Ahsoka Tano vs Qui-Gon Jinn

Originally posted by thesithmaster
But him saving Ventress doesn't mean he could have finished Maul. Yeah, Maul was a bit staggered, but that doesn't mean he was vulnerable to a killing blow.

Originally posted by Rockydonovang
Maul was out for 5 seconds, Kenobi absolutely could have ended that

Nah it's still speculation. Anakin was floored by Dooku for close to 10 seconds in ROTS. Does that mean Dooku could have absolutely ended him?

No, we can't say for sure. All we can say for sure is that Dooku and Obi-Wan were beating Anakin and Maul at those earlier stages of the fight.

Qui gon solidly

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Nah it's still speculation. Anakin was floored by Dooku for close to 10 seconds in ROTS. Does that mean Dooku could have absolutely ended him?

No, we can't say for sure. All we can say for sure is that Dooku and Obi-Wan were beating Anakin and Maul at those earlier stages of the fight.

The ROTS novel seriously disagrees. Anakin was running all over Dooku.

But Maul and Anakin there had the luxury of time due to Kenobi and Dooku doing other things.

Originally posted by thesithmaster

But Maul and Anakin there had the luxury of time due to Kenobi and Dooku doing other things.

Yeah that's my point. We can't just assume that they would carry on lying there if being directly attacked.

All we can say is the fight seemed to be going in Dooku and Kenobi's favour before said distractions.

https://i.giphy.com/media/2D51boXnKq4Jq/giphy.gif

Originally posted by thesithmaster
He won by kicking him around and making him force defeat. How is that not superior ability?

He won because of his use of Dun Moch causing Obi-Wan to be unbalanced. Not to mention, Kenobi was just beaten to shit by Savage...

Originally posted by ares834
He won because of his use of Dun Moch causing Obi-Wan to be unbalanced. Not to mention, Kenobi was just beaten to shit by Savage...

In CW microseries, Kenobi was fine after a bigger beating.

Originally posted by thesithmaster
In CW microseries, Kenobi was fine after a bigger beating.

Canon =/= Legends

Originally posted by Zenwolf
Canon =/= Legends

TCW is also part of the Legends continuity. And the microseries one was an inferior version of Kenobi.

Well even in Canon, Kanan was tortured for days before giving his best fight against the GI.

Kenobi being unbalanced (per Maul) and not in the right mind set (per Filoni) is why he lost.

Originally posted by thesithmaster
TCW is also part of the Legends continuity. And the microseries one was an inferior version of Kenobi.

Nah TCW is just Canon.