Order These Races By Power

Originally posted by Digi
I'm in if needed. Just shoot me a PM once it's over and time to judge.

4 Judges: Delta, Martian_Mind, Darksaint and Digi.

3 to go.

I'll post this again, since it's at the bottom of the page:

@bwr

Just in case there's no confusion - we'll be debating Pre-Flashpoint, since we can't address both New 52 and the previous one coherently, given that they're separate in their continuities and canon [for now]

If you have another suggestion, be free to say so.

What is a judge required to do other than decide who won, if anything?

I'd be down.

Originally posted by CosmicComet
What is a judge required to do other than decide who won, if anything?

I'd be down.

Ok, I'll add you too. I didn't have you on 'the list' because I was just going by who bluewater suggested.

So we have 5 judges: 4 Judges: Delta, Martian_Mind, Darksaint, Digi, CosmicComet.

other 3 pending (leo, abhi, pr)

Pr agrees to judge.

6 judges: Delta, Martian_Mind, Darksaint, Digi, CosmicComet, Pr.

other 2 pending (leo, abhi)

I'll do it.

Originally posted by abhilegend
I'll do it.

7 judges. Leo is pending, but we'll be starting tomorrow either way.

Final notes:

Topic:
Average kryptonian (blueareavet) vs Average martian (me) - who is more powerful? No burning martians.
Pre-Flashpoint Universe
Opening + 5 posts (each single post is an overall post)
Judges: Delta, Martian_Mind, Darksaint, Digi, CosmicComet, Pr, Abhil (maybe Leo)
Deadline: Saturday/Sunday

We'll be PM the opening post to one of the judges (Pr?), and he'll submit them tomorrow night.

All good, bluearea?

Phildo, who reps whom?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Phildo, who reps whom?

I edited the post for clarity.

So Philo has his own arguments and the judges stacked against him. This is...interesting.,

Even if you win, you lose, but I'll be hella proud 👆

Also, it's bluewaterrider.

BAV has been banned.

You look fine for judges etc, but let me know if you need a fill-in, or a thread creator/host.

Looking forward to reading 👆

Originally posted by Cogito
So Philo has his own arguments and the judges stacked against him. This is...interesting.,

Even if you win, you lose, but I'll be hella proud 👆

It's gonna break my heart. 😂

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Also, it's bluewaterrider.

BAV has been banned.

Originally posted by Smurph
You look fine for judges etc, but let me know if you need a fill-in, or a thread creator/host.

Looking forward to reading 👆

Not taking a side in this, but you know what's really 'interesting?'

If we are using 'original specifications,' and thus taking Kryptonians as they would naturally be, then in the same vein we should be taking Martians as they should naturally be.

As in, not Green or White Martians, but rather Burning Martians.

After all ...the original Martians (the REAL Martians), were Burning Martians. It is the Guardians who messed with their DNA and turned them into WEAKER less malevolent Greens and Whites.

So, the original Martians are the Burning variety.

Eh, Burning Martians were a huge retcon and the story has never been referenced and contradicted too much.

It's just not that relevant in the grand structure of comics and certainly not to the value some put in it.

We also don't know if Fernus was typical of his race. Sure, the Guardians viewed the Martians as a threat, but we can't just share feats across 'average' Burning Martians.

Can I just make this easier for everyone and say that Phil is obviously correct, and it's really not debatable?

uwelcome. 👆

Originally posted by Galan007
Can I just make this easier for everyone and say that Phil is obviously correct, and it's really not debatable?

uwelcome. 👆

Nah, I'm here for the show 🤣

Besides, you put average Asgardian fodder above Martian fodder, so what the hell do you know 👇

mmm...

...You raise some good points. mhmm

👆

If you need a judge, I am also ready to help out if there is need.

😂

what a sh!t show. 👆

anyway, if i judged i'd make 8 so i'll pass (to avoid any draw, NOT for lack of interest!!) i'll def read this as it goes along. hopefully judges can get their votes in promptly as that it what typically ruins bz's....

i never commented on this thread because i sort of thought it was a bait thread. using krptonians as a race implied to me using them as they were on krypton, which seemed asinine. /shrug

if we take superman, zod et al., as krptonians they would be the winners, followed by martians in my mind. krypts simply have a better average of highs and fewer lows than martians do. either way i figured this would turn stupid, which it has in some places, but it has led to this bz so ultimately i guess we have to call this thread a gleaming success. 👆