Is "Cut Content", specifically TLSRCM, to be considered Canon?

Started by ares8349 pages

Lucasfilm hasn't directly endorsed or supported anything with TSLRCM.

Originally posted by ares834
Lucasfilm hasn't directly endorsed or supported anything with TSLRCM.

Uh...

http://steamcommunity.com/games/208580/announcements/detail/145589580847766181

😬

And? Aspyr didn't create the mod.

Originally posted by ares834
And? Aspyr didn't create the mod.

You rn.

😂

Yes, throw around gifs when you have no argument. Let me reiterate what I’ve repeatedly said. Lucasfilm has not directly endorsed or supported the mod.

So far, you've posted nothing to the contrary.

😂 I throw around gifs when I feel like a line has been crossed and gifs are required, not when I have no argument. Never have I 'thrown around' gifs for that particular reason, actually.

We can go back to the basics, if you like. How is Aspyr related to KOTOR II?

No. I’m not going to answer any irrelevant questions until you prove your claim that Lucasfilm directly supported or endorsed TSLRCM.

The simple fact is, they haven’t. You are wrong. Even Beni would agree with me there, though he would offer an argument (as he already has) for a non-direct form of endorsement through Aspyr which is an entirely different debate I have no interest in.

I'm unsure why are incapable of grasping this simple fact.

Do you realize I'm claiming the exact same thing as Beni?

Then when are you arguing with me when I repeatedly have said “directly”? And, for shits and giggles, where have you made such an argument?

Just go back and read the previous pages. I think there was a misunderstanding along the way. I have repeatedly said 'by extension', not directly.

"I am uninterested in discussing why my stance is wrong."

😂

Originally posted by Petrus
The fact that the content of the mod is actually endorsed and supported by Lucasfilm is a literal extension of the act of giving official support to the developers of the mod.
Originally posted by Petrus
And Ares, I said that Lucasfilm supporting the application of this mod to the game implies an extremely obvious [B]extension of support to the modders themselves. [/B]

😬

Not only are these two post contradictory (in the first you say Lucasfilm is “giving official support to the developers of the mod” thus this extends to the mod and in the second you say they “support the application of the mod” which then extends to the modders 😕 ), they are wrong. Lucasfillm has not directly supported either of those.

Originally posted by S W LeGenD
Where does LC state that anything they support/endorse is officially canon?
When describing the Holocron (which tracks continuity):
The Holocron is an internal database maintained by Lucas Licensing that tracks all the fictional elements created for the Star Wars universe. The database includes material from the films, books, comics, videogames, trading cards, roleplaying games, websites, toys, cartoons, and just about every officially sanctioned fictional element of the Star Wars universe.

(https://web.archive.org/web/20090123212139/http://forums.starwars.com/thread.jspa?threadID=152583)

erm

Not only are these two post contradictory (in the first you say Lucasfilm is “giving official support to the developers of the mod” thus this extends to the mod and in the second you say they “support the application of the mod” which then extends to the modders confused ), they are wrong. Lucasfillm has not directly supported either of those.

In the first post, I admittedly did not explain myself correctly, or phrased the meaning of my sentence wrong.

But in the second one, I'm not saying anything that isn't true. Lucasfilm does support the implementation of the mod by releasing the latest update in collaboration with Aspyr and Disney, which includes the TSLRCM. By working with Aspyr and Disney and by being responsible of the latest update of KOTOR II, they are supporting the mod and its creators. Lucasfilm does not have to go out and scream 'HEY GUYS, I officially endorse and support this' to make it obvious that they do. 😬

No. The update does not include the mod. It includes steam workshop support (which includes a lot of other mods) and Aspyr worked with modders to make sure TSLRCM was up on release. Lucasfilm never worked with TSLRCM nor supported them, only Aspyr did.

But whatever, if your point was what Beni's was fair enough. It just was not at all made clear in your posts.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
When describing the Holocron (which tracks continuity):

But you're in no way justified in claiming that LC had in mind anything LFL merely supports/endorses when talking about "just about every officially sanctioned fictional element of the Star Wars universe".