Cin Drallig vs. Galen Marek (Felcucia) [Lightsabers Only]

Originally posted by MythLord
Except the reprint has him saying the exact same thing about Shaak Ti. Not to mention, Tyranus was extremely angry at General Grievous and tried to humble him.

You will have to provide a video clip of you opening the book in the relevant passage for me to believe you. A quote, and even a scan can easily be faked.

And Ti was compared to Dooku himself at one point, which is obviously beyond Drallig.

She wasn't compared to Dooku; she was just listed alongside him as having "stylistic grace". And any comparison between the two would be rendered invalid when looking at Ti's own feats - mainly her being stomped at the hands of General Grievous wielding one lightsaber and holding Palpatine. General Grievous, who is noted to be inferior to Cin Drallig.

Originally posted by Azronger
So what if he was angry? His assessement of three of the combatants is correct, so why not Drallig?

Windu didn't stalemate Grievous; the engagement lasted only a few seconds and was inconclusive. More information can be found here

And we know Obi-Wan defeated Grievous, and nobody questions Yoda would trash him. Dooku has proven himself to be a credible source in these things, which leads me to believe his assessment of Drallig is correct.

There's nothing to support his assessment being correct. There is evidence to support the opposite though, that being Grievous's performance against Mace.

I've read that blog by Emp and have already commented my thoughts on it to him to which he had no answer to other then different interpretations. His explanation is flawed as he failed to take into account the interval where Fisto and his magnaguard opponents had fought their way to the other end of the train from where the fight had started.

Obi Wan defeated him because of his form being perfectly suited to combating Grievous. RotS would have you believe Dooku didn't even know Obi Wan's real main form before their final duel.

Originally posted by Azronger
You will have to provide a video clip of you opening the book in the relevant passage for me to believe you. A quote, and even a scan can easily be faked.

Sadly, I don't have the book itself.

Originally posted by Azronger
She wasn't compared to Dooku; she was just listed alongside him as having "stylistic grace". And any comparison between the two would be rendered invalid when looking at Ti's own feats - mainly her being stomped at the hands of General Grievous wielding one lightsaber and holding Palpatine. General Grievous, who is noted to be inferior to Cin Drallig.

Yeah, stylistic grace like Dooku. That grace being a big part of her fighting technique. And Shaak was exhausted when that happened, lmao. She just fought off a small army of MagnaGuards, got tagged several times by electrical discharges that can bring down TCW Anakin Skywalker, ran across Coruscant, then ran even further to GG.

She was at the end of her ropes. Shaak actually managing to fend off and survive an engagement with Knightfall Anakin, as oppose to Drallig who gets Fisto'ed while Anakin was choking a b!tch and fending off two other Jedi, marks her as just better.

Where did Ti fight Anakin? There's no real proof to that.

Except the Official Vehicle Collections Fact File noting she nearly died by Anakin's hands, but managed to escape(implying a fight given how she was cornered by him in her meditation chamber).

But other sources say no such thing about that. Also why is a Vehicle Fact File saying things like that to begin with? That's completely far and away from vehicles.

Anakin actively searches out Shaak Ti in the RotS novel.

Doesn't mean he found her, when the attack began, Ti rallied Jedi to fight off the Clone attack according to TFU Databank.

That's 3 sources that imply and support her having fought and escaped Anakin.

Those 3 sources being?

RotS novelization, TFU comic and the Official Vehicle Collections Fact File.

Edit: Oh! That's 4 sources I guess. Add the TFU databank to that.

The TFU Databank could simply note that after she escaped from dueling Anakin, she rallied the Jedi and ensured they survived. mmm It makes coherent sense, especially when Ti was Anakin's prime target in RotS.

As for why that's in a Vehicle Fact File... beats the hell out of me. Those things apparently not a character's backstory, then their favoured vehicles or something.

RoTS novel doesn't really confirm anything, sure Anakin asked where Ti was. Doesn't mean he found her, because when the attack began she rallied Jedi to her and fought the attack.

If he found her, this wouldn't have happened.

The comic doesn't really show anything concrete either.

Originally posted by MythLord
The TFU Databank could simply note that after she escaped from dueling Anakin, she rallied the Jedi and ensured they survived. mmm It makes coherent sense, especially when Ti was Anakin's prime target in RotS.

As for why that's in a Vehicle Fact File... beats the hell out of me. Those things apparently not a character's backstory, then their favoured vehicles or something.

But she rallied Jedi and helped fight off the Clone attack and then escaped when she realized the Temple was doomed.

Soo...I don't see how this adds up. She fought Anakin? Then went on to fight Clones? So Anakin then just ignored her after the fight? That doesn't seem likely.

Maybe she fought Anakin and the clones alongside the other Jedi?

You're kind of latching onto irrelevant points Zen.

Originally posted by Zenwolf
RoTS novel doesn't really confirm anything, sure Anakin asked where Ti was. Doesn't mean he found her, because when the attack began she rallied Jedi to her and fought the attack.

If he found her, this wouldn't have happened.

The comic doesn't really show anything concrete either.

It doesn't outright say it but it heavily implies it and given it's implied in like 4 different sources it seems likely.

Whatever, I don't care enough about these characters to bother continuing.

👆

Originally posted by UCanShootMyNova
Maybe she fought Anakin and the clones alongside the other Jedi?

You're kind of latching onto irrelevant points Zen.

That would seem more likely.

But I'm just trying to sort through the weirdness of it all. But fair point, it's treading off topic anyway, so I'll just end here.

Originally posted by Zenwolf
Plus Dooku notes, those are the same moves he used on Hypori where he trashed all those Jedi.

👆

Including Shaak Ti, lawl. I doubt there's a reprint with her replacing Cin, cuz that would be pretty retarded.