Originally posted by Blue Area Vetno he doesn't. He has very impressive showings, but Stewart does have more showings and is one of the more consistent lanterns out there. Honestly, I don't think I could ever see any herald legal character outright stomping on a lantern, let alone John Stewart. It's a good fight and I could honestly see it going either way.
Are you kidding? Blue Marvel stomps.
Originally posted by leonidas
i'd take marvel. be interesting to see how john dealt with the anti-matter energy. if we assume bm's antimatter is the same as the dc version of antimatter, that probably wouldn't be good for john. antimatter tends to trump a lot of things in dc. oddly enough, i can't recall off-hand how a gl has fared against antimatter though. maybe someone has a scan to help out?
Originally posted by carver9
Blue Marvel stomps. Lanterns does not do well against high tier bricks. Blue Marvel 10/10.
We don't share feats. Not all Lanterns are the same. Not all high tier bricks are the same. What combat showings does BM have to make you give him such a high rating?
I ask for combat showings, because you are always ignoring non combat showings.
Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Ha. I wager that any one of the big guns - hell, maybe even the entire JLA - would have more appearances than BM.Only SHAZAM I think has had fewer appearances. Batman has more, Supes, WW, GL, Flash, even Aquaman and Cyborg have more appearances.
Heck, i've even asked that about being a member on MBs, this one included, when posters have said "you havent BEEN here long enough to say what you just did". Never gotten an answer to that one, either. 😆
Originally posted by riv6672
So are YOU willing to give me the magic number of appearances, feats feat appearances, that legitimizes a character?
I've asked before, but never gotten an answer.Heck, i've even asked that about being a member on MBs, this one included, when posters have said "you havent BEEN here long enough to say what you just did". Never gotten an answer to that one, either. 😆
The exact threshold? Nope. I am unable to do that - but my point remains.
DCnU Batman, WW, Superman, Cyborg, Aquaman et al, all have MORE appearances than BM, despite debuting a good few years after BM. For the purposes of this thread, John also has more appearances than BM.
As it stands, the amount needed is pretty subjective. But just remember Red Hulk as a guide.
When he first appeared, he was smacking things left right and center. Punched a Watcher out etc.
Then, he gathered more appearances, and gradually came down in power.