Blue Marvel vs Byrne era Superman

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Not a single excuse since nothing is lackluster.

Yes.

Originally posted by deathslash
that very same Superman got knocked out by standing next to a gas station when it blew up so.........

Originally posted by deathslash
also got kicked through a house and was out of it long enough for Doomsday to knock out booster, walk in the house, crack Ice's ribs, and nearly kill the family. 👆

Blue Marvel will be beaten black and blue and will earn his title here.

Did he hit him anytime before that single punch or was that the only punch shown in that fight.

Not as if Doomsday doesn't have a healing factor...

I see that Dark post after almost 90% of my posts.

Originally posted by carver9
Did he hit him anytime before that single punch or was that the only punch shown in that fight.

Originally posted by abhilegend
Doomsday was shrugging off everything before that.

He obviously wasn't shrugging it off if it took one punch to take him out when he became stronger.

Originally posted by carver9
I see that Dark post after almost 90% of my posts.

Bottomless well of idiocy. 90% of your posts are garbage.

Originally posted by carver9
He obviously wasn't shrugging it off if it took one punch to take him out when he became stronger.

Case in point.

Originally posted by TheHulkster
He has not taken the bulk of his punishment by that point and much of the fighting up to that point involves Superman fighting alongside the JLA. There is little indication of Superman being physically worn when the explosion happens IMO.

I have read the story several times.

Fact is DD steamrolled the JLA with one hand and supes and maxima were the only two characters capable of keeping up the fight with DD wich did take it's toll on both Maxima and Superman.
In fact IIRC Maxima got her ribs broken after all this and Maxima had some ubber feats under Jurgens. So yes I am comfortable saying that it was an accumulation of all this circumstances.
Now I would like to know what other hero can take this punishment with DD tank DD punches, Maxima haymakers and still stay on one piece? Certantly there are not too many of them.

Originally posted by deathslash
also got kicked through a house and was out of it long enough for Doomsday to knock out booster, walk in the house, crack Ice's ribs, and nearly kill the family. 👆

And this is Doomsday we are talking about. Doomsday is not a walk in the park.

Just tanking a Doomsday punch like nothing speaks volumes of Byrne Superman.

Please show me a marvel character doing something similar. I think the closest will be SS tanking that she hulk punch but that is still way low of Superman tanking this DD punch.

Originally posted by carver9
He obviously wasn't shrugging it off if it took one punch to take him out when he became stronger.

I would like to see how many marvel characters can tank a punch of a Doomsday level character like Byrne Superman did.

Or maybe fighting pc kryptonian level characters

Please show scans

Superman.

Originally posted by Rao Kal El
And this is Doomsday we are talking about. Doomsday is not a walk in the park.

Just tanking a Doomsday punch like nothing speaks volumes of Byrne Superman.

Please show me a marvel character doing something similar. I think the closest will be SS tanking that she hulk punch but that is still way low of Superman tanking this DD punch.

Not trying to take anything away from Superman, but Jesus, getting knocked through a house vs getting knocked into orbit (and only stopping because you hit a satellite); which one seems more impressive to you?

Originally posted by Rao Kal El
I would like to see how many marvel characters can tank a punch of a Doomsday level character like Byrne Superman did.

Or maybe fighting pc kryptonian level characters

Please show scans

Maybe Busiek's Nefaria. I do think that the clear implication is that Doomsday underestimates the force necessary to hurt Superman and subsequently puts more into every blow. Thus, every blow after than hurts Superman. So more than one character could take that particular blow, yet not take the more forceful blows delivered after.

I believe that if the gas station scene was absent, no one would be arguing that Superman is worn out at that point. There simply is no indication of it.

Originally posted by deathslash
not saying that BM wins, but Doomsday's only feats up until that punch consisted of him beating a peak human nearly to death (which is hilarious considering that Doomsday doesn't hold back and with proper medical attention, Beatle made a full recovery), knocking Martian manhunter back (amid a field of fire btw), and beating guy Gardner (who didn't even have his shields up (lol)).

Not trying to take anything away from Superman, but Jesus, getting knocked through a house vs getting knocked into orbit (and only stopping because you hit a satellite); which one seems more impressive to you?

Maybe you should check Doomdday year one.

Originally posted by deathslash
not saying that BM wins, but Doomsday's only feats up until that punch consisted of him beating a peak human nearly to death (which is hilarious considering that Doomsday doesn't hold back and with proper medical attention, Beatle made a full recovery), knocking Martian manhunter back (amid a field of fire btw), and beating guy Gardner (who didn't even have his shields up (lol)).

Not trying to take anything away from Superman, but Jesus, getting knocked through a house vs getting knocked into orbit (and only stopping because you hit a satellite); which one seems more impressive to you?

You beat me to the punch. He didn't even kill Booster and no one here can say Doomsday holds back.

Originally posted by TheHulkster
Maybe Busiek's Nefaria. I do think that the clear implication is that Doomsday underestimates the force necessary to hurt Superman and subsequently puts more into every blow. Thus, every blow after than hurts Superman. So more than one character could take that particular blow, yet not take the more forceful blows delivered after.

I believe that if the gas station scene was absent, no one would be arguing that Superman is worn out at that point. There simply is no indication of it.

Actually Doomsday has Dynamic strength based on his evolution factor.

Meaning that he becomes stronger with each revival and that his strength increases on the fly.

At this time DD had already under his belt defeated several GL's, a Guardian (stealmeate) and was already inmune to Radiants 1/5 of Kalaton's wasteland buster.

Superman had already survived Almerac's core under the same writer. Using logic that will mean that Jurgens thinks that a gas station explosion is >>>>>>>>> The core of a planet

Or that superman got KO by the cumulation of attacks he received. Take your pick. It's up to you. I pick the most logical one.

Oh and that was a good showing for classic Nefaria. Thanks for sharing.

Originally posted by carver9
You beat me to the punch. He didn't even kill Booster and no one here can say Doomsday holds back.

He also didn't kill Blue Bettle. Therefore Blue bettle >>>>>>>>Superman 😂

Trying to lowball superman or dd is not going to work

Please also mind that I said Byrne Superman has the feats to grant a victory in here.

Never said if he will win or lose, but certantly has the feats to justify a victory in here.

Originally posted by Philosophía
bump.

A year has passed. Can Blue Marvel compete?