Originally posted by Bentley
Well, then you could argue that their decision making is poorer because it's impulsive. Then we'd be assuming they are intelligent enough not to be the most intelligent they can be. Which is sort of where we are since we lie to ourselves terribly.It does tell us that reasonable decision making departs from instict.
Yes, that is because the idea of mass suicide as the end of a race's lifetime came to me from discussing with a poster who was a big promoter of humans becoming essentially AI. By becoming AI they are already commiting mass suicide, so I don't think the AI would have much of a motivation to continue its existence indefinitively. Up to a point, machine intelligence and organic beings are very different things.
However, suicide is something that happen very often with humans compared with less intelligent animals because we are conscious of our actions. It's a part of the life equation despite the many efforts our society makes to hide it as a shameful thing. The more open and intelligent we become, the better option suicide seems to be. At some point we will allow people to kill themselves freely.
Just by looking at us right now I can tell death plays a big part in our desire for eternity, so if we continue to play god with technology it's very likely to be one of our ends. Then again, we could stray from that path given the right conditioning, but as we stand I remain sceptic.
So you'd think less of them for not fully embracing cold, machine-like nihilistic logic and actually choosing to be happy? You know, there are people who fully recognize that life has no intrinsic meaning, but still remain happy.
Yeah, it sure does sometimes. Doesn't mean it's unreasonable to be happy.
Well, I believe that a sufficiently advanced AI could feel identical or very similar emotions and motivations to biological intelligences. So there's probably not a whole lot of difference there. The vast majority of people commit suicide due to psychological disturbances, not because they came to the conclusion that it's the best option through some sort of a philosophy. In fact, I think it's very telling that we can contemplate the meaninglessness of life without not only not immediately deciding to kill ourselves, but actually remaining happy.
What can I say: most of us are just not very comfortable with death.