Bane/Batman (Nolan)vs. John Wick/Daredevil (Netflix)

Started by carthage3 pages

Bane/Batman (Nolan)vs. John Wick/Daredevil (Netflix)

*h2h only

Fight takes place on neutra ground

T1

team one

facepalm Team 1

Because this is pure H2H, Wick is the weak link IMO, so going to give team 1 a majority.

Are you guys serious? Wick is pretty much a non factor, but Daredevil would solo both Bane and Bats.

Well, I assume Batman is in his suit, so can soak up some damage. I would put Daredevil above either Batman or Bane solo, but not sure he could win 2 on 1. Though I suppose an argument could potentially be made for DD taking Bane out quickly, considering his senses would allow him to most likely detect Bane's mask weakness from the start. And Matt would go for that. He might not kill, but he has no problem maiming people.

DD's suit at the end of season 1 was padded and armor-like to soak up damage as well.

Originally posted by Lestov16
Are you guys serious? Wick is pretty much a non factor, but Daredevil would solo both Bane and Bats.
This

Though I don't know about Wick being a non factor. The dude was a beast from what I remember. Still, I cant remember any hand to hand only scenes. He was an artist with guns, but that unfortunately makes him featless

Anyway, team 2 wins. DD is above both Bats and Bane.

Originally posted by Arachnid1
This

Though I don't know about Wick being a non factor. The dude was a beast from what I remember. Still, I cant remember any hand to hand only scenes. He was an artist with guns, but that unfortunately makes him featless

Anyway, team 2 wins. DD is above both Bats and Bane.

Then you don't really remember correctly, Wick got his ass beat in H2H by someone far less then bane and barely beat that old man at the end.

Bane breaks his back.

Originally posted by Time-Immemorial
Then you don't really remember correctly, Wick got his ass beat in H2H by someone far less then bane and barely beat that old man at the end.

Bane breaks his back.

Like I said, I cant remember the hand to hand scenes if there were any. It's been too long since I've watched it

I'll take your word for it though

Here is wick showing some H2H skills

YouTube video

Here he is fighting with his hands tied together after he was tied up in a chair.

YouTube video

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

It had been a while since I watched John Wick. After getting a refresher that Wick isn't just all gun skills , I have to side with team 2 for the majority.
Some of the goons wick beat up or was fighting show more skill and speed than Bane or Baleman ever did.

Originally posted by Inhuman
It had been a while since I watched John Wick. After getting a refresher that Wick isn't just all gun skills , I have to side with team 2 for the majority.
Some of the goons wick beat up or was fighting show more skill and speed than Bane or Baleman ever did.
There's the absolute beast I remember. That scene where he beat the toughest combatant in the entire movie with his hands tied says everything. I doubt Bats could replicate that.

The other scene is still mostly him wrecking house with a gun though. While he likely could take Bats or Bane, he still didn't have enough overall hand to hand feats for me to back that up.

Despite that, team 2 still gets it 9/10

Originally posted by Inhuman
Here is wick showing some H2H skills

YouTube video

At min 6:20, he absolutely gets murder stomped by some thug and then tossed over the rail onto the dance floor.

Bane kills him instantly via back breaker.

Originally posted by Time-Immemorial
At min 6:20, he absolutely gets murder stomped by some thug and then tossed over the rail onto the dance floor.

Bane kills him instantly via back breaker.

You mean after he gets shot twice in the chest? 5:47 (even if he was wearing a bullet proof vest, that shit would hurt)

He took out the same guy with his hands tied together in that second clip i posted.

Dude, he can't do anything to Bane, so cut it out. Bane killed someone with one hand, and broke through concrete with ease. Even Alfred said Bane was a monster like he had never seen.

Originally posted by Time-Immemorial
Dude, he can't do anything to Bane, so cut it out. Bane killed someone with one hand, and broke through concrete with ease. Even Alfred said Bane was a monster like he had never seen.

Without getting into all that...
All I'm saying is that Team 2 takes the majority.
I think Team 2 skill and speed advantage trumps Teams 1 strength and armor advantage. Although daredevils suit is armored as well. And John is wearing a bullet proof vest. Don't know if that helps in this fight or not.

Baleman was doing well against Bane once he was healthy and ready to fight.
And Baleman isn't the most skilled or fast fighters around.

They have no way to take down Batman with all his gear, and Bane is an absolute monster.

Bane killed a random thug of no note who wasn't even fighting back with one hand.

Wick beat the toughest and most skilled bad guy in the entire movie with his hands tied.

Bane is stronger, sure, but the skill gap between Wick and Bane is huge. Wick kills him and Bats in that department

Who was the toughest guy he fought, and how does he even remotely compared to batman, who Bane bested easily the first time they fought. There is no way for Wick to even hurt bane. The only reason Bat took him down was cause he has armored gauntlets and knew his weakness.

You think Wicks bare knuckles would even do anything to his mask, if you do, you are kidding yourself.