Vader in Rogue One

Started by quanchi11221 pages
quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Rebel95
Maul died as a failure of a sith, lol
Maul was on his own and did what Vader could not do with the resources of a galactic regime: Draw Kenobi out. Maul died a Sith death whereas Vader became Anakin abandoning the Sith. Pussy.

Rebel95 Senior Member
Originally posted by Rebel95
Not even worthy of being Sidious' apprentice. He chose a cripple over him. Pathetic
quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Rebel95
Maul defied him long before Anakin became his apprentice. Aren't you familiar with the characters ??

😂

Rebel95 Senior Member

Maul was a pussy and acted like he did everything for Sidious. Sidious saw through that and killed savage and took Maul captive. He could've taken him in as his apprentice again but he didn't, because Maul was weak. Lol

Bashar Teg Senior Mentat

they were both failures. that's the whole point of a villain in traditional story telling. their end-purpose for being created is to fail.

Rebel95 Senior Member

Vader failed as a villain yeah. But he destroyed the sith which is far more impressive than anything maul has ever done

Bashar Teg Senior Mentat

the most successful villain was ben kenobi. what a POS he was.

guy fails to kill his mortal enemy, so he cooks up this zero-chill revenge scheme with yoda to train the guy's own son to kill him, while lying and manipulating said son to believe that he was killing his father's murderer. his thirst for vengeance is so powerful that he cheats death to continue encouraging son to kill father.

and he won!

Rebel95 Senior Member

Yep Kenobi is the GOAT

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Rebel95
Maul was a pussy and acted like he did everything for Sidious. Sidious saw through that and killed savage and took Maul captive. He could've taken him in as his apprentice again but he didn't, because Maul was weak. Lol
So you admit Maul was his own man and tried to deceive Sidious. This wasn't the first time. Maul broke free from his captivity and was against Sidious. He never stopped hating him. Sidious chose the traitor who killed him who was a Jedi underneath it all. Palpatine was stupid.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Rebel95
Vader failed as a villain yeah. But he destroyed the sith which is far more impressive than anything maul has ever done
So he died a good guys a Jedi not a bad guy. He was emotionally weak and vulnerable hence his initial fall to the dark side. He wasn't a Sith but was seduced there by Palpatine. Maul was always a bad guy with or without Sidious.

queeq Chaos
Originally posted by Rebel95
Vader failed as a villain yeah. But he destroyed the sith which is far more impressive than anything maul has ever done

In the end, Luke is the true chosen one!

Beniboybling Worst Member

I watched this and thought of you guys:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DW7_syufbVc

🙂

JediRobin23 Somewhat Liberal

Originally posted by Beniboybling
I watched this and thought of you guys:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DW7_syufbVc

🙂

He based everything on the 'only?' reference he had was leia inserting the disc in R2?.......

He should have actually watched ANH and listened to 'ALL' the dialogue.....

Originally posted by queeq
In the end, Luke is the true chosen one!

Vader was the real chosen one!......

Darth Thor Senior Member

Originally posted by Bashar Teg
they were both failures. that's the whole point of a villain in traditional story telling. their end-purpose for being created is to fail.

And to make our heroes look good.

queeq Chaos
Originally posted by JediRobin23
Vader was the real chosen one!......

So some loser Jedi say in the PT... but I know better. 😈

JediRobin23 Somewhat Liberal
Originally posted by queeq
So some loser Jedi say in the PT... but I know better. 😈

Loser Jedi? You mean Mace? Yoda? Quigon?

Wouldn't call them that. Would just say the prophecy was misread....

queeq Chaos

They all lost, didn't they?

And yes, misread. Making Luke the real Chosen One. After all, he was the one that resisted the temptation of the Dark Side after first using it to defeat Vader. He showed his daddy the way.

Bashar Teg Senior Mentat

Originally posted by queeq
They all lost, didn't they?

And yes, misread. Making Luke the real Chosen One. After all, he was the one that resisted the temptation of the Dark Side after first using it to defeat Vader. He showed his daddy the way.

it could be argued that luke was the catalyst for anakin fulfilling his destiny at last. while luke was the one who took the risk, it was still left to vader to decide.

then again i am truly sick of the tired old "chosen one" plot device and hope we never hear reference to it in any future episodes.

JediRobin23 Somewhat Liberal
Originally posted by Bashar Teg
it could be argued that luke was the catalyst for anakin fulfilling his destiny at last. while luke was the one who took the risk, it was still left to vader to decide.

👆

coolmovies Senior Member

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DW7_syufbVc

It could very well be the best scene in Rogue One: A Star Wars Story— Darth Vader violently pursuing rebels as they try to escape with the Death Star plans. But, as Director Gareth Edwards reveals, the scene fans saw in theaters almost didn't happen