Daredevil vs Judge dredd in Law knowledge

who knows the law better? matt or dredd?

It's a tie I think.

Judge Dredd isn't just a Cop. He is by definition a Judge and that means that, in Omega City One, he is the law.

Daredevil perfectly knows how the law works in our world.

Not exactly an apples to apples comparison as their respective laws are completely different.

Dredd had every letter of the law literally bred into his brain during his cloning/ageing process so there's nothing about his version of the law that he doesn't know FWIW.

Cheers.

^ I'd also wager that Mega-City One's laws are far more abundant(and complex) than those of mainstream Marvel earth, given that Judges serve as judge/jury/executioner due to the city's absurd overpopulation.

...And like you said: Dredd knows EVERY last detail of EVERY last law.

Is there going to be a Dredd 2 film? It'd be a shame if there wasn't

I f*cking hope so. Really enjoyed that film... Holds up great with repeated viewings as well. 👆

Originally posted by Galan007
^ I'd also wager that Mega-City One's laws are far more abundant(and complex) than those of mainstream Marvel earth, given that Judges serve as judge/jury/executioner due to the city's absurd overpopulation.

...And like you said: Dredd knows EVERY last detail of EVERY last law.

Or, everything is given the sentence of 30 years in jail, or death, lol.

True, ive never seen community service offered in mega city one lol

..seriously tho i find the world of dredd more and more interesting as I read into it and now really phukking want to see dredd 2 or a series.

^ Dunno about community service, but I have seen Dredd divvy-out sentences for lesser infractions on several occasions. One that comes to mind is when he sentenced a citizen to a month in the iso-cubes for littering.

^^^From the movie:

Attempted murder of a judge (life in an Iso-Cube without parole or Death)
Manufacture and distribution of narcotics (?)
Multiple homicide (life in an Iso-Cube without parole / Death)
Murder (Death)
Resisting Arrest (Death)
Possession and use of controlled substance (2 years Iso-Cube)
Prostitution
Vagrancy (3 weeks in an Iso-Cube or let off with a warning, if a higher priority crime is being investigated and the vagrant is not in the same place when the Judge or Judges return)
Abetting a Felon (5 years )
Obstruction of Justice, e.g. interfering with a crime scene, preventing a Judge or Judges from entering a building or withholding information relevant to a case (Automatic 5 years in an Iso-Cube)

Despite it's simplicity, 2012 Dredd is pretty much the best comic book movie ever.

Its up there, yeah. Definitely one of MY top picks.

Originally posted by psycho gundam
Is there going to be a Dredd 2 film? It'd be a shame if there wasn't

Not sure about the sequel happening, But they have been doing Dredd stories set within that world from the movie.

Where is She Hulk?

also it seems like dredd is more about criminal law. but the LAW is beyond only criminal or even law of torts. wonder if dredd or matt know the law of succession or the Family LAW. they probably do but would really be interesting. seeing judge dredd walking down the street and a couple asking him to rule as a judge about child support and devision of property. and dredd will be like ***** you are abstracting the LAW by preventing me from stopping a commited crime right now. you get 5 years.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Or, everything is given the sentence of 30 years in jail, or death, lol.

And the odd banishment from Earth via rocket.

The fate of poor "not Wily Wonka" for making candy so addicting, even the crime computer kept asking for samples.

i think he just makes up the punishment on spot 0_0

^^^nope.

Originally posted by riv6672
^^^nope.

did you ever see the Penal Code of that universe? i mean nobody ever question dredd about the Law Sections he is accusing with. i dont think most of those criminals really know the law. it would be funny if someone actually question him like what? section 3.5? what are you talking about dredd? thats the section about witnessing a crime and being detained for questioning on spot. what death penalty are you talking about.