EP I Maul VS EP I Obi Wan

Fair 1v1 duel, no sucker punch allowed.

Maul. But to be fair, Sith do have a tendency to toy with and mock their opponents. If Maul does that then it could cost him again

Maul would kill him.

Obi Wan has the thickest plot armour, he wins easy

don't we already know how this goes based on Maul holding his own against Obi Wan and Qui Gon at the same time?

Even with Mauls rematch on Rebels, Obi-Wan still Bested Maul.

oh, well there you have it.

never seen Rebels. can't deal with that shitty art.

wait, Obi Wan is much older in Rebels, correct?

that fight isn't relevant since this is Obi wan from Episode 1

Rebels Kenobi has decades worth of experience and was a General on top of being a Jedi Master who already bested a more powerful and skilled Sith in Vader.

Lucky for Maul he ain't fighting that grizzled veteran.

Maul would kill E1 Kenobi in seconds. Only reason Padawan Kenobi could hold his own solo was because of him being filled with rage after Qui-Gon's death.

Is this regular Obi-Wan or rage-amped Obi-Wan? Because a pissed Kenobi was handing Maul his ass.

I am under the impression its regular Kenobi, but I could be wrong. I just automatically imaged TPM duel without QUi-Gon being present.

Well, then Maul wins. Any other version of Kenobi beats him, though.

Ep 1 Obi Wan only beat Maul because the guy acted like a cocky moron.

To be fair at least Obi Wan didn't look like he was about to have a heart attack like Qui Gon did.

Plus thank god that section of Naboo had the perfect place for a lightsaber fight with all these platforms and forcefields randomly going on and off. That was just good luck all around.

Originally posted by Surtur
Ep 1 Obi Wan only beat Maul because the guy acted like a cocky moron.

To be fair at least Obi Wan didn't look like he was about to have a heart attack like Qui Gon did.

Plus thank god that section of Naboo had the perfect place for a lightsaber fight with all these platforms and forcefields randomly going on and off. That was just good luck all around.

Honestly, if there wasn't a bottomless pit behind him for Maul exploit, Obi-Wan could have beaten him in that duel.

Originally posted by Psychotron
Honestly, if there wasn't a bottomless pit behind him for Maul exploit, Obi-Wan could have beaten him in that duel.

Nah Obi-Wan was floored and disarmed right in front of Maul even before he fell into the pit.

Originally posted by Psychotron
Well, then Maul wins. Any other version of Kenobi beats him, though.

AOTC Obi-Wan would still have a really hard time against TPM Maul. Even TCW Obi-Wanwas pretty even with TCW Maul. By ROTS Obi-Wan would probably win but it wouldn't be a stomp or anything IMO. Post ROTS it's Obi-Wan all the way.

Didn't he beat Maul and his brother at the same time in TCW? That sounds like he'd stomp him by RotS.

that was also an OLDER Obi Wan

Originally posted by marwash22
that was also an OLDER Obi Wan

Pre-RotS, though.

Originally posted by Psychotron
Didn't he beat Maul and his brother at the same time in TCW? That sounds like he'd stomp him by RotS.

H fought them both at the same time, hard to say he beat Maul though.

Same episode prior to that fight him and Maul had an extended 1 on 1 which seemed pretty equal.