ROTJ Sidious vs TFA Luke

Sidious goes into the future to change his ROTJ ending and meets Luke TFA. Who wins all out?

Does anyone think Luke is more powerful than Sidious at this point?

Luke has no screen feats as of yet.

Technically no at this stage. But he does have a win over Vader as of ROTJ. The only feat Sidious has that is greater than that is stalemating Yoda. That was circumstantial.

TFA Luke is likely akin to NJO Luke from legends. He'll win, and pretty easily. He already beat a more powerful Sids than his ROTJ version. I don't get the thread really... how does ROTJ Sids going into the future to still be ROTJ Sids and meet Luke? I don't get that, but if it's what I think you meant... he losses.

Originally posted by KuRuPT Thanosi
TFA Luke is likely akin to NJO Luke from legends. He'll win, and pretty easily. He already beat a more powerful Sids than his ROTJ version. I don't get the thread really... how does ROTJ Sids going into the future to still be ROTJ Sids and meet Luke? I don't get that, but if it's what I think you meant... he losses.

If Luke is akin to NJO I agree he wins in a good battle.

I meant that ROTJ Sid found out how he die and to escape his fate went into the future. I really did not give the opening scenario much thought.

Luke should be more powerful than Yoda or Palpatine ever were.

Remember what Vader says to Luke in ESB "Luke you can destroy the Emperor. He has foreseen this.."

TFA Luke stomps and stomps hard, end of story

Originally posted by Impediment
Luke has no screen feats as of yet.

👆

He might be weak AF or strong AF, we don't really know.

so far no feats, ask me again once ep 8 drops

Originally posted by Impediment
Luke has no screen feats as of yet.

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
👆

He might be weak AF or strong AF, we don't really know.

Originally posted by relentless1
so far no feats, ask me again once ep 8 drops

the three of you are wrong.. dead wrong...

😄 😛 😛

Luke has no screen feats, kiddo.

Well based on what we know and have seen from both characters, Palpatine wins by default...

🙂

Originally posted by Impediment
Luke has no screen feats as of yet.

Well Luke still has his OT feats right?

Curious though, going by the rules does Kylo Ren beat Snoke because Snoke hasn't shown anything yet?

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Curious though, going by the rules does Kylo Ren beat Snoke because Snoke hasn't shown anything yet?

Snoke is a complete unknown though, he may or may not be a fraud, we don't know jack shit about him, at least with Luke theres an assumed trajectory based on his younger feats/growth as a Jedi.

Originally posted by relentless1
Snoke is a complete unknown though, he may or may not be a fraud, we don't know jack shit about him, at least with Luke theres an assumed trajectory based on his younger feats/growth as a Jedi.

We know Snoke's his Master, that he seduced him to the dark side, and that he will train Ren further 😬

And that somehow puts Snoake above Luke...... 😬

Originally posted by Kazenji
And that somehow puts Snoake above Luke...... 😬

No! Above Kylo.. Pay attention:

Originally posted by Darth Thor

Curious though, going by the rules does Kylo Ren beat Snoke because Snoke hasn't shown anything yet?

Originally posted by relentless1
Snoke is a complete unknown though, he may or may not be a fraud, we don't know jack shit about him, at least with Luke theres an assumed trajectory based on his younger feats/growth as a Jedi.

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
Well based on what we know and have seen from both characters, Palpatine wins by default...

🙂

Originally posted by quanchi112
Well I have been the first to claim Snoke will be proven greater than Palpatine. Let's see who is correct.

I'm very interested for eps 8 and 9 precisely to see just how powerful Snoke and Luke are.