Lumiya vs Darth Zannah

1.) Naboo
2.) "The Home"
3.) Lake Natth

Lumiya should win in sabers and all-out, unless if it's on Ambria.

Lumiya probably takes sabers and makes the better Illusions. Zannah triumphs in all else.

How? Without her tendrils, her only shot is to try to break her mentally, and frankly I don't see conclusive evidence that she could do that, not when it failed against Bane and only worked on random, featless Jedi. Lumiya has illusions, and she has a weapon that Zannah is utterly unfamiliar with.

Zannah could probably ragdoll her, if she tried.

Zannah couldn't even ragdoll Rastka Lsu, lol.

Not sure what makes you say so; Zannah never fought Raskta. And it's not like ragdolling Lumiya should be much harder than ragdolling Raskta anyways.

Lumiya in melee.
Zannah in Force.
Not sure as of yet. Need to find out about Lumiya's own knowledge in Sith Sorcery and more importantly, illusions.

Originally posted by NewGuy01
Not sure what makes you say so; Zannah never fought Raskta. And it's not like ragdolling Lumiya should be much harder than ragdolling Raskta anyways.

Raskta was explicitly weak in the Force relative to other Jedi, meanwhile Lumiya seems to be pretty prominent; she was relatively well respected in the Empire, and then was knowledgeable enough in the Force for Caedus to accept her as a master.

This also comes down to how seriously you take her final performance against Luke.

Lumiya's noted to be incredibly weak in the Force, too; she's something like 90% machine. Apparently it's noted in Betrayal that Jacen could kill her at any time with TK, for what it's worth. For that matter, Jacen's irrelevant Jedi apprentice also stalemated her in a TK struggle iirc.

Huh, do you have a quote? Either way if that's true and in context, then Zannah could take all-out depending on how close they start.

Zannah takes all but sabers.

Originally posted by The Ellimist
Huh, do you have a quote?.

Here's the quote:

"Frowning, Jacen cast out his senses like a net, sampling the present and the future. Pathways led in all directions, but in each of them one of the three people present fell dying. Jacen, head severed by a pliant whip of light. Lumiya, Nelani’s lightsaber cutting her in half-lengthwise, so there was no chance of missing the organic parts. Nelani, her heart speared by Jacen’s lightsaber. Jacen, stabbed from behind by Ben, the boy’s uncomprehending features making it clear that he was seeing something very different from the reality before him. Lumiya, swept into a marble wall by Jacen’s control of the Force, her skull shattered-Jacen shut his eyes against the parade of tragedy."

-- Legacy of the Force: Betrayal

He's basically seeing all the possibilities that could happen and Jacen kills Lumiya with TK in one of them - he literally ragdolls her into a wall so hard that her skulls shatters.

Lumiya dies.

Ehhh...yeah, that hardly suggests Jacen would have killed her casually without a fight, and even if it did, he could've easily done that to Zannah too.

If Jacen could instakill her with TK, I really doubt they'd be much of a fight.

Where does it say it was an instakill?

In either case, Jacen could ragdoll Zannah. If he's not jobbing he could probably ragdoll Dooku.

It says that somebody died in each of the visions, and if Lumiya's skull was crushed, well, it ain't Jacen that's dead.

And you could show a vision where Sidious is begging for mercy below Windu, but that doesn't mean Windu one-shotted him.