Starkiller vs. DE Luke Skywalker

Started by carthage3 pages

Starkiller vs. DE Luke Skywalker

Round 1: Lightsabers only

Round 2: All out fight

DE Luke

DE Luke

DE Luke.

WHO WINS

^ Luke shitstomps him.

Luke takes sabers. All out is debatable.

^ lol

🙂

Starkiller is nothing next to TFU Sidious.

DE Sidious acknowledges that Luke would give him a fight.

Would have to disagree there.

Pretending to troll to mask the fact that you couldn't muster an argument even if you tried. Cliched defense mechanism. *Yawn*

I'm neither pretending nor trolling. Just trying to be polite.

Imo Galen has shown himself to be significantly more powerful and while I would agree the DE Luke is a superior duelist I wouldn't say the gap between them is insurmountable which is why I don't believe Luke stomps if he wins at all.

Originally posted by Syndicate
I'm neither pretending nor trolling. Just trying to be polite.

A new look from you.


Imo Galen has shown himself to be significantly more powerful

He was "no match" for the Emperor. Luke was, by Palpatine's own admission. Luke also downed an AT-AT. There's no reason to think that Galen is even as powerful as Luke, let alone "significantly more[so]".


and while I would agree the DE Luke is a superior duelist I wouldn't say the gap between them is insurmountable which is why I don't believe Luke stomps if he wins at all.

Luke is already a superior duelist to Galen by RotJ. It's a common plot point of Dark Empire that Skywalker's grown significantly more powerful since the Emperor's death.

Don't know what you mean by that. I only respond to someone the same I'm treated.

Galen casually downs an ATAT then goes on to defeat Vader and then exchange force attacks with Sidious.

He also has feats far greater feats then simply downing an ATAT such as destroying the supports of an orbital superstructure, powering an ore cannon that pierced through a Star Destroyer, clearing a platform of an Imperial army and casually blasting hundreds of droids.

I would have to disagree there. Granted and I stated that Luke is probably the superior duelist. I'm simply stating I don't believe the disparity to be so great to be insurmountable.

Luke wins.

Luke legitimately challenged a more powerful iteration of Sheev than the one faced by 'Killer. Luke may not stomp, but he definitely wins.

Galen says himself that Sidious is toying with him. Excepting his oneness esque final moments, the SW database is reasonable in concluding that he's "no match" for the Emperor.

Originally posted by Syndicate
Don't know what you mean by that. I only respond to someone the same I'm treated.

Galen casually downs an ATAT then goes on to defeat Vader and then exchange force attacks with Sidious.

He also has feats far greater feats then simply downing an ATAT such as destroying the supports of an orbital superstructure, powering an ore cannon that pierced through a Star Destroyer, clearing a platform of an Imperial army and casually blasting hundreds of droids.

I would have to disagree there. Granted and I stated that Luke is probably the superior duelist. I'm simply stating I don't believe the disparity to be so great to be insurmountable.

The DS ending makes it clear as day Sheev was toying with him the whole time.

Originally posted by Syndicate
Don't know what you mean by that. I only respond to someone the same I'm treated.

Galen casually downs an ATAT then goes on to defeat Vader and then exchange force attacks with Sidious.

He also has feats far greater feats then simply downing an ATAT such as destroying the supports of an orbital superstructure, powering an ore cannon that pierced through a Star Destroyer, clearing a platform of an Imperial army and casually blasting hundreds of droids.

I would have to disagree there. Granted and I stated that Luke is probably the superior duelist. I'm simply stating I don't believe the disparity to be so great to be insurmountable.

Now Syndicate, be reasonable. We all know Palpatine was just goofing around and let Marek throw him around just to taunt him so he can fall to the Dark Side. Also, DE Luke brought down Imperial Walkers and deflected blows from them, plus he's rivalling a superoir Vader as of Return of the Jedi already... nevermind a Luke that improves nine years later.

He'll stomp every round.