Arcann vs. Darth Maul

Started by The Ellimist16 pages
Originally posted by AncientPower
It's the potency of the power that caused the devastation which is the point here. It was potent enough that it raged on and burnt the entire city block down.

Lmao you realize that all sorts of mundane things like cigarettes and gas stoves have done that right?

Originally posted by SunRazer
Another mental breakdown. 😂 😆

Nah, I came in here hoping for an actual debate with ILS but you lot decided to cherry-pick a single feat which was of the least importance to my argument.

It's sad to see you're actually stooping to that level though.

Originally posted by AncientPower
if I cared. [/B]

AP atm:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UxxajLWwzqY
Get your goth on brah, or is it bruh, can never be too sure with one like yourself.

Originally posted by AncientPower
They've reverted to cherry-picking a single feat, and actual trolling, so 👆 basically.

I think I gave a pretty apt rebuttal to your citadel wordplay by pointing out that it's a pretty common literary technique but go ahead and keep ignoring our arguments to complain about us not giving you arguments lol

Originally posted by The Ellimist
Lmao you realize that all sorts of mundane things like cigarettes and gas stoves have done that right?

So, let me get this straight. Your brigade has gone on for years about how mindless, senseless and badly written TOR's power creep is. But when it comes to the actual displays of power, you all revert to attempting to find context in said power feats where there's none implied?

Seems logical.

Originally posted by AncientPower
Nah, I came in here hoping for an actual debate with ILS but you lot decided to cherry-pick a single feat which was of the least importance to my argument.

It's sad to see you're actually stooping to that level though.

The only person who's stooped to anything is you, with your blatant double standards and fact denials/distortions. Worse than stooping, you've actually stopped using your brain.

You're not even going to offer your attempt at a refutation of his logic?

Concede already, lmao

AP now:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OQfjIw3mivc

*ahem*

Originally posted by ILS
This level of delusion is surreal. You have convinced yourself everyone else is wrong that the two Sith participating in a Kaggath, which "pits the power bases and resources" of the Sith against each other, and can span entire star systems, must have used telekinesis to destroy the citadel. The possibility that their huge military resources which includes capital ships could have caused the destruction has totally escaped your mind.

Originally posted by AncientPower
So, let me get this straight. Your brigade has gone on for years about how mindless, senseless and badly written TOR's power creep is. But when it comes to the actual displays of power, you all revert to attempting to find context in said power feats where there's none implied?

Seems logical.

I mean just read the quote it says that it burns down the city block as some sort of eventual effect, not that it literally blows up the block in its blast radius. This implies a chain reaction, which if it just burns one apartment building or whatever can easily spread to the entire block depending on the arrangement and flammability of the buildings. E.g. it could just be open-gas-stove level.

You complain about the level of intellectual discourse but I see you outright ignoring arguments and giving zero-substance appeals to incredulity to others, so I'm not sure how I'm supposed to buy it.

Originally posted by The Ellimist
I think I gave a pretty apt rebuttal to your citadel wordplay by pointing out that it's a pretty common literary technique but go ahead and keep ignoring our arguments to complain about us not giving you arguments lol

I'd agree, if not for the fact that it's said that the other DC members executed both of the combatants of the actual duelwhen they drew. Nor have I seen any reason to explain why the rest of the Empire would watch two armies devastate Kaas city when the entire idea of the Kaggath is to fight off of Sith space. Nor have I seen any explanation for the fact that it's specifically stated in the Encyclopedia that the resources of both of their powerbases are fully intact and are ready to be used by Darth Nostrem to construct the new citadel.

I have an idea, one I want everyone to take very seriously.

Why doesn't every single person on the forum put AP on ignore. All of us, right now. Maybe just for a week, see what happens. Pretend he doesn't exist.

If you're with me, do it now.

Originally posted by AncientPower
I'd agree, if not for the fact that it's said that the other DC members executed both of the combatants of the actual duelwhen they drew.

Lmfao yes of course it's not uncommon to execute the leaders of military organizations when they order their organizations to do illegal things.


Nor have I seen any reason to explain why the rest of the Empire would watch two armies devastate Kaas city when the entire idea of the Kaggath is to fight off of Sith space.

Yeah it went against the Empire's wishes hence whey they were executed...

Nor have I seen any explanation for the fact that it's specifically stated in the Encyclopedia that the resources of both of their powerbases are fully intact and are ready to be used by Darth Nostrem to construct the new citadel.

*Citation needed*

@ILS

Reported. 😬

But please do provide an actual response instead of showboating.

If you want to argue ambiguity regarding the citadel and city block feats then I fully expect the same from you regarding the Rivi Anu and Anakin feats.

@Ell, I'm already in the middle of asking others to get the exact quote for me. Mine's at home.

Originally posted by ILS
Why doesn't every single person on the forum put AP on ignore.

Where's the fun in that?
Like seriously:
Reported.

Stop being such a buzzkill swords.

Nor have I seen any explanation for the fact that it's specifically stated in the Encyclopedia that the resources of both of their powerbases are fully intact and are ready to be used by Darth Nostrem to construct the new citadel
What on earth... that they had resources left over to rebuild does not mean they didn't use said resources to cause the damage...

What am I reading?

Originally posted by ILS
I have an idea, one I want everyone to take very seriously.

Why doesn't every single person on the forum put AP on ignore. All of us, right now. Maybe just for a week, see what happens. Pretend he doesn't exist.

If you're with me, do it now.

👆👆👆

Originally posted by AncientPower

@Ell, I'm already in the middle of asking others to get the exact quote for me. Mine's at home.


Gloss cover or nah?

I'm more than happy enough to throw all four feats out of the window and continue if appeals to ambiguity are being used, whether ILS can recover from such a loss to the crux of his scaling argument is another question.

AP, got a proposal for you. 1v1 kaggath style debate, me repping Maul and you repping Arcann. Public vote determines the winner. Loser leaves KMC forever.

What do you say? That way neither of us have any excuses. The spotlight will be shone directly on our arguments.