Magneto vs. Hulk

Started by Surtur4 pages
Surtur Restricted

Something will stop him before he gets close. Snag him up by the leg when he is running or swat him out of the air if he leaps.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Surtur
Something will stop him before he gets close. Snag him up by the leg when he is running or swat him out of the air if he leaps.
Imagination debating without anything substantial to back it up. Fanboy. Hulk wins based off the evidence.

Surtur Restricted
Originally posted by quanchi112
Imagination debating without anything substantial to back it up. Fanboy. Hulk wins based off the evidence.

It's looking at what the guy can do when he puts his mind to it, but okay. We'll have to agree to disagree. You say I'm a fanboy, but I'm not. I think Magneto is a cool character, but that is about it.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Surtur
It's looking at what the guy can do when he puts his mind to it, but okay. We'll have to agree to disagree. You say I'm a fanboy, but I'm not. I think Magneto is a cool character, but that is about it.
You just said something will stop him basically saying I don't know but I bet he could. That's being biased. Hulk leapt at the leviathan and changed its momentum. You think magneto can whip up so etching bigger and more durable than that in no time. Get real.

Surtur Restricted
Originally posted by quanchi112
You just said something will stop him basically saying I don't know but I bet he could. That's being biased. Hulk leapt at the leviathan and changed its momentum. You think magneto can whip up so etching bigger and more durable than that in no time. Get real.

I'm basing it on the feats he showed in the movie. Whipping up metal objects quite fast. Showing an ability to rip up material from the ground. We can extrapolate on things you know. It's not a bias.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Surtur
I'm basing it on the feats he showed in the movie. Whipping up metal objects quite fast. Showing an ability to rip up material from the ground. We can extrapolate on things you know. It's not a bias.
Well base it off evidence and base it off a time with something you've seen on screen. You can't just make shit up in your head and think that's concrete evidence.

Stigma Herald of the Judgement

So the general consensus seems to be that Magneto wins decisively here.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Stigma
So the general consensus seems to be that Magneto wins decisively here.
Evidence favors Hulk.

Evidence>popularity.

TheLordofMurder Senior Member

Evidence favors Magneto...

Bias favors quanchi...

Magneto wins baxsed on his planet shaking power...

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
Evidence favors Magneto...

Bias favors quanchi...

Magneto wins baxsed on his planet shaking power...

This isn't about who can rattle what it's about who wins in a fight. You've never been able to grasp relevance to irrelevance. Hulk is quicker, stronger, more durable, etc. He easily defeats Magneto once he gets ahold of him. Evidence and their actual powers actually matter.

Stigma Herald of the Judgement

Originally posted by TheLordofMurder
Evidence favors Magneto...

Bias favors quanchi...

Magneto wins baxsed on his planet shaking power...


Good points.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by Stigma
Good points.
Based on ?

FrothByte Nailcutter Massacre
Originally posted by Stigma
So the general consensus seems to be that Magneto wins decisively here.

No. I believe the consensus is Magneto wins if he is able to gather enough power fast enough before Hulk turns him into pulp.

John Murdoch Senior Member
Originally posted by FrothByte
No. I believe the consensus is Magneto wins if he is able to gather enough power fast enough before Hulk turns him into pulp.

Agreed sir.

ShadowFyre Senior Member

I personally see this as an endurance contest. If mags run out of energy he's toast. I'm honestly on the ropes on this one. Mags is pretty powerful.

carthage PLEASE PROTECT ME STONES

Hulk per current versions is wearing armor which means Magneto ragdolls him and crushes his head with his helmet or rapes him with his hammers

GG Hulk sucks compared to Erik

FrothByte Nailcutter Massacre

Originally posted by carthage
Hulk per current versions is wearing armor which means Magneto ragdolls him and crushes his head with his helmet or rapes him with his hammers

GG Hulk sucks compared to Erik

Hulk as last seen is without armor.

quanchi112 Disney

Originally posted by carthage
Hulk per current versions is wearing armor which means Magneto ragdolls him and crushes his head with his helmet or rapes him with his hammers

GG Hulk sucks compared to Erik

Hulk was not wearing armor at the end of the film. You're not clever are you. This isn't Hulk with his armor on Sakaar.