Captain Marvel Vs Big Barda

Started by Sin I AM3 pages
Originally posted by One Big Mob
Did they actually give Carol an on panel powerup, or is she just receiving very favorable writing that turns into a permanent powerup?

she's done nothing, i liked her better as ms marvel

She dusted Tony's prepped armor.

https://comicnewbies.files.wordpress.com/2017/01/captain-marvel-beats-iron-man-civil-war-ii-7.jpg

but her limits are clear.

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11113/111137054/4267700-avengers+%282012-%29+039-018.jpg
https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11113/111137054/4267701-avengers+%282012-%29+039-019.jpg

That was when she still had somewhat long hair.

Once Ewing got his grubby mitts on Carol is when she seemed to change in power. Then Bendis followed suit. Then even Ewing was like "woah, is that the type of message I'm trying to send? I better dial this back."

Under Ewing she's more powerful than Blue Marvel. Bendis Ms Marvel is more powerful.
Anything before that was a seemingly weaker form.

Tbf everyone dusts Tony with prep

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Tbf everyone dusts Tony with prep

pretty much...he doesnt get mcu love in comics

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Tbf everyone dusts Tony with prep
he seems to do better when he doesn't have prep tbh.

She didn't even use Binary against big suit Tony and she trashed him that entire fight. All she prepped against was the one blast. That was complete shit

well CW2 was complete shit

I don't put much stock into the Iron Man thing. In that same dumb arc, Tony got smacked around by Karnak and Black Panther, who restrained him somehow.

https://postimg.org/image/dk2e75uhx/

It's not the "prepped" suit, but if he is that shitty normally, it's totally possible his amped suit is barely Carol level, and she absorbs energy, making her a bit problematic for him. Also, Bendis.

Outside of this, she punched an already weakened and battered Thanos, while being amped by Blue Marvel. And split an asteroid. I'm just not seeing the upgrades here tbh. We could argue a mild increase to her base strength before absorbing anything I guess.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Tbf everyone dusts Tony with prep

True enough

As for Barda, if we wanted to explore a case for Carol, I think it would hinge upon her ranged abilities. If she really pours on the ranged energy assault like against Tony at times, she might make the fight competitive.

https://postimg.org/image/4p1jx0vj9/
https://postimg.org/image/uklag7pn9/

Thanks for the in depth replies, KMCers.

Originally posted by Damborgson
She dusted Tony's prepped armor.

https://comicnewbies.files.wordpress.com/2017/01/captain-marvel-beats-iron-man-civil-war-ii-7.jpg

but her limits are clear.

https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11113/111137054/4267700-avengers+%282012-%29+039-018.jpg
https://static.comicvine.com/uploads/original/11113/111137054/4267701-avengers+%282012-%29+039-019.jpg

That was when she was more feminine and had longer hair. She's the reverse Sampson. Before, she needed large amounts of energy to push her into top tier, like a Nuke or a black hole/white hole (Aka Binary), but now she's walking around at Top Tier levels apparently.

I think the more of a lesbian she becomes, the greater she grows in power.

And Hulk could easily dust Barda in hand to hand like that on a good day so it's not really relevant.

Originally posted by StyleTime
As for Barda, if we wanted to explore a case for Carol, I think it would hinge upon her ranged abilities. If she really pours on the ranged energy assault like against Tony at times, she might make the fight competitive.

https://postimg.org/image/4p1jx0vj9/
https://postimg.org/image/uklag7pn9/

Barda's Mega Rod has withstood and deflected Grail's Omega Beams [which have, among others, one-shot Diana's bracelets]. There's also the motherbox, and depending on how much leeway you want to give Barda in its use of it, it would nullify basically everything.

Yeah, Barda is basically a better fighter, with better gear. She wins the high majority.

Nothing happens when I try and quote Phil for some reason.

Anyways, yeah. I was just trying to throw Carol whatever bone I could think of. If she can amp off the mega rod, she might make things interesting. But that is about the extent of that argument.

Mother box in full effect makes that moot of course.

Originally posted by StyleTime
I don't put much stock into the Iron Man thing. In that same dumb arc, Tony got smacked around by Karnak and Black Panther, who restrained him somehow.

https://postimg.org/image/dk2e75uhx/

It's not the "prepped" suit, but if he is that shitty normally, it's totally possible his amped suit is barely Carol level, and she absorbs energy, making her a bit problematic for him. Also, Bendis.

Outside of this, she punched an already weakened and battered Thanos, while being amped by Blue Marvel. And split an asteroid. I'm just not seeing the upgrades here tbh. We could argue a mild increase to her base strength before absorbing anything I guess.


👆

Don't really see the big bump in power.

She did have one high end showing that I recall. Shared, but pretty uber.
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/-N_zWq_o1asw/Vmvm0qI3BfI/AAAAAAAT0x8/qKwpCu-CShU/s1600/11_13.jpg

Other than that, nothing really eye popping.