Originally posted by cs_zoltan
I'm concerned. I think Legend has a brain tumour.
Here is another:
Jessiah Eberlin: I read in your interview with TFN that George was adamant about Plagueis’s death ending in a specific way. But I’m curious, do you feel that had it come to a contest of lightsabers or Force powers that Sidious would have prevailed anyway?
Luceno: Jessiah, if it had come to a duel, I think Plagueis may have found a way to undermine his apprentice.
😮💨
And if you had read the novel, you'd note Sidious experiencing a growth in power after he killed Plagueis. Plagueis might've been Sidious at that point, but once Sidious killed Plagueis, he surpassed him as well. Also, what Luceno "thinks" isn't canon - where multiple sourcebooks have stated that Palpatine killed Plagueis only after obtaining the skill and knowledge to do so.
That he chose a safe and insured avenue doesn't preclude the possibility of him (at that point) being able to beat Plagueis in a legitimate fight - something that would probably go either way, in my opinion. Regardless, after the event, Sidious grew more powerful and only continued to grow in power in the decades to come. Future iterations of Sidious would absolutely defeat Plagueis.
Originally posted by SunRazer
And if you had read the novel, you'd note Sidious experiencing a growth in power after he killed Plagueis. Plagueis might've been Sidious at that point, but once Sidious killed Plagueis, he surpassed him as well. Also, what Luceno "thinks" isn't canon - where multiple sourcebooks have stated that Palpatine killed Plagueis only after obtaining the skill and knowledge to do so.That he chose a safe and insured avenue doesn't preclude the possibility of him (at that point) being able to beat Plagueis in a legitimate fight - something that would probably go either way, in my opinion. Regardless, after the event, Sidious grew more powerful and only continued to grow in power in the decades to come. Future iterations of Sidious would absolutely defeat Plagueis.
I got you to do some critical thinking as an example.
Unfortunately, The_Ellimist is bereft of critical thinking.
Originally posted by MythLord
How does LeG even have the brain capacity to spell properly, I wonder.
Lmao, just vaguely responding to someone's argument, and sniping at someone else's, by saying "you lack critical thinking" isn't an actual rebuttal.
The Plagueis quote means Plagueis at some point in time was more powerful than any Sith who had lived up to his time. Sidious had lived to his time; but he hadn't reached his peak yet. This isn't even critical thinking - don't run before you can walk - this is just an understanding of the past perfect tense, kek.
Originally posted by The Ellimist
Lmao, just vaguely responding to someone's argument, and sniping at someone else's, by saying "you lack critical thinking" isn't an actual rebuttal.The Plagueis quote means Plagueis at some point in time was more powerful than any Sith who had lived up to his time. Sidious had lived to his time; but he hadn't reached his peak yet. This isn't even critical thinking - don't run before you can walk - this is just an understanding of the past perfect tense, kek.
Now, instead of questioning my assessment and making excuses, try to figure out what you are overlooking or missing in your assessment.
Originally posted by The Ellimist
roflmao, it's not my job to find your arguments for you.Try harder please. 👆
Critical thinking is not your cup of tea, my friend. 👆
The answer is crystal-clear to those who understand or do not have memory problems. You might recall it as well, if you were paying attention.