Star Wars: The Mandalorian - Discussion Thread

Started by juggernaut7456 pages

Originally posted by Total Warrior
Baby Yoda is the future of the New Jedi Order alongside Rey and whoever will join it after ep. IX
I hope you are right. Baby Yoda will be 76 at the time of Rise of Skywalker and hopefully he goes through a growth spurt in the next 25 years which is possible because Yoda was training Jedi at 100 already.

I also don't think it's a coincidence this season will overlap with Episode 9's release date. Hoping for big things from Baby Yoda in the future.

Oh no no no.

^OH NO NO NO

Originally posted by ares834
Oh no no no.
tell him to **** off

Lol how badly could he mess up directing 1 episode?

Rians response: CHALLENGE ACCEPTED

Of course he's interested in directing... Rian is desperately seeking any sort of redemption/validation he can get after the trainwreck that is TLJ.

But even IF he were to direct an episode, it doesn't bother me, tbh. As long as Favreau is still writing the script, and Rian is *only* directing, I don't really care.

Well, he could still direct some cringy scene like Leia flying. That scene wasn’t even bad per se, that would have been a cool feat for her, but that way it was shot really made it embarrassing

That's a bit different, though.

Rian actually wrote the story/script for TLJ(with Kennedy's blessing), and then directed it. Flip side, The Mandalorian is Favreau's baby -- HE is writing the entire story, and is a producer for each episode.

So even if Rian were to direct an episode, at least he wouldn't be creating the content... He'd still be following Favreau's overall vision. That would be the saving grace, imo.

Do we know what area of the glaxy this show takes place in?

Outer Rim for sure.

Originally posted by Galan007
Outer Rim for sure.
I figured that much but this show isn't very good at giving the names of the planets aside from Sorgan in episode 4. Is Hutt space still a thing during this time?

There are only 2 outcomes I see for the baby.
Either dead by the series end. Season 3,4 whatever.
Or is hidden away somewhere untraceable.
Because if any force-users are around the vicinity of other people that can detect force users, then baby Yoda cannot stay hidden for long from Luke or Snoke, Kylo, Palp, or whomever else. And who knows what the range of them being able to sense Force users is.

Originally posted by juggernaut74
I figured that much but this show isn't very good at giving the names of the planets aside from Sorgan in episode 4. Is Hutt space still a thing during this time?
Yeah, the only other planet that has been named so far is Arvala-7, where Kuiil lives(and where baby Yoda was being held)... And I only know that because it's listed on his SW.com bio:
https://www.starwars.com/databank/kuiil

Originally posted by Inhuman
There are only 2 outcomes I see for the baby.
Either dead by the series end. Season 3,4 whatever.
Or is hidden away somewhere untraceable.
Because if any force-users are around the vicinity of other people that can detect force users, then baby Yoda cannot stay hidden for long from Luke or Smoke, Kylo or whomever else. And who knows what the range of them being able to sense Force users is.
It could also transition into them searching for the homeworld of Yoda's species(its location has never been revealed in any SW lore.) Handing baby Yoda over to his own people would effectively keep him safe AND take him off the grid.

My guess is Yoda and Yaddles homeworld is in the unknown regions.

I think it would be cool to go to Maz's castle to find out info on baby Yoda and where he comes from because if anyone would know it would be her.

Originally posted by Inhuman
Because if any force-users are around the vicinity of other people that can detect force users, then baby Yoda cannot stay hidden for long from Luke or Snoke, Kylo, Palp, or whomever else. And who knows what the range of them being able to sense Force users is.

Palpatine kept his force ability hidden for years though and he was surrounded by them at times, lots of them, Vader could only sense 'something' when both Kenobi and Luke were aboard the Death Star, Kylo didn't seem to have much of a clue about Rey (although might need a rewatch of TFA to confirm), Maul needed a tracking device to locate Padme's ship on Tatooine IIRC and Yoda, Ahsoka, Maul and one or two others I'll bet managed to remain hidden canonically for years. Just saying I'm not sure the 'Detect Force User' power is as infallible as it might seem (if it even exists at all).

No, you're right. The difference is that most force users who are capable of hiding in plain sight like that have been proper Jedi/Sith, who have learned to mask their presence through years of training... Baby Yoda obviously doesn't have that training(not yet, at least.)

However, newer canon material, like the Force Collector novel, makes it clear that there are force-sensitive beings(who can use the force to varying degrees) sprinkled all over the galaxy, and they aren't being actively tracked down by anyone. So yeah... /shrug

So is it some sort of scale, then? Like, unless this person has x out of 10 on the force sensitivity scale, they get left alone?

It's just inconsistency, tbh.

TFA implied that there hadn't been an "awakening" in the force for a LONG time -- almost like 'new' force-sensitives were borderline non-existent by that point. So when one finally surfaced(ie. Rey), they immediately took notice.

But fast-forward to current canon, like the Force Collector novel I mentioned above(which is set shortly before TFA), and we know that is definitely not the case. There are still force-users popping up all over the galaxy(which honestly makes sense... I mean, why would that just stop?)

The novel's protagonist is one of those, for example. He used the force a number of times throughout the story.

Originally posted by Galan007
No, you're right. The difference is that most force users who are capable of hiding in plain sight like that have been proper Jedi/Sith, who have learned to mask their presence through years of training... Baby Yoda obviously doesn't have that training(not yet, at least.)

However, newer canon material, like the Force Collector novel, makes it clear that there are force-sensitive beings(who can use the force to varying degrees) sprinkled all over the galaxy, and they aren't being actively tracked down by anyone. So yeah... /shrug

I thought that, but it doesn't really explain ANH Luke and Rey getting by largely unnoticed, also, if it's an ability that has to be activated or concentrated on in some way, it doesn't really explain why Maul needed drones and such to find them on Tatooine when Qui-Gonn and Obi-Wan had no idea that the Sith still existed, much less that one was stalking them. (I know I'm over-geeking here.)

I'd like to read some of the new canon stuff, but honestly Disney are failing at the big things, I don't hold out much hope of them delivering with the small things.

Galan, could you post scans from the Force collector like tou did with other contents?