Originally posted by Petrus
Nah, she wouldn't. For all everyone's argued, the fact that Shaak struggles greatly against a pre-peak Galen [even with phucking Felucia aiding her] remains. Ahsoka doing a good job against Vader > what Shaak did against Galen.
Originally posted by XSUPREMEXSKILLZLMFAO
Read what Neph said, the comments right after, and rethink what you just said. 🙂
Originally posted by MythLord
Cutscenes and game mechanics =/= factual evidence.
The novel and the comic portray Shaak being Galen's equal/superior in both skill and power(the latter's debatable, but meh), so yeah...
Lol wut? The comic shows the environment aiding her ( describes it as an entire planet aiding her ) and still not being able to defeat Galen. She knocks him off balance once and hits him with a force energy attack that makes his clothes steam. The novel has her having to throw herself onto his blade to even land a hit on Galen.
Originally posted by NephthysHow? Ti had literally everything going for her and still failed to defeat Marek. She had an entire ****ing planet under her control. Ahsoka went up against a more powerful and easily more skilled opponent in Vader and did extremely well, and only "lost" due to environmental circumstances that caused a BFR. TK'ing Vader, who barrier'd that massive explosion on Malachor, is > Ti's telekinetic feats, or at least close enough that Ti won't be having any huge Force advantage, especially on neutral ground.
Also Ti's showing against Marek was far more impressive than Ahsokas and she's a far superior Force wielder.
Originally posted by |King Joker|
How? Ti had literally everything going for her and still failed to defeat Marek. She had an entire ****ing planet under her control. Ahsoka went up against a more powerful and easily more skilled opponent in Vader and did extremely well, and only "lost" due to environmental circumstances that caused a BFR. TK'ing Vader, who barrier'd that massive explosion on Malachor, is > Ti's telekinetic feats, or at least close enough that Ti won't be having any huge Force advantage, especially on neutral ground.
Joker I agree with everything you're saying here ( aside from the Force as I showed in my prior post ) where I take issue is that you think Ahsoka could beat Felucia Galen despite him ultimately winning against Shaak despite Shaak having an environmental advantage, the environment aiding her, the planet being a Light Side nexus and the darkness on it being stifles and Galen having just fought through an entire population of powerful force users to get to her.
Actually I'm not sure whether that was you or Beni. I get you two confused alot.
Was Vader really more powerful and skilled? Marek does wreck him in the end. You can say he improved and he probably did, but not enough that Ti dominating Marek in sabers isn't a better showing than Ahsoka getting smashed by Vader.
Mid-duel TKing someone doesn't mean much. Barris TK'd Anakin. Big whoop.
Originally posted by Petrus
Nah, she wouldn't. For all everyone's argued, the fact that Shaak struggles greatly against a pre-peak Galen [even with phucking Felucia aiding her] remains. Ahsoka doing a good job against Vader > what Shaak did against Galen.
That coming from someone who didn't even read the Galen - Shaak Ti fight until like an hour ago I concede.
Spoiler:
Not.
Originally posted by Beniboybling
>Assumes that isn't what one would expect using an exhaustive form against an "near perfect duelist" & Star Destroyer TK'er.kek indeed 🙂
Near perfect duelist is it? Hmmm, I recall Ahsoka wankers claiming like 2 pages back that early Galen sucks.
At least be consistent with each other 👆
Never mind the fact that force users can replenish mid combat and a nexus would grant her a huge pool of force reserves...
But this is something you argued for before, not that it surprises me that you change stance whenever it's convenient for you.
Also since when do people take prose so ****ing literally.
Believe it or not, Dooku didn't actually summon all the Dark Side energy in the galaxy. Vitiate isn't a god. Sidious isn't literally a shadow. Shaak Ti didn't have the entire planet under her control, believe me I'd love that to be the case more than most....
Originally posted by SyndicateI said that Tano could probably beat Marek under similar circumstances.
Joker I agree with everything you're saying here ( aside from the Force as I showed in my prior post ) where I take issue is that you think Ahsoka could beat Felucia Galen despite him ultimately winning against Shaak despite Shaak having an environmental advantage, the environment aiding her, the planet being a Light Side nexus and the darkness on it being stifles and Galen having just fought through an entire population of powerful force users to get to her.Actually I'm not sure whether that was you or Beni. I get you two confused alot.
Originally posted by Selenial
Also since when do people take prose so ****ing literally.Believe it or not, Dooku didn't actually summon all the Dark Side energy in the galaxy. Vitiate isn't a god. Sidious isn't literally a shadow. Shaak Ti didn't have the entire planet under her control, believe me I'd love that to be the case more than most....
👆
Originally posted by cs_zoltanLol.
Near perfect duelist is it? Hmmm, I recall Ahsoka wankers claiming like 2 pages back that early Galen sucks.At least be consistent with each other 👆
Never mind the fact that force users can replenish mid combat and a nexus would grant her a huge pool of force reserves...So many gratuitous implications of biased.But this is something you argued for before, not that it surprises me that you change stance whenever it's convenient for you.
Originally posted by SelenialWhich is why you'll notice I always employed " " in referencing it - I assume everyone else is on the same page. 😬
Also since when do people take prose so ****ing literally.Believe it or not, Dooku didn't actually summon all the Dark Side energy in the galaxy. Vitiate isn't a god. Sidious isn't literally a shadow. Shaak Ti didn't have the entire planet under her control, believe me I'd love that to be the case more than most....