Not really. I re-watched the movie a few days ago.
Kylo consistently had a problem where he'd knock his foes back, but they'd have time to recover because he had to pause and recover thanks to his wound. He was consistently able to put them on the back foot and throw them off-balance, but unable to press any advantage he made, and even so, still pushed Rey up to the side of the chasm.
Rey's defense, basically, sucked. Once she turned to the force, she was able to overwhelm Kylo with offense- again his lack of maneuverability from the wound hindering him- but at that point she wasn't defending from his attacks, she just took advantage that he gave her another breather to go on the offense.
Luke, if he's attacked, can defend and back up without leaving the big openings because he doesn't have a hole in his side, so if she does the same thing, he can weather it without taking damage. In return, Rey has not shown anything like the defense needed to stop his attacks.
Originally posted by Q99
Not really. I re-watched the movie a few days ago.Kylo consistently had a problem where he'd knock his foes back, but they'd have time to recover because he had to pause and recover thanks to his wound. He was consistently able to put them on the back foot and throw them off-balance, but unable to press any advantage he made, and even so, still pushed Rey up to the side of the chasm.
Rey's defense, basically, sucked. Once she turned to the force, she was able to overwhelm Kylo with offense- again his lack of maneuverability from the wound hindering him- but at that point she wasn't defending from his attacks, she just took advantage that he gave her another breather to go on the offense.
Luke, if he's attacked, can defend and back up without leaving the big openings because he doesn't have a hole in his side, so if she does the same thing, he can weather it without taking damage. In return, Rey has not shown anything like the defense needed to stop his attacks.
ESB Luke
"aww too easy perhaps you are not as strong as the emperor thought" - vader
luke lost. rey won.
rey did train using her stick.
luke also lost his hand. rey didn't.