Bane vs. TFA Captain America

Started by carthage11 pages

Bane vs. TFA Captain America

Rodgers doesn't have his shield

Who wins

Captain America 10/10

Bane has no business fighting enhanced humans. Give him a non-enhanced opponent like Punisher or human Thor.

Originally posted by Silent Master
Captain America 10/10
Originally posted by FrothByte
Bane has no business fighting enhanced humans. Give him a non-enhanced opponent like Punisher or human Thor.

Rogers still ran down a car, swam down that HYDRA agent's submarine, punched through said submarine's cockpit glass, through said HYDRA agent onto the dock above from the water that was several feet below the dock, fought and eventually beat Red Skull (who took an early version of the SSS, moved the heavy casket lid in the opening of TFA, and dented Cap's original metal shield with a hit), and kicked that HYDRA dude into the air backwards.

I'd say he's more than enough.

Not enough time for me now, but Bane vs street clothes Batfleck and the other new Bane thread are much closer fights.

WHERE IS H1??
we need his insight

hahahaha

I guess we can look at the multiple people Cap sent flying. Remember that one guy he threw over the tank and he just didn't come down?

Cap would punch Bane's mask out the back of his head.

Split. Bane is strong enough to hurt Cap a lot and far more skilled.

Originally posted by h1a8
Split. Bane is strong enough to hurt Cap a lot and far more skilled.

More like Cap 10/10.

Cap can quite literally beat Bane with one hand tied behind his back.

Originally posted by Dreampanther
Cap can quite literally beat Bane with one hand tied behind his back.

He's not very skilled in h2h in TFA. He relies solely on his physical stats. Bane is vastly more skilled and strong enough to really hurt Steve.

Even if true, Cap >>>> Bane in physical stats. it would be like Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson fighting a 10 year old 2nd degree black belt.

Originally posted by h1a8
He's not very skilled in h2h in TFA. He relies solely on his physical stats. Bane is vastly more skilled and strong enough to really hurt Steve.

Can you specifically tell me or show me what scene in the movie displays Bane's "vast skill"? I want to see it with my own eyes.

You keep speaking of Bane's skill but I dont recall ever witnessing said skill in the movie. Show me because I have actually posted Bane scenes from the actual movie that show he is a slow basic type brawler.

He also has peak human strength. Nothing more.
Like i have said before real world martial artists break concrete blocks all the time. And real world strong men in the competitions regularly lift boulders and huge logs , sometimes with not too much effort.
Bane is not above real world strong men.

Originally posted by h1a8
Split. Bane is strong enough to hurt Cap a lot and far more skilled.

there you are ,,, hahaha

Cap stomps 10/10

Originally posted by Inhuman
Can you specifically tell me or show me what scene in the movie displays Bane's "vast skill"? I want to see it with my own eyes.

You keep speaking of Bane's skill but I dont recall ever witnessing said skill in the movie. Show me because I have actually posted Bane scenes from the actual movie that show he is a slow basic type brawler.

He also has peak human strength. Nothing more.
Like i have said before real world martial artists break concrete blocks all the time. And real world strong men in the competitions regularly lift boulders and huge logs , sometimes with not too much effort.
Bane is not above real world strong men.

No, you're completely wrong here my friend. No human being alive could replicate Bane's feat of neck lifting Batman with one hand.

Only the absolute strongest men in the world can lift the Thomas Inch Dumbell, and Batman's neck would be much more awkward to grip and Batman himself would be quite a bit heavier.

Originally posted by NemeBro
No, you're completely wrong here my friend. No human being alive could replicate Bane's feat of neck lifting Batman with one hand.

Only the absolute strongest men in the world can lift the Thomas Inch Dumbell, and Batman's neck would be much more awkward to grip and Batman himself would be quite a bit heavier.

Okay. Bane is really strong.

Can he replicate Cap holding up 3 women on a motorcycle?

Not even the strongest man in the world can casually throw men over tanks, or chase down cars, or punch through submarine glass, etc, etc...

So Cap is >>>>>to Bane what Bane is to really strong, but regular people?

How does any of that change the outcome of the fight?

Originally posted by NemeBro
No, you're completely wrong here my friend. No human being alive could replicate Bane's feat of neck lifting Batman with one hand.

Only the absolute strongest men in the world can lift the Thomas Inch Dumbell, and Batman's neck would be much more awkward to grip and Batman himself would be quite a bit heavier.

No human alive maybe, but quite a number of movie humans can.

Originally posted by NemeBro
No, you're completely wrong here my friend. No human being alive could replicate Bane's feat of neck lifting Batman with one hand.

Only the absolute strongest men in the world can lift the Thomas Inch Dumbell, and Batman's neck would be much more awkward to grip and Batman himself would be quite a bit heavier.

Bane is obviously strong compared to your average Nolan-gothamite. Problem is, Cap won't be getting into any neck-lifting monologue challenges with Mr. Bane in this fight. He'll have Bane down in no time.

Originally posted by Inhuman
Can you specifically tell me or show me what scene in the movie displays Bane's "vast skill"? I want to see it with my own eyes.

You keep speaking of Bane's skill but I dont recall ever witnessing said skill in the movie. Show me because I have actually posted Bane scenes from the actual movie that show he is a slow basic type brawler.

He also has peak human strength. Nothing more.
Like i have said before real world martial artists break concrete blocks all the time. And real world strong men in the competitions regularly lift boulders and huge logs , sometimes with not too much effort.
Bane is not above real world strong men.

Visual speed is irrelevant to determine real fighting speed, otherwise Cap and WS would be vastly slower than real professional fighters. Batman can't possibly ko many many thugs in a matter of seconds moving slow as hell in real life.

No real human can bust through a solid stone column (that's over 4ft thick) with their fist. Concrete blocks are fluffy pillows compared to that. I use to bust multiple ones when I was in martial art class. If I punched that column then not only I wouldn't put a blemish on it (except my skin and blood) but I would break my hand.

Batman is a master from the league of shadows. So is Bane. That along proves skill.