Qui-Gon Jinn vs Plo Koon

Okay, these two Jedi Masters face off against one another.

TCW Plo Koon
TPM Qui-Gon Jinn

Using Legends for both.

1. Sparring match (pure lightsaber skills)
2. All out (no morals)
3. Force battle (no lightsabers)

Without really going into analysing it, I reckon it would be:

1. Jinn
2. Jinn/Plo Koon
3. Plo Koon

Not sure, tbh. Plo at least would take Force, IMO.

Probably Plo in all.

Plo in all, yeah. Good fight, though.

Lol Jinn wins all

Jinn, but it's close.

koon sweeps

Split

I'd say Jinn at least takes sparring definitively, and in my opinion he could probably contend if not beat Plo Koon in all in and force.

Beating a pre prime ventress(who was a superior version of the one who beat fisto(with a form advantage)while injured and outclassing oppress(sorry folks, but pulling someone's mask off when a fight's interrupted and your opponent's distracted doesn't make up for only being able to parry one strike of their saber before getting injured under normal circumstances) tells me he could take sabers too

Plo

Jinn
Jinn
Plo

Originally posted by Rockydonovang
outclassing oppress(sorry folks, but pulling someone's mask off when a fight's interrupted and your opponent's distracted doesn't make up for only being able to parry one strike of their saber before getting injured under normal circumstances)

More excuses for Opress vs Koon I see.

Opress won because he was stronger. Deal with it.

They should really be near equals as duelists in all honesty.

But that said Jinn get the edge.

Force goes to Koon, he's more versatile than Jinn and is probably gonna wreck.

All out, eh who knows.

Anoon Bondara thinks to himself that Qui-Gon and Mace were superior duelists to himself. The fact that he mentions those two together puts Jinn in quite high esteem.

That just means Jinn > Anoon & Mace > Anoon.
In no way that suggests parity between Mace & Jinn lol.

Yeah but he refers specifically to those two masters. I'm not at all saying Mace and Jinn are equals. It's just that Jinn is held in quite high esteem if he's mentioned alongside Mace.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
More excuses for Opress vs Koon I see.

Opress won because he was stronger. Deal with it.

Originally posted by Rockydonovang
Beating a pre prime ventress(who was a superior version of the one who beat fisto(with a form advantage)while injured and outclassing oppress(sorry folks, but pulling someone's mask off when a fight's interrupted and your opponent's distracted doesn't make up for only being able to parry one strike of their saber before getting injured under normal circumstances) tells me he could take sabers too

How is that indicative of Plo Koon being better in sabers? Jinn would have no problem beating Ventress in lightsaber combat, and he is known to have beaten Anoon Bondara, a master of all seven forms [presumably, as he was Battlemaster for the temple] and practitioner of Form VII in sparring. He was a student of Dooku, and had fought many times with his old master. There's just simply no way that he isn't good.

plo scales off qui-gon as a duelist and has better force feats and equal force hype.

He wins.