Rebels Ahsoka vs TFU Shaak Ti

Pong Krell fcking butchering the best clones at the time with ease doesn't impress you, but Shaak Ti losing to Magnaguards does?

Originally posted by MythLord
I dunno when Zen will answer.

😕

I would comment because....why? Force Users aren't my forte.

Originally posted by chingchangwalla
Pong Krell fcking butchering the best clones at the time with ease doesn't impress you, but Shaak Ti losing to Magnaguards does?

It's almost as if like Magnaguards >>> clones.

Originally posted by Zenwolf
😕

I would comment because....why?

Originally posted by cs_zoltan
It's almost as if like Magnaguards >>> clones.

Ahsoka wins sabers and all-out, maybe or maybe not force as well.

Cause lets be real, Ahsoka's duel against Vader is more impressive than Shaak dueling a Galen whose only dueling feat is beating Kota, and these "elites" are better compared to the ones who got matched/beaten by a Jedi Grievous one shotted, got danced around by Fisto, and got tagged by Red Guards, than to the ones that gave Anakin and Obi-Wan trouble.

Ashoka dominates.

Ahsoka.
Shaak.
Ahsoka.

Originally posted by SunRazer
1. She wasn't leaping to anything new. Only 2 Magnaguards are shown there, with a third arriving to be Pushed off the ledge. She pretty much just attacked the same one with an acrobatic attack, lol.

Impressive to what degree?

2. EU Vader is canonically weaker than RotS Anakin by this time in terms of sabers, whereas Canon Vader appears to be stronger (or at least, it's never stated that he got weaker).

She escaped, but did she even face him direct combat? Somebody persuaded me otherwise.

Besides, escaping could just as easily refer to how lucky you are or if somebody else sacrificed themselves so you could escape. KotOR Revan escaped from Darth Malak on the Leviathan, as well.

1. I mean, the MGs were dropping from the sky, so it is possible she's leaping to a new MG. Not that it'd matter, since the exchange is, at best, a few seconds long.

Impressive enough to mark her at least comparable to Obi, in her prime.

2. I mean, this is Knightfall Anakin who Fisto'ed Cin Drallig, so that is better than Canon Vader who is only subjectively superior to Skywalker.

3. I mean, it is noted in the TFU databank she stalled long enough for many'a'padawan to escape, and I doubt she would let a padawan or Knight just jump in and get speedblitzed by Vader. And as per TCSWE, many believed she was killed by Vader when he cornered her, so they saw a fight going on.

The Databank of TFU says nothing about Anakin and Ti solely, just there was the attack, she rallied Jedi and did evacs.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Ahsoka wins sabers and all-out, maybe or maybe not force as well.

Cause lets be real, Ahsoka's duel against Vader is more impressive than Shaak dueling a Galen whose only dueling feat is beating Kota, and these "elites" are better compared to the ones who got matched/beaten by a Jedi Grievous one shotted, got danced around by Fisto, and got tagged by Red Guards, than to the ones that gave Anakin and Obi-Wan trouble.

Id be inclined to believe you on that part...its just a few factors here.

1. Was Darth Vader..hindered in ANYWAY...because I saw sudtle hints.

2. I need....more of Ahsoka to make a proper decuction (That novel will do)

3. Ahsoka isnt too far back imo, I think she has hella improved.

She needs more time to cook, to me this is too raw...now if Daddy disney does jack **** then Ill say yeah sure That Vader duel is all she has on skill scaling and yada yada yada yada.

Originally posted by Zenwolf
The Databank of TFU says nothing about Anakin and Ti solely, just there was the attack, she rallied Jedi and did evacs.

I am combining all the sources noting the engagement to try and form a coherent recreation of what happened.

Originally posted by Dread Dark
Id be inclined to believe you on that part...its just a few factors here.

1. Was Darth Vader..hindered in ANYWAY...because I saw sudtle hints.

Originally posted by Dread Dark
2. I need....more of Ahsoka to make a proper decuction (That novel will do)

3. Ahsoka isnt too far back imo, I think she has hella improved.

She needs more time to cook, to me this is too raw...now if Daddy disney does jack **** then Ill say yeah sure That Vader duel is all she has on skill scaling and yada yada yada yada.

Originally posted by Emperordmb
Filoni said he wouldn't hesitate to kill her.

Well I mean Ahsoka really doesn't have that much less exposure than Ti does as a duelist so I don't see why this is an issue.

Ahhh very good, still I just personally want more because I swear to god if some dumbshit happens and Ahsoka jobs, like loosing to Ezra or Kanan...because plot.

INTERESTING....then why did he that time? (Why did he let her live?)

Then my head will be in a scrabble, Id rather play stratego.

Let us hope she is consistent.....hehehehe LET US HOPE!!

Ahsoka wins sabers and all out, Shaak wins Force

Originally posted by Deronn_solo
Ahsoka dominates.

Good to see you back Joker. 🙂

Originally posted by Dread Dark
Ahhh very good, still I just personally want more because I swear to god if some dumbshit happens and Ahsoka jobs, like loosing to Ezra or Kanan...because plot.

INTERESTING....then why did he that time? (Why did he let her live?)

Then my head will be in a scrabble, Id rather play stratego.

Let us hope she is consistent.....hehehehe LET US HOPE!!

He didn't let her live, he left it as ambiguous because he chickened out on giving an actual clarifying ending.

Originally posted by Beniboybling
Good to see you back Joker. 🙂