pretty sure ss did pretty well against hulk and his buddies in the arena. can't see am doing any real lasting damage to him. ss should take this pretty handily i'd think. and on planet hulk, i think ss was weakened as well... he wouldn't be here, obviously. need a bigger gun to punch ss's lights out imo.
Originally posted by leonidas
pretty sure ss did pretty well against hulk and his buddies in the arena. can't see am doing any real lasting damage to him. ss should take this pretty handily i'd think. and on planet hulk, i think ss was weakened as well... he wouldn't be here, obviously. need a bigger gun to punch ss's lights out imo.
This?
https://lowbrowcomics.com/2016/04/10/incredible-hulk-vs-silver-surfer-planet-hulk/
Not really seeing anything that looks unreplicatable by Aquaman. Or where Surfer did any lasting damage. Probably missing some scenes though?
Surfer has a weapon and his board. And it's seems Hulk is holding back until that final hit..
no i think that's all of it. hulk only got his shots in because he had help though, and a weak ss seemed pretty capable of matching him. the hulk in that arc is a lot stronger than am imo and like i said, that ss was weakened on a couple fronts. at full strength i don't see am being able to come close to what hulk did. he'd get some shots in but ss has far too many durability feats for me to believe he'd be punched out by arthur. /shrug
Originally posted by leonidasI'll have to check, but wasn't Hulk weakened at that point, or had he already recovered? I haven't read PH in years.
no i think that's all of it. hulk only got his shots in because he had help though, and a weak ss seemed pretty capable of matching him. the hulk in that arc is a lot stronger than am imo and like i said, that ss was weakened on a couple fronts. at full strength i don't see am being able to come close to what hulk did. he'd get some shots in but ss has far too many durability feats for me to believe he'd be punched out by arthur. /shrug
Originally posted by leonidas
no i think that's all of it. hulk only got his shots in because he had help though, and a weak ss seemed pretty capable of matching him. the hulk in that arc is a lot stronger than am imo and like i said, that ss was weakened on a couple fronts. at full strength i don't see am being able to come close to what hulk did. he'd get some shots in but ss has far too many durability feats for me to believe he'd be punched out by arthur. /shrug
Hulk's undoubtedly the physically stronger character between him and Arthur. Given the dialogue I don't think Arthur's punching out Surfer either at least before being punched out himself.
Is it stated though that Surfer was weakened?
Originally posted by EcstaticGrace
This?
https://lowbrowcomics.com/2016/04/10/incredible-hulk-vs-silver-surfer-planet-hulk/Not really seeing anything that looks unreplicatable by Aquaman. Or where Surfer did any lasting damage. Probably missing some scenes though?
Surfer has a weapon and his board. And it's seems Hulk is holding back until that final hit..
SS wins this, imo, due to greater durability and strength, all other things being equal.
Originally posted by leonidas
if he was weak, that would be news to me. if you find that, def worth posting. 👆
"News to you"...?
Have you even read Planet Hulk? He was f*cking weakened, while Surfer was bloodlusted and secretely relishing in his new life as a gladiator slave.
And guess what, Norrin got smashed.
durhulk
Originally posted by riv6672
By the same token, i see nothing that puts AQ significantly above SS in regards to h2h.
A lot is made of SS being pacifistic, but he throws hands just fine when the occasion calls for it.
In comic book terms, neither he nor AQ do much more than punch dramatically.SS wins this, imo, due to greater durability and strength, all other things being equal.
Aquaman does more than punch, he'll show more technical fighting when he grapples. The only issue that comes in mind with Aquaman and h2h is that it's never gone in depth with.
Like it is for the slugfester Thor, or same with Orion ironically.
Not that I was saying he's a better fighter then Norrin though?
Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
"News to you"...?Have you even read Planet Hulk? He was f*cking weakened, while Surfer was bloodlusted and secretely relishing in his new life as a gladiator slave.
And guess what, Norrin got smashed.
durhulk
lol what year did that come out again....?
if hulk was weakened, i'd completely forgotten that bit. it was expressly stated by ss at the end of that book that he wasn't only cut off from the pc in the fight, but was weakened in other ways too. THAT bit i remembered. 👆