Superman gauntlet

One person is saying whirlwind, another is saying Saturn Ring, and the other is saying he was ejected (which means he was transported) near Saturn. These fans are all over the place.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
This whirlwind scene:

Is NOT THIS:

They look pretty similar, but one has him punching through a hole in Saturn's rings, whereas the first is the whirlwind.

Tbh, it looks more similar than most recap scenes, which is pretty impressive. I'll take your word for it but I would be REALLY surprised if it wasn't the case. When I have a minute, I'll read the entire story-line.

Even his hair is basically identical. I wouldn't be surprised if he traced the first one.

I'm saying both.

Read the text Carver. Superman specifically says he was punching through Saturn's rings. We can even see the hole he punches.

Your own scans show Brainiac using his whirlwind, and Superman then flying off.

What is YOUR interpretation?

Originally posted by Rage.Of.Olympus
Are you sure? When I have a minute, I'll read the entire story-line. Because that looks like the exact same scene in another comic.

Tbh, it looks more similar than most recap scenes, which is pretty impressive. I'll take your word for it but I would be REALLY surprised if it wasn't the case.

Supes specifically says he's punching through the rings. No argument there.

We see the hole he's punched. No argument there either.

Now, if we believe the scenes to be exactly the same, that would mean in Carver's scans, the whirlwind from Brainiac, which looks exactly like Saturn's rings, deposited Superman at Saturn. And he then flew on, and the text about sixty days makes....zero sense.

I thought I remember you guys arguing this before about him dipping into black holes and shit? It's such a pointless argument though that I didn't pay too much attention and I won't now

Yeah, I think you're right.

I was wrong about it being a black hole. Supes WAS deposited into one, and he had no memory other then him and Brainiac going down the well.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
I'm saying both.

Read the text Carver. Superman specifically says he was punching through Saturn's rings. We can even see the hole he punches.

Your own scans show Brainiac using his whirlwind, and Superman then flying off.

What is YOUR interpretation?

I'm not disputing him punching through Saturn moon, lol, I'm talking about him flying from one end of the Universe to earth.

Originally posted by One Big Mob
I thought I remember you guys arguing this before about him dipping into black holes and shit? It's such a pointless argument though that I didn't pay too much attention and I won't now

Come on Bran... I want to see your interpretation of it. The issue is there for you to read. .

Originally posted by cdtm
Yeah, I think you're right.

I was wrong about it being a black hole. Supes WAS deposited into one, and he had no memory other then him and Brainiac going down the well.

Because his memory was erased and he was tossed right at Saturns ring. We see the same wormhole that Brainiac used to throw him back.

Originally posted by carver9
I'm not disputing him punching through Saturn moon, lol, I'm talking about him flying from one end of the Universe to earth.

The scan and the issue you posted isn't the same as the scan Abhi posted, that's my point.

In HIS scan, it specifically says he has been flying for 60days through endless space, non stop. No memory loss there, he REMEMBERS 60 days of flying.

YOUR scan just shows Brainiac whirlwinding Superman into....well, the upper atmosphere of that planet.

So why can't they both be right? After that whirlwind, he then starts flying, for sixty days, until he punches through the rings and returns to Earth (which happens to look like the whirlwind)?

In abhis scan, that's not a black hole. That's the hole he's just punched in Saturn's rings.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Supes specifically says he's punching through the rings. No argument there.

We see the hole he's punched. No argument there either.

Now, if we believe the scenes to be exactly the same, that would mean in Carver's scans, the whirlwind from Brainiac, which looks exactly like Saturn's rings, deposited Superman at Saturn. And he then flew on, and the text about sixty days makes....zero sense.

Superman memories was erased/replaced, its said right there in the issue I posted. He THOUGHT he was flying through space but he was truly stuck with Brainiac the entire time and thrown back.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
The scan and the issue you posted isn't the same as the scan Abhi posted, that's my point.

In HIS scan, it specifically says he has been flying for 60days through endless space, non stop.

YOUR scan just shows Brainiac whirlwinding Superman into....well, the upper atmosphere of that planet.

So why can't they both be right? After that whirlwind, he then starts flying, for sixty days, until he punches through the rings and returns to Earth (which happens to look like the whirlwind)?

Read above please. They are the same exact scene. He just dont know what happened in between the time he was gone because everything was erased.

Originally posted by carver9
I'm not disputing him punching through Saturn moon, lol, I'm talking about him flying from one end of the Universe to earth.

What else do you need?

Originally posted by carver9
Read above please. They are the same exact scene. He just dont know what happened in between the time he was gone because everything was erased.

But he remembers 60 days of flying.

That's not a black hole. That's a hole HE punched through, as per the text.

Originally posted by carver9
Because his memory was erased and he was tossed right at Saturns ring. We see the same wormhole that Brainiac used to throw him back.

Originally posted by carver9
Here is where he was transported, lol...

The next page, this happens...

Lol... it isn't a flight ft.

The manner and path of your return will ensure you forget EVERYTHING. Lol... he THOUGHT he flew back. It didn't happen.

Wait so how can he lose memories, but also remember 60days of flying?

Like you yourself emphasize...forget EVERYTHING. So he what, simultaneously forgets but also remembers?

Originally posted by carver9
Come on Bran... I want to see your interpretation of it. The issue is there for you to read. .

I'm more of an old timer though, and I don't think "heroes" should even fly. That is the direct work of the Luciferian age we're living in now.

Originally posted by carver9
The manner and path of your return will ensure you forget EVERYTHING. Lol... he THOUGHT he flew back. It didn't happen.

He remembered flying through space for sixty days.

This oddly reminds me of yo momma jokes.

Superman forgot so hard, he remembered flying through the Universe.