Unorthodox Opinions

Shrugs the only Rule of Two Sith we know in Canon, besides Sheev and his apprentices, are Plagueis and Bane.

Yoda~Mace>=Palpatine. Yoda would have beaten Palpatine if the fight took place in a more neutral ground and/or the fight continued with no interference. Invisible Hand Anakin is close to Palpatine/Yoda/Mace.

I didn't like Shatterpoint that much.

It seemed kind of racist to me that Mace comes from the Black Person planet thats a huge jungle that makes him lose control because it's so "wild". Also his brother is a jungle man who tames animals and attacks outposts.

It was kind of awkward to read. Not sure I actually got through it.

I enjoyed Shatterpoint. But it was easily the worst SW novel of Stover's.

Oh also its utterly unbelievable that the most stilted, wooden, boring character in the entire trilogy is a secret badass who has rage problems, skirts the darkside and has trouble with controlling himself.

god that performance sucks

**** mace windu

Originally posted by Nephthys
It seemed kind of racist to me that Mace comes from the Black Person planet thats a huge jungle that makes him lose control because it's so "wild". Also his brother is a jungle man who tames animals and attacks outposts.

Oh also its utterly unbelievable that the most stilted, wooden, boring character in the entire trilogy is a secret badass who has rage problems, skirts the darkside and has trouble with controlling himself.

Originally posted by ares834
I enjoyed Shatterpoint. But it was easily the worst SW novel of Stover's.

Uh, no.

That dubious honor belongs to Shadows of Mindor.

The ranking of Stover Star Wars novels is as follows:

ROTS
Shatterpoint
Traitor

Shadows of Mindor

Shadows of Mindor was great. Just pure fun pulp. I loved it.

SoM was awesome, Temp. What are you talking about?

Shut your whore mouths, both of you.

He thinks Darth Plagueis sucks too. 🙄

I thought he liked it originally but his opinion on it lowered a second reading.

Originally posted by The Merchant
I thought he liked it originally but his opinion on it lowered a second reading.

👆

Originally posted by SunRazer
He thinks Darth Plagueis sucks too. 🙄

It's much like Anakin himself: it's not so much that it sucks, just that it sucks compared to what it could have been.

Pfft. A sin is a sin.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
It's much like Anakin himself: it's not so much that it sucks, just that it sucks compared to what it could have been.

Well, Anakin's still the strongest Jedi, so DP is still the strongest novel 🙂

Originally posted by SunRazer
Well, Anakin's still the strongest Jedi, so DP is still the strongest novel 🙂

That is genuinely disgusting. And this comes from someone who has every reason to give that book the benefit of the doubt and love it.

YDR shits all over DP. Even among Luceno's own works, TUF and COD are much better.

Currently in the process of rereading TUF now, actually.

Originally posted by The_Tempest
That is genuinely disgusting. And this comes from someone who has every reason to give that book the benefit of the doubt and love it.

YDR shits all over DP. Even among Luceno's own works, TUF and COD are much better.

Currently in the process of rereading TUF now, actually.

You know I don't have DP at the top. I was just following your train of thought 🙂

RotS is probably the best.

Originally posted by SunRazer
RotS is probably the best.

You misspelled YDR.

Nah, RotS is better.