DE Luke runs a Revan gauntlet

Windu isn't factually more powerful, even if you take Nova's quote seriously, that's pre-mask Revan who is < Reborn Revan.

As far as the quote is concerned premask revan is the same jedi as reborn revan

Revan Reborn hasn't walked the Jedi Temple.

Are we certain Revan's walked the Temple on Coruscant?

He does at the start of the Revan novel, a year after KotOR.

Ah. Well, does it apply to him after he leaves the Jedi Temple?

Yoda was the most respected and most powerful Master ever to have walked the corridors of the Jedi Temple.

He may have become a more powerful Jedi Master, but he didn't walk the Temple with that power.

It applies to him as of the time he walked the Temple, which is at the start of the novel. It doesn't apply to SoR Revan or any future incarnations.

Still probably < Yoda.

Then again, SoR Revan was "ultimately neither Jedi nor Sith."

perhaps the ideals of the Jedi proved insufficient, in the end, for a man neither Jedi nor Sith.

Obviously Yoda's more powerful than any incarnation of Revan. I thought were discussing Mace, who has that quote about being more powerful than anybody who's walked the Temple corridors bar Yoda (until Y: DR inserted a retcon by making Dooku more powerful than Mace).

Originally posted by darthbane77
Mace is in no way "factually more powerful than revan and vader", Vader is for sure more powerful than Windu, and Revan ****ing ragdolls Windu.

Are reborn revan and pre mask revan two versions of the same character?
Yes
So has reborn revan ever walked the corridors of the jedi temple?
Yes, he has
So if mace is more powerful than any jedi who've ever walked the corridors of the jedi temple, does that place mace above jedi revan? yes it does.

Originally posted by SunRazer
Revan Reborn hasn't walked the Jedi Temple.

Revan Reborn isn't a Jedi either, pre-mask Revan is. Pre-mask Revan doesn't have Reborn's immense Sith knowledge.

According to Drew, Revan already regained most of his memories before acquiring the mask.

The funny thing is that most of us argue about whether or not he's in Plagueis' league, and Rocky's using an ambiguous quote to wank Mace over him.

Originally posted by Geistalt
The funny thing is that most of us argue about whether or not he's in Plagueis' league, and Rocky's using an ambiguous quote to wank Mace above him.

Originally posted by Rockydonovang
Revan has absolutely nothing putting him revan league

Originally posted by Geistalt
Nice save.

I mean, sor revan is half the man he once was

Revan Reborn is a Jedi, indeed. He's listed as a Jedi Master in the dramatis personae, identifies himself as a "champion of the light", and is referred to as a Jedi Master in TOR, IIRC.

However, he still hasn't walked the Jedi Temple's corridors.

Originally posted by SunRazer
Revan Reborn is a Jedi, indeed. He's listed as a Jedi Master in the dramatis personae, identifies himself as a "champion of the light", and is referred to as a Jedi Master in TOR, IIRC.

However, he still hasn't walked the Jedi Temple's corridors.

Post-KotOR Revan is a very broad term. You can't classify Revan a year on from KotOR with SoR Revan for instance.