Immortal Hulk Vs. Mangog

Started by Sin I AM11 pages

i think Simon couldve

Originally posted by Sin I AM
i think Simon couldve
Based on all the other Hulk fights, it did seem to be leading up to another classic Wonderman win

Originally posted by The Sorrow
Doesn't sound like you read the book based on this post tbh.

Hercules hurt his hand after his first punch, putting to bed the "holding back" nonsense. There were comments about how every blow Thor and Herc were dishing out resembled thunderclaps, don't get it twisted they were trying real hard to put Hulk down. They failed individually so Jane suggested attacking together. IMO it's pretty obvious there were parts of this fight that happened off-panel, the dialogue implies as much, but ultimately I think the point was Jane Thor and Hercules (and Rogue) couldn't stop Hulk no matter what tactic they tried.

Based on the tactics they could use. Seriously? Jane could have punched Hulk intothesun easily, let the hammer, nuclear level lightning blast, mother storm etc.

They will never have Hulk fight a Thor that is actually using his/her full abilities. He'd get his shit pushed in.

Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Based on the tactics they could use. Seriously? Jane could have punched Hulk intothesun easily, let the hammer, nuclear level lightning blast, mother storm etc.

They will never have Hulk fight a Thor that is actually using his/her full abilities. He'd get his shit pushed in.

everyone who fights the hulk does so on his level...except surfer

this battle could last for eternity mangog feeding on the hate of a billion billion persons in the universe and if i remember correctly only RKT had an easy victory over him againt somone whose strength increases according to the level of his anger(its almost like the unsttopable force vs the immovable object)unless a powerful cosmic entity separates them,they just continue to wreck everything in their path.=TIE

Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Based on the tactics they could use. Seriously? Jane could have punched Hulk intothesun easily, let the hammer, nuclear level lightning blast, mother storm etc.

They will never have Hulk fight a Thor that is actually using his/her full abilities. He'd get his shit pushed in.


It's not easy in the slightest when Hulk is the strongest hero on Earth, he rarely ever gets bfr'd by physical force because it takes a crazy amount to do so. Jane used powers that made sense in their fight and fought exactly as a Thor does, brawn first - that isn't because of Hulk it ingrained in the character. Bar plot device like mother storm eating supernovas and crap it almost always comes down to power vs power with Thor until they're forced to think outside the box or they're defeated.

I can get behind the idea that it may not have been Jane Thors absolute max damage output (depends what the writers intent was) but to make out as if she wasn't trying or majorly holding back is reaching and not backed up by the comic.

But Jane isn't Thor. That is to say, she doesn't have memories or experiences of Thor.

So why is it in character of a 'Thor' to brawl, and how does that make sense when it's Jane, who does thing throughout her run that they explicitly said Odinson didn't? She was a fresh new take, a fresh new perspective, until it came to Hulk, it seems.

Remind me, when did Jane and Hulk fight again?

Google only returns the movie fight, or a bunch of forum fights with Totally Awesome Hulk.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
But Jane isn't Thor. That is to say, she doesn't have memories or experiences of Thor.

So why is it in character of a 'Thor' to brawl, and how does that make sense when it's Jane, who does thing throughout her run that they explicitly said Odinson didn't? She was a fresh new take, a fresh new perspective, until it came to Hulk, it seems.

thats because everyone from zeus to thor to iron man to strange HAS to fight Hulk h2h in order to give hulk something of a fight

Originally posted by Sin I AM
thats because everyone from zeus to thor to iron man to strange HAS to fight Hulk h2h in order to give hulk something of a fight
You should spend less time on KMC and more time cooking and cleaning. 😂

A lot of good points are being made

Originally posted by cdtm
Remind me, when did Jane and Hulk fight again?

Google only returns the movie fight, or a bunch of forum fights with Totally Awesome Hulk.

avengers 686...

Originally posted by Hildabeast 2020
You should spend less time on KMC and more time cooking and cleaning. 😂

i weep for what youve become....tragic

Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Based on the tactics they could use. Seriously? Jane could have punched Hulk intothesun easily, let the hammer, nuclear level lightning blast, mother storm etc.

They will never have Hulk fight a Thor that is actually using his/her full abilities. He'd get his shit pushed in.

She couldn't even budge him with a hammer shot filled with lightning. What makes you think she could have hit him to the sun?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
But Jane isn't Thor. That is to say, she doesn't have memories or experiences of Thor.

So why is it in character of a 'Thor' to brawl, and how does that make sense when it's Jane, who does thing throughout her run that they explicitly said Odinson didn't? She was a fresh new take, a fresh new perspective, until it came to Hulk, it seems.

What did she do against Mangog and Odin when she fought them?

Originally posted by Sin I AM
thats because everyone from zeus to thor to iron man to strange HAS to fight Hulk h2h in order to give hulk something of a fight

So if I show you these people going versatile on Hulk, would you accept that you didn't know what you were talking about?

Originally posted by ShadowFyre
Based on the tactics they could use. Seriously? Jane could have punched Hulk intothesun easily, let the hammer, nuclear level lightning blast, mother storm etc.

They will never have Hulk fight a Thor that is actually using his/her full abilities. He'd get his shit pushed in.


I've never read something so profoundly ridiculous.
Jane couldn't have punched Hulk to the Sun in fact her attacks couldn't even budge him, what is nuclear level lighting blast gonna do when he tanked things, he eats nuclear level blast for breakfast, mother storm could have given her the win but considering they are fighting on Earth she'd destroy the Earth as well and also she needs to ask the mother storm for help.
Thor has fought Hulk going all out on at least 4 different occasions, either by himself stating it or the narration, in fact they even had Thor said he wanted to kill Hulk on 3 separate occasions.
Thor fights Hulk how he fights every other powerhouse, even in Blood and Thunder when Thor was at his strongest and one-two shotting herald level characters all he still did was swing his hammer at them wildly. So Thor prefers brawling and brawling is Hulks game unfortunately for him.

Originally posted by Sin I AM
thats because everyone from zeus to thor to iron man to strange HAS to fight Hulk h2h in order to give hulk something of a fight

That's actually untrue.

Originally posted by carver9
What did she do against Mangog when she fought them?

She went all out.
😉

Then cheated with a nigh indestructible rope.

Originally posted by carver9
So if I show you these people going versatile on Hulk, would you accept that you didn't know what you were talking about?

u can show me zeus, thor and strange not resorting to h2h and fighting hulk to the best of their abilities? sure y not. challenge accepted.

Originally posted by Subnero89
That's actually untrue.

show me your true form...stop being a coward