Gideon runs the debating gauntlet

Started by JKBart6 pages

Caseiden > Tempest either way

Did Caseiden ever join KMC? Gideon's GOAT quotes are binding for anyone's debating level pre-2010.

Oh, wait, you said Tempest. Yeah, he's good, but not a GOAT contender; probably early DE hewhoknowsall level.

Caseiden one-shotted Skillz with Kenth Hamner & Valin Horn > Freedon Nadd and proceeded to an hero right after the debate not giving a fug

You can't really surpass that

Kek, I remember that. 🙂

That was an weakened SKILLZ 🙂

still best feat known to SW debating 🙂 🙂

Yeah, he totally didn't do that on a nexus, with respect threads or anything...

Without nexuses and respect threads he's Nai or Silver level at best.

EDIT: maybe I'm being a little harsh on him...but he's still not = Gideon. I'd say he's slightly below Tempest.

Nah, no respect threads, just full authorial analysis 🙂

I still can't believe he literally ended his own life

The world is lesser without him. 🙁

And to think he provided so much without even mastering English above google-translator-tier 🙁

Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZ
Kek, I remember that. 🙂

That was an weakened SKILLZ 🙂

What were you weakened by?

Originally posted by The Ellimist
Gideon was brilliance incarnate. It was like staring into the heart of Star Wars.

- Sidious666

lmao

Unleashing the full power of his hatred, he conjures a wall of text that threatens to dominate all of the internet, including the antediluvian fleet.

Gideon = internet-buster confirmed.

Originally posted by Nephthys
There's literally no way he gets past Nai. That man isn't human.

While I agree with the first sentence, I can't agree with the second one. Still profiled, though. 😉

Originally posted by The Ellimist
Meh, Nai strikes me as someone whose eloquence makes him sound much smarter than he actually is. Like nebaris, except obviously far greater.

That's quite ironic for three reasons.

1)
I'm not even utilizing my primary language here (that would be German).
That leads to the question: Doesn't mastering a second language to an extend, where my eloquence can make me look smarter than I am, require me to be rather smart in the first place?

2)
Eloquence and smartness aren't mutually exclusive. If anything, the opposite is the case. That doesn't mean that people can't use their talent in rhetorics for wrong reasons. And I'm not excluding myself from that line of inquisition.

3)
I wonder how I could have made that impression, provided we have never interacted. 😉

And back to the topic: Gideon would stop at Janus.

Nai's back?

Da hell am I(Wolfninjajedi) on the list for? I hardly debate.

Originally posted by Col. Valerian
Nai's back?

Have I ever been away?
My visits here have just become infrequent for various reasons.

Or is this some question regarding my reverse side?

Originally posted by Nai
Have I ever been away?
My visits here have just become infrequent for various reasons.

Or is this some question regarding my reverse side?

It definitely is regarding your reverse side. 🙂

Nah, make those visits frequent.

Originally posted by Nai
While I agree with the first sentence, I can't agree with the second one. Still profiled, though. 😉
Originally posted by Nai
And back to the topic: Gideon would stop at Janus.

Originally posted by Nai

1)
I'm not even utilizing my primary language here (that would be German).
That leads to the question: Doesn't mastering a second language to an extend, where my eloquence can make me look smarter than I am, require me to be rather smart in the first place?

2)
Eloquence and smartness aren't mutually exclusive. If anything, the opposite is the case. That doesn't mean that people can't use their talent in rhetorics for wrong reasons. And I'm not excluding myself from that line of inquisition.

Eloquence and intelligence are not mutually exclusive; they're probably positively correlated with one another. I just suggested that in your case, the former is disproportionately impressive to the latter. It doesn't mean you're stupid; TBH everyone here is probably at least smarter than average so we're all evaluating these terms by arbitrary reference points anyway.

Of course, I'm only guessing your intelligence through the quality of your arguments as a proxy, so maybe the former is disproportionately great to the latter. Or perhaps I'm biased because I'm a Sidious-is-the-strongest guy. Or maybe I was baiting you to see if you were still around. Beats me.


3)
I wonder how I could have made that impression, provided we have never interacted. 😉

Well, I am known as someone who knows all.


And back to the topic: Gideon would stop at Janus.

Janus is as much of an ******** as Gideon, but unlike his nemesis lacks the eloquence or debating ability to compensate.