that.

I know it's a semantic argument, but you said that you doubted that he could, what you seem to have meant is that you doubt he would.

I just dont see that type of feat, but we agree he will use the hammer. I asked you earlier if you thought Thor could stop the LV the way hulk did with just his fist, but I never heard back from you. I was trying to gauge where you thought his dynamic strength was.

I think the Hulk is stronger, but that Thor can cause far more damage with a charged hammer strike.

That said, ragdolling a couple hundred pounds doesn't really take that much strength. hell, these days Cap could likely ragdoll someone that heavy.

Cool👆

Originally posted by quanchi112
Hulk was able to gain the upper hand on his own and looked to be superior by fights end. Thor wasn't on deaths door but the portrayal has always been clear. Hulk is the badass on the team.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Fanboyism at its finest.

Originally posted by Adam Grimes

Movie Thor's Resume:

Thor 1 - Thor (when he was Thor) was pretty much unstoppable. Probably his best showing from physical standpoint. He also fairly easily defeated The Destroyer Armor (while showing his versatility in the process).

Thor 2- Not a great showing for Thor, though he did survive an ugly beatdown from Kurse, and also endured Malekith's aether energy storm around him.

Avengers 1 - Thor again was dumbed/powered way down here, but still was impressive. He tried reasoning with Hulk and stalemated him long enough for the pilot to take the aggro (thus getting hulk off the hellicarrier). He also fought an amped 400% power Iron man and took 0 damage basically. He showed off how powerful his lightning could be as well by destroying a fleet of Chutari with one attack.

Avengers 2- One of Thor's best feats. He destroys the entire Sokovia meteor with one charged attack, obliterating it to save the planet. He is also the one Avenger that Ultron knew he had to single out and take by himself.

Now Movie Hulk:

Avengers 1: A mindless Hulk fights Thor and is slightly winning; though Thor was obviously holding back and trying to reason with Hulk. Hulk is also rampaging at the end of the movie and being physically dominant against Chutari and Loki alike.

Avengers 2: Again a mindless version of Hulk loses to Iron Man. Granted Iron man had "Veronica" (Hulkbuster) armor on, but it's still a bad showing for Hulk. Hulk should have won but the power of RDJ is too great. Hulk does look impressive the rest of the movie however.

THE VERDICT: Thor, as usual; if he tries to just punch Hulk to submission he's going to lose. IF, however, he uses his abilities he will win every time. That being said, Thor loves fisticuffs so I'm going to give them about a 50/50, or slight edge to Thor based on the fact his high end feats are higher.

Originally posted by quanchi112
So you can't grasp a film. I always kind of sensed your intellectual learning disabilities but this definitely confirms them.

Originally posted by CPT Space Bomb
Movie Thor's Resume:

Thor 1 - Thor (when he was Thor) was pretty much unstoppable. Probably his best showing from physical standpoint. He also fairly easily defeated The Destroyer Armor (while showing his versatility in the process).

Thor 2- Not a great showing for Thor, though he did survive an ugly beatdown from Kurse, and also endured Malekith's aether energy storm around him.

Avengers 1 - Thor again was dumbed/powered way down here, but still was impressive. He tried reasoning with Hulk and stalemated him long enough for the pilot to take the aggro (thus getting hulk off the hellicarrier). He also fought an amped 400% power Iron man and took 0 damage basically. He showed off how powerful his lightning could be as well by destroying a fleet of Chutari with one attack.

Avengers 2- One of Thor's best feats. He destroys the entire Sokovia meteor with one charged attack, obliterating it to save the planet. He is also the one Avenger that Ultron knew he had to single out and take by himself.

Now Movie Hulk:

Avengers 1: A mindless Hulk fights Thor and is slightly winning; though Thor was obviously holding back and trying to reason with Hulk. Hulk is also rampaging at the end of the movie and being physically dominant against Chutari and Loki alike.

Avengers 2: Again a mindless version of Hulk loses to Iron Man. Granted Iron man had "Veronica" (Hulkbuster) armor on, but it's still a bad showing for Hulk. Hulk should have won but the power of RDJ is too great. Hulk does look impressive the rest of the movie however.

THE VERDICT: Thor, as usual; if he tries to just punch Hulk to submission he's going to lose. IF, however, he uses his abilities he will win every time. That being said, Thor loves fisticuffs so I'm going to give them about a 50/50, or slight edge to Thor based on the fact his high end feats are higher.

You left out Hulk's solo film

Originally posted by juggerman
You left out Hulk's solo film

In any case, it's not a great showing for Hulk; but it really doesn't hurt his resume too much either..

Originally posted by Adam Grimes
Do you ever get tired of being wrong, quanbuddy?

You're quite ridiculous yourself, though.

Originally posted by Adam Grimes
You're quite ridiculous yourself, though.

If you're done with your goofy posturing, how does Hulk win then?

Originally posted by Adam Grimes
If you're done with your goofy posturing, how does Hulk win then?

Originally posted by quanchi112
Beating the shit out of him. If you'll recall when they fought he had the upper hand when the fighter jet started shooting the Hulk.