ESB Luke vs TFA Rey

Started by The Merchant4 pages

Palpatine does have (near) Lightspeed reactions though. In the ROTS Novelization it's flat out told to us Anakin and Obi Wan out react to Tri fighters electronic reflexes which calculate stuff at the speed of Light. Magnaguards and Grievous are also stated to have electronic reflexes, although the Magnaguards are stated to have Near Lightspeed reflexes. This is all from the ROTS Novelization, which is 100% canon since none of those statements really conflict with what's shown in the movies.

But that's off topic, Luke wins. He was able to give a Vader a decent fight and even landed a hit on him.

Originally posted by The Merchant
Palpatine does have (near) Lightspeed reactions though. In the ROTS Novelization it's flat out told to us Anakin and Obi Wan out react to Tri fighters electronic reflexes which calculate stuff at the speed of Light. Magnaguards and Grievous are also stated to have electronic reflexes, although the Magnaguards are stated to have Near Lightspeed reflexes. This is all from the ROTS Novelization, which is 100% canon since none of those statements really conflict with what's shown in the movies.

But that's off topic, Luke wins. He was able to give a Vader a decent fight and even landed a hit on him.

is that canon?

all vader had to do was pick up palpy and toss him down

some reaction speed

Originally posted by redpill
is that canon?

all vader had to do was pick up palpy and toss him down

some reaction speed

😂

Well done.

Originally posted by Lord Stark
Is this a joke?
Yes

Originally posted by quanchi112
😂

Well done.

nuisance bird wanted us to fight. seems like we agree instead 😆 😆 😂 😂 🤣

Originally posted by redpill
nuisance bird wanted us to fight. seems like we agree instead 😆 😆 😂 😂 🤣
This bird seems like a real nuisance.

Originally posted by quanchi112
This bird seems like a real nuisance.
😂 😂 😂 🤣

sorry thenuissancebird but we and quanchi agree 😆

😂

Originally posted by The Merchant
Palpatine does have (near) Lightspeed reactions though. In the ROTS Novelization it's flat out told to us Anakin and Obi Wan out react to Tri fighters electronic reflexes which calculate stuff at the speed of Light. Magnaguards and Grievous are also stated to have electronic reflexes, although the Magnaguards are stated to have Near Lightspeed reflexes. This is all from the ROTS Novelization, which is 100% canon since none of those statements really conflict with what's shown in the movies.

But that's off topic, Luke wins. He was able to give a Vader a decent fight and even landed a hit on him.

Calculating stuff at the speed of light and actually doing it are two different things.

Luke wins this.
Being able to contend with Vader>>>beating an injured Kylo

Originally posted by Jmanghan
Calculating stuff at the speed of light and actually doing it are two different things.

*Very* different.

And heck, having lightspeed transmission medium.... btw, electronics aren't really lightspeed, going through matter slows electricity down... is much different than calculating in no time.

Which in turn, is slower than the actuators of a droid arm or muscles.

Originally posted by Rebel95
Luke wins this.
Being able to contend with Vader>>>beating an injured Kylo
Vader got tagged in the shoulder and Luke was an embarrassment in that film.

Dude started to lift an X-wing with only prior experience lifting medium sized stones, hardly call him an embarassment.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Dude started to lift an X-wing with only prior experience lifting medium sized stones, hardly call him an embarassment.
He failed like a chump.

The fact that he started to move an object with that much mass upwards at all on his first try moving something that big is pretty damn impressive. Never seen Khan move something that big have you?

Originally posted by Emperordmb
The fact that he started to move an object with that much mass upwards at all on his first try moving something that big is pretty damn impressive. Never seen Khan move something that big have you?
Khan designed the U.S.S. Vengeance which is far greater than that shitty x wing.

Originally posted by quanchi112
Khan designed the U.S.S. Vengeance which is far greater than that shitty x wing.

I don't see how this is relevant.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
The fact that he started to move an object with that much mass upwards at all on his first try moving something that big is pretty damn impressive. Never seen Khan move something that big have you?

He also moved several crates and R2 while upside down. He also showed bladework that even impressed Vader, showed deflecting objects with the Force and so on.

Post training with Yoda, I don't see him losing to Rey at all.

Originally posted by TheNuisanceBird
I don't see how this is relevant.
He wanted to compare whiny Luke to Khan and I did so.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Never seen Khan move something that big have you?
Khan sucks though. He's a loser that ran away from Spock.