Originally posted by Blindside12
Nether did the Avengers, three times.Tony: I'm bringing them right to you. (Meaning Middle of NYC)
Yes, Tony brought the Leviathan to the only people capable of stopping it. Although I suppose he could be more like Superman and just let it run wild through the city killing people.
Originally posted by Silent Master
No, the Frost Giants started at the hostilities by invading Asgard. Even if you consider Thor as having started the hostilities, him hitting two people does not give everyone the right to try and kill him and his friends.
Odin told Thor to drop it therefore Thor was legally obligated to obey. He broke the law by going there and began the hostilities because he doesn't like name calling.
There's a law that states if you are commiting a crime then any deaths that occur can be murder charges on you. I remember this because some guys broke into a woman's house and she shot one to death and the other was charged with his murder. Pretty similar situation here. Thor and company "broke in" and began wrecking shit. Murder.
Originally posted by Blindside12
Nether did the Avengers, three times.Tony: I'm bringing them right to you. (Meaning Middle of NYC)
Originally posted by SquallX
You mean just like the Hulk did Cap told him to go wild right?Or when Tony was casually fighting the Hulk in the city in part 2?
To be fair, SM did state that some of the Avengers are murderers in his opinion.
Originally posted by juggerman
Odin told Thor to drop it therefore Thor was legally obligated to obey. He broke the law by going there and began the hostilities because he doesn't like name calling.There's a law that states if you are commiting a crime then any deaths that occur can be murder charges on you. I remember this because some guys broke into a woman's house and she shot one to death and the other was charged with his murder. Pretty similar situation here. Thor and company "broke in" and began wrecking shit. Murder.
Post the Asgardian law that states Thor has to do everything Odin says or face legal consequences?
Actually I just re-watched the scene from Thor, going against his farther was breaking Asgardian law. so you have a point there.
However, we don't know what their laws are in regards to what constitues murder. or even if either of the two Frost Giants Thor hit before he and his friends were attacked even died.
Yeah I thought it was a law. I mean when a king orders you not to do something I think you're supposed to obey. And from what we've seen from Thor and his hammer I think it's safe to say they died, but even if they didn't all the other deaths were still on Thor.
What do you think of the idea of aliens like Thor and Kal not being subject to human laws? I'm on the fence.
Originally posted by juggerman
Yeah I thought it was a law. I mean when a king orders you not to do something I think you're supposed to obey. And from what we've seen from Thor and his hammer I think it's safe to say they died, but even if they didn't all the other deaths were still on Thor.What do you think of the idea of aliens like Thor and Kal not being subject to human laws? I'm on the fence.
If they're living on the Earth as a citizen, they are subject to Earth's laws. if they are just visiting, they might have some form of diplomatic immunity. no way to know for sure unless the movie/tv show actually brings it up.