Luke Skywalker vs. Valkorion (Force only)

Started by darthbane773 pages

Originally posted by The Ellimist
Spirit Valkorion would be weaker; he was significantly weakened in his loss to the Hero, for instance.
He displayed immense power as a spirit though in KOTFE, in the Visions in the Dark chapter. I don't think he was weakened much, if at all.

Originally posted by darthbane77
How is Taalon above Valk and Sidious? Is he equal to Luke or something? I know he either drank from the font ot bathed in the pool, can't remember which.

He bathed in the Pool of Knowledge, then leaped out and basically fought as a rough equal with Luke, then as his transformation progressed he became more powerful to the extent that his existence shifted the balance of the Force towards the dark side, he was able to move too fast for Luke to perceive, and he was able to drag Luke around with telekinesis for a very considerable distance.

Well shit, OK then.

Originally posted by darthbane77
He displayed immense power as a spirit though in KOTFE, in the Visions in the Dark chapter. I don't think he was weakened much, if at all.

You mean aside from the part where he oneshots Arcann in his body, then when he channels his power through the outlander it takes a protracted lightning attack to beat Arcann and Arcann right after that commenting about how he was weaker?

Seems pretty clear cut to me.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
You mean aside from the part where he oneshots Arcann in his body, then when he channels his power through the outlander it takes a protracted lightning attack to beat Arcann and Arcann right after that commenting about how he was weaker?

Seems pretty clear cut to me.

He isn't weakened significantly though, he's still strong enough as a spirit to dominate the Outlander and freezing time.

Bottom line, Luke does win.

Originally posted by darthbane77
He isn't weakened significantly though,

Debatable. But regardless, if Luke already beats him at full strength, then just Valkorion being a little less than that still keeps Luke's victory cemented.

Originally posted by darthbane77
he's still strong enough as a spirit to dominate the Outlander

Fair enough for him I guess

Originally posted by darthbane77
and freezing time.

No... no he doesn't.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
And then Luke uses mindwalking to punch a hole through Valk's spirit's chest.

GG


Kindly elaborate this part with solid evidence.

Not the first time you got things wrong.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Revan can use Force drain across a solar system.

When?

KotORCG states Kun, Revan, Malak, Kreia, Sion, and Nihilus *can* expand their power as far as a solar system.

Note it's not just Force drain though. It's any ranged ability. Telekinesis, such as a Force choke, would work too.

It's a rather heavy mechanic-based power though.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
KotORCG states Kun, Revan, Malak, Kreia, Sion, and Nihilus *can* expand their power as far as a solar system.

Note it's not just Force drain though. It's any ranged ability. Telekinesis, such as a Force choke, would work too.

It's a rather heavy mechanic-based power though.

Is this the devastating/distant power stuff? Vandar Tokare had that as well. How seriously do you take this stuff?

Yeah, that. I mean, if Palpatine's bringing Vader to his knees across the galaxy with telepathy, it's not a stretch to assume Revan can choke someone on a nearby planet if he's really unleashing his power. Point is I can easily see Valkorion attacking his opponent from across a planet, since those powers confirm as much. However the text made specific note it's more indication of mastery, not raw power.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Yeah, that. I mean, if Palpatine's bringing Vader to his knees across the galaxy with telepathy, it's not a stretch to assume Revan can choke someone on a nearby planet if he's really unleashing his power.

Revan and Nihilus have both used Sense across the galaxy before. Traya's used Sense and Telepathy across the galaxy. Heck, Baras Choked people from across the galaxy, pintpointed the exact coordinates of his lightsaber from across the galaxy with Sense, etc. It's not hard to believe that most powerful Sith can do this.

Point is I can easily see Valkorion attacking his opponent from across a planet, since those powers confirm as much. However the text made specific note it's more indication of mastery, not raw power.

Which text? Where's the part where Devastating Power and Distant Power are described to begin with?

👆

---

The main game guide. I'll scan you tomorrow if interested. Off to bed now. Peace.

Which game guide?

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Debatable. But regardless, if Luke already beats him at full strength, then just Valkorion being a little less than that still keeps Luke's victory cemented.

Fair enough for him I guess

No... no he doesn't.

Then exactly what is this? https://imgur.com/NZzuotc

Originally posted by darthbane77
Did not know Luke could do that, nevermind then.

It is not that simple.

Mind Walking is practical in storytelling context but not in a hypothetical confrontation like this one where every second counts.

One cannot just Mind Walk in an instant; it is a ritualistic procedure that takes some time (possibly a minute?). And it is also a risky endeavor because it leaves the body in vegetable state. In order to attempt:

1. Luke Skywalker should be fully aware of Valkorion's abilities and powers in the first place
2. Luke needs to do it from relative safety

It is unwise to assume that Luke is fully aware of Valkorion's abilities and powers without solid evidence. The two have never met, and the literature gives us the impression that much about Valkorion is shrouded in mystery because he was not active on the front-lines. A reason is that Valkorion muted all those who came into contact with him but were not welcome. Jedi historians also attempted to get some insight about him but did not learn much.

Now, let us assume for the sake of argument that Luke manages to defeat an avatar of Valkorion (which is also a matter of IF, because Luke can loose in this confrontation as well). Now, Luke would feel that he has beaten his foe and he no longer exists. Therefore, Valkorion can take advantage of this situation and kill Luke because the Jedi won't see it coming.

For more information, kindly consult Star Wars: Fate of the Jedi - Abyss. Look at pages 162 - 170 in particular. My assessment is based on revelations in this novel.

^^^So spirit Valk very well could kill Luke then, hmm.

If we're using practical context, spirit Valkorion isn't just going to come out and kill Luke either.

Originally posted by SunRazer
If we're using practical context, spirit Valkorion isn't just going to come out and kill Luke either.

Probably not. He'll create a monster out of thin air to do it. Nobody is touching spirit Valkorion (not at least until we find out how he dies).