Originally posted by Deronn_solo
So, you don't find Galen's character to be very author inserty, and, essentially, a power fulfillment character?
The makers of TFU at first didn't even want to use Vader and Sidious in the game as villains, because they thought those guys should be way more powerful than him and Galen shouldn't beat them, and instead they wanted to use a second apprentice of Vader. Then Lucas intervened and told them to use Vader and Sidious.
So you are not only talking shit but horribly misinformed too 👆
Originally posted by cs_zoltan
The makers of TFU at first didn't even want to use Vader and Sidious in the game as villains, because they thought those guys should be way more powerful than him and Galen shouldn't beat them, and instead they wanted to use a second apprentice of Vader. Then Lucas intervened and told them to use Vader and Sidious.So you are not only talking shit but horribly misinformed too 👆
I don't actually care for what their intent was initially, the only thing that matters is the finished product, and to that end, yes --- he is, for reasons already eluded to.
Originally posted by cs_zoltan
Your argument essentially boils down to "but...but he's powarful". You are either salty, retarded, or uneducated 🙂
Except, that really isn't my argument Besides power, Galen really doesn't have any unique qualities, or personality traits besides being broody.
Learn to actually comprehend for a change.
Originally posted by Deronn_solo
I don't actually care for what their intent was initially, the only thing that matters is the finished product, and to that end, yes --- he is, for reasons already eluded to.
You claimed you thought he was a "self insert character for the author" so I'd think their intent would be sort of relevant to you.
Originally posted by nfactor1995There's been Bane > Plagueis, Bane > RotS Yoda/Sidious, Bane > Kun/Krayt/Revan/Caedus etc, and just as unreasonably IMO > Maul/Dooku/Vader.
Tbh it sounds like (from what I've heard from some KMC users) that the Bane hatred is due to the Bane brigade trying to hype him to be more powerful than the likes of Revan and Caedus, and only surpassed by the Banite Sith and the obvious top tiers like Yoda and Sidious.
I find that poorly written characters attract readers of a similar proclivity, so it's no coincidence that most Bane fans are dense, with the exception of DMB who is simply confused atm. And because those readers are dense, their arguments fall along similar lines.
Originally posted by Deronn_solo
I don't actually care for what their intent was initially, the only thing that matters is the finished product, and to that end, yes --- he is, for reasons already eluded to.
Nice goalpost moving you got there, because that's not what you said.
Originally posted by Deronn_solo
So, you don't find Galen's character to be very author inserty, and, essentially, a power fulfillment character?
How is he either, when his makers didn't even want to make him face with either Vader or Sidious out of respect (unlike that f-cuktard Filoni who makes his precious character contend with Vader on a DS nexus...), and in the end still made him quite less powerful than either and only being able to beat Vader due to circumstances?
Originally posted by Deronn_solo
Except, that really isn't my argument Besides power, Galen really doesn't have any unique qualities, or personality traits besides being broody.Learn to actually comprehend for a change.
That's only to your limited view. How about his struggle with the Dark and Light (not very unique, but still there it is), his dynamic with Vader and being used, his demons about his slayed parents, or his redemption on the Death Star (he's one of the few characters that went from sith to jedi, not the usual other way around). And in TFU II his self identity crisis.
Your precious Kyp fits your version of a Gary Sue a lot more than Galen 🙂
Originally posted by The Merchant
Bane's awesome. He was able to beat one of the greatest lightsaber duelists of all time and resist the mental influence of a Sith Lord capable of mentally influencing thousands of other Sith to remain loyal to each other. That puts Bane on the level of ROTS Palpatine easily.
Originally posted by cs_zoltanGuess you can't appreciate character development. 🙂
No, I hated Assoka from the first minute I saw her in the TCW movie.
Originally posted by cs_zoltanPlease, even barring "wankers", you know she's extremely powerful, and it bothers you. 🙂
She's one of the few characters I hate by her own merit, not just because of her wankers 🙂
Re: Why do peoole hate Darth Bane?
Originally posted by Deronn_soloBane was worse.
I mean, I understand he is a terrible Gary Sue, but so is someone like, say, a Galen Marek --- but he doesn't get anywhere near the hate Bane receives.I just don't get it. mmm
Never got injured.
Never had to use any forethought.
Got portrayed as retardedly OP, despite his role among the Banite Sith.
All-around lucky SoB whose life always went the way he wanted.