Knightfall Vader vs. Darth Plagueis

Started by The Ellimist4 pages
The Ellimist The Shadow

Knightfall Vader vs. Darth Plagueis

1. Sabers
2. All-out

Beniboybling Worst Member

Plagueis tanks and spanks.

UCanShootMyNova Senior Member

Plagueis stomps both rounds.

SunRazer Back From The Dead

Plagueis stomping sabers? Based on what?

JKBart Restricted

1. Plagueis wins
2. Plagueis wins easily

Dark-Kenshin Blocked

1. Anakin.
2. Plagueis.

Sinious Yo Da Best

Plagueis

Ursumeles Traitor

Plagueis wins All-Out, and probably Sabers as well.

UCanShootMyNova Senior Member
Originally posted by SunRazer
Plagueis stomping sabers? Based on what?

The author stating he would have likely defeated TPM Sidious in a duel.

SunRazer Back From The Dead

I thought you didn't take claims like that unless it was supported by feats?

ares834 Senior Member

1. Anakin
2. Plagueis

The Ellimist The Shadow

IMHO:

1. Anakin
2. Honestly not sure. It probably depends on starting distance.

UCanShootMyNova Senior Member
Originally posted by SunRazer
I thought you didn't take claims like that unless it was supported by feats?

It's not contradicted by feats and is left ambiguous. In those cases I do.

SunRazer Back From The Dead
Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
It's not contradicted by feats and is left ambiguous. In those cases I do.

TPM Sidious doesn't draw his lightsaber again for more than a decade, so it's safe to say that he really didn't improve. In which case, using his RotS feats is still understandable. Does that not contradict the idea of Plagueis being a better duelist to you?

I'm not seeing how Meetra quote is contradicted by Satele, then.

The Ellimist The Shadow

Syndicate's also assuming that RotS Sidious (or rather TPM Sidious) > Knightfall Vader as a duelist, and I'm not sure if that assumption is fair to make. They're comparable in augmentation (Sidious already acknowledges that Anakin is potentially more powerful than him, and Vader at this stage is even stronger), and while Sidious may or may not have an edge in skill, Anakin is younger.

Ursumeles Traitor

Originally posted by SunRazer

I'm not seeing how Meetra quote is contradicted by Satele, then.

Which quote? And how Satele contradicts it?

SunRazer Back From The Dead

Scourge's claim that Revan and Meetra were the greatest Jedi in terms of strength up until he met HoT. And he's met Satele.

Syndicate doesn't believe in the quote and thinks that Satele's feats contradict it or something. I'm asking him to elaborate.

The Ellimist The Shadow

That's made even more interesting by the fact that Meetra was being hindered on a dark side nexus.

SunRazer Back From The Dead

Yes, it is.

Ursumeles Traitor

So Exile>Meetra on a DS Nexus>Satele. Cool, lol.