Darth Nihl vs. Plo Koon

Started by ILS3 pages

I'd need the context, haven't read that instance in a long time if at all.

Nihl choking Cade might've been brief, but Cade lost consciousness which is still more impressive than holding him longer with no effect at all.

Originally posted by ILS
I'd need the context, haven't read that instance in a long time if at all.

"He flicked his wrist, and Corran went sailing across the hangar back toward Kenth and the other Jedi. It was a particularly insulting dismissal, since Corran could not respond in kind, having never been able to master the skill of Force telekinesis.
The same was not true of Kenth Hamner. He extended his arm, and Kyp flew back against the hull of his StealthX and remained there, pinned."

Originally posted by ILS
If we're trying to mingle canon examples in with Legends, which I find to be a practice in futility a lot of the time,
I don't see what's so different from using Rebels and using TCW if you're talking about Legends, as they are both made by the same people and follow the same principles in regards to the Force / combat.

Originally posted by ILS
I would consider the option that at that moment, Kanan was just the stronger of the two. He clearly has greater inherent ability than the Inquisitor, by a long-shot, but on average he's outclassed due to far inferior training. He was desperate in the moment he pinned him because he cares about Ezra, so perhaps his true power shown through however briefly?
I suppose it's possible? But to me, I really don't think Kanan could've done that straight-up, like if the G.I. wasn't caught off-guard. You can theorize all you want about whether or not Kanan surpassed the Inquisitor in that moment, but I feel like the more consequential factor was that the G.I. thought Kanan was unconscious and thus wouldn't really have been able to defend himself against Kanan's TK.

Originally posted by ILS
Otherwise, it's contradictory to Legends, which canon doesn't acknowledge, so it doesn't have to play by the same rules. If you can show me a Legends example of a weaker Force user pinning a stronger one because they caught them off-guard, I'm all ears.
I don't see any reason why the Rebels example should be disregarded, if everyone still uses TCW in Legends discussions. I know that argument probably won't fly with you, but there's no real reason why the two shows would be operating differently in terms of combat and telekinesis and stuff, even if one is Legends and the other isn't. Regardless, I don't have any Legends examples on me ATM (unless Sel's example is legitimate, then I guess that is sufficient?) but if I get an example I'll bring it forth (I'm sure there must be a few similar examples).

Originally posted by Q99
and while wounded with shrapnel gave Cade a saber fight.
He was wounded with shrapnel?

Originally posted by |King Joker|
He was wounded with shrapnel?

Remember when Cade blew up the transparisteel cube that had his father's lightsaber? Both Talon and Nihl were covered in cuts from that. Which probably goes a long way to why Talon went down easier than normal too.