Pre TPM Maul vs. TCW Ahsoka Tano

Started by DarthAnt665 pages

It should be noted that that fight was the first time Grievous ever dished out the spinning four-arms against Kenobi, as far as I'm aware. Obi-Wan wasn't well equipped to deal with that in an environment that was absurdly narrow and small, which favors Grievous greatly. Overall though, Grievous presenting a challenge to Kenobi doesn't mean he's on-level with Kenobi. Kenobi in TPM, as a 7, pressed Maul, an 8, and Anakin in AotC /TCW movie, as a 7, pressed Dooku, an 8. To me, the best indicator to see where you're at is if Grievous can do likewise (so, if we want to assume incorrectly that he's a 7, see how he does against 8s), and given he's losing to Ventress (I don't think nexus' in Canon work like they do in Legends, and even if so, there's no indicator or implication whatsoever that the nexus was the deciding factor there), I really doubt he's coming close to pressuring Dooku in any form. Thus, I associate Grievous' performance against Kenobi similar to Kenobi's against Maul's: Grievous, a 6, is able to compete with a 7, although he's inferior, thus why he generally has to resort to trickery and/or aid to help him.

Grievous<TPM Kenobi? What?

TPM Kenobi is roughly just as good as TCW Kenobi.

The only difference is one's using the dark-side "cheats" to be at 7, whereas TCW Kenobi has mastered his form to be a 7.

Different routes. Same outcome.

lmao That's some severe lowballing.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
TPM Kenobi is roughly just as good as TCW Kenobi.

The only difference is one's using the dark-side "cheats" to be at 7, whereas TCW Kenobi has mastered his form to be a 7.

Different routes. Same outcome.


I wonder hwo you reconcile this with TCW Kenobi's performances vs TCW Maul, a superior version of an 8 😬

Wait, TPM Kenobi=TCW Kenobi?

Originally posted by MythLord
lmao That's some severe lowballing.

That moment when fcking sithmaster makes more sense than you do

Than me? Or Ant?

Originally posted by Rockydonovang
I wonder hwo you reconcile this with TCW Kenobi's performances vs TCW Maul, a superior version of an 8 😬

TPM Maul's better than pre-Season 5 Maul, for starters. Not seeing what you're getting at though.

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
TPM Maul's better than pre-Season 5 Maul, for starters. Not seeing what you're getting at though.

and yet "fry" confirmed that powerful meant maul was superor in all aspects

Originally posted by MythLord
Than me? Or Ant?

Ant of course

Originally posted by Rockydonovang
and yet "fry" confirmed that powerful meant maul was superor in all aspects

Who's "fry?"

Jason fry, shadow conspiracy, explained that when he said maul wa smore powerful, that translated othim being more skilled and physically superior

Yeah that's not Canon, lmfao.

It doesn't have to be

Its an authoritative explantion of his own work, it holds weight, your rather baseless opinon saying otherwise doesn't

No, I mean the novel isn't Canon.

Fair point

But then we have oppress's implying Season 5 Maul was more powerful, and Maul off course having better TCW feats

Opress has never seen TPM Maul, so he has nothing to gauge off of. Mandalore Maul is better than TPM Maul, but probably not the earlier incarnations. His legs limit his mobility and acrobatic-potential, and he's not as focused.

Becoz we know talzin restored maul to his former power in season 4.
That Maul's legs are enough to bride the gap between him and Kenobi as swordsmen when Kenobi is outdueling him under unfavorable circumstances is pure spitballing