Rebirth Superman vs. Thor

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Again... Stop mixing the two series. I don't care about the Man o War series. That was under Fraction. This series was written by a totally different writer. It has nothing to do with the other.
This series was shown in an official Thor handbook that gave a chronological history of the character.

So was Man of War and its still out of continuity.

Again what part of Trial/Rage shows that it is out of continuity?

The part where first Ragnarok is mentioned. Modern Asgardians didn't know about Ragnarok.

Lol... Do u know how different a character can be portrayed writer to writer or era to era? I know you know....

😂

That's your excuse? I guess Fenris can kill Odin and get killed by Tyr now?

Uhh... The Asgardians died at least twice recently.

Thor hasn't died in Ragnarok though.

Anyway, Rage of Thor/Trial of Thor are both out of continuity. Deal with it.

Originally posted by abhilegend
So was Man of War and its still out of continuity.

The part where first Ragnarok is mentioned. Modern Asgardians didn't know about Ragnarok.

Lol.. Modern Asgardians. Oh the reach. That statement about 1st Ragnarok only confirms that Asgardians go through similar cycles over and over.

I worry about u sometimes.

Originally posted by abhilegend

😂

That's your excuse? I guess Fenris can kill Odin and get killed by Tyr now?

Thor hasn't died in Ragnarok though.

Anyway, Rage of Thor/Trial of Thor are both out of continuity. Deal with it.

Been mentioned a few times. Fenrir grows big enuff to swallow the sun. Which he did btw in one of the recent rag cycles.

So nothing in the story that makes it out of continuity.... 👆

Instead of worrying so much about continuity in Thor books, worry about continuity in New God books. That shiet is a clusterphukk.

This is almost as bad when u tried to refute the Thor story in Breaking Into Comics the Marvel Way. Even after it was shown in another official handbook and editor/writer official interviews saying it was canon. Some of your reasoning was just beyond the pale.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Lol... Man o War wasn't shown in the actual meat of the chronological history. It was cited at the end of the handbook for supplemental reading. Smh..

Lol.. Modern Asgardians. Oh the reach. That statement about 1st Ragnarok only confirms that Asgardians go through similar cycles over and over.

I worry about u sometimes.

It's not an excuse. It is fact.

Been mentioned a few times. Fenrir grows big enuff to swallow the sun. Which he did btw in one of the recent rag cycles.

So nothing in the story that makes it out of continuity.... 👆

Instead of worrying so much about continuity in Thor books, worry about continuity in New God books. That shiet is a clusterphukk.

Your Pattern:
Thor has ridiculous feat...

Downplay the feat- fails to do so

Refute the book that shows the feat - fails to do so

Refute the source that cited the book with the feat - fails to do so

Throw everything including the kitchen sink to muddy the waters if all else fails - never works

Thor fighting a copy of himself and making Asgard's ground shake while he in in Warrior Madness is worthy of being argued for pages of its 'canocity'? Nevermind that it's obviously not canon but..

...This is..quite weird, for such a 'meh' feat.

Damborg, Abhi? Any...particular reason? lol

facepalm

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Your Pattern:
Thor has ridiculous feat...

Downplay the feat- fails to do so

Refute the book that shows the feat - fails to do so

Refute the source that cited the book with the feat - fails to do so

Throw everything including the kitchen sink to muddy the waters if all else fails - never works

Here is the chronology of Thor as per mighty Thor saga itself.

https://imgur.com/gallery/qe9X0A3

You will notice Trial of Thor/Rage of Thor are not included there.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Your Pattern:
Thor has ridiculous feat...

Downplay the feat- fails to do so

Refute the book that shows the feat - fails to do so

Refute the source that cited the book with the feat - fails to do so

Throw everything including the kitchen sink to muddy the waters if all else fails - never works

Originally posted by abhilegend
Seriously?

Here is the chronology of Thor as per mighty Thor saga itself.

https://imgur.com/gallery/qe9X0A3

You will notice Trial of Thor/Rage of Thor are not included there.

Lol who do u think pointed out that list earlier that funnily enough includes the other series you are trying to refute(Thor Man o War)? What are you trying to do, show me something I haven't seen? Smh...

That there is a suggested reading list that gives a good representation of the character. Not everything canon to Thor is listed there... For example showings in other series like Avengers, and a plethora of other books, etc... You do know that right?

While on the other hand, scenes from the particular series in question(Trial/Rage) was actually printed in the actual meat of the handbook. Smh.

The attempt to obfuscate here is mind numbing.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
facepalm

lol who do u think pointed out that list that funnily enough includes the other series you are trying to refute(Thor Man o War)? Smh...

That there is a suggested reading list that gives a good representation of the character. Not everything canon to Thor is listed there. Like showings in other series like Avengers, and a plethora of other books, etc... You do know that right?

While on the other hand, scenes from the particular series in question(Trial/Rage) was actually printed in the actual meat of the handbook. Smh.

The attempt to obfuscate here is mind numbing.

That list only seems to include HC/TP. Trial of Thor HC was released in 2017, after that list was made iirc.

I don't even know what the **** you're arguing and to what extent (I tuned out after the Serpent shit came up) but yeah. srug

Trial of Thor/Rage of Thor came out 2009 and 2010 respectively.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Trial of Thor/Rage of Thor came out 2009 and 2010 respectively.

https://www.amazon.com/Thor-Trial-Alan-Davis/dp/1302907956

No iced coffee for me to spill this time.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
facepalm

Lol who do u think pointed out that list earlier that funnily enough includes the other series you are trying to refute(Thor Man o War)? What are you trying to do, show me something I haven't seen? Smh...

That there is a suggested reading list that gives a good representation of the character. Not everything canon to Thor is listed there... For example showings in other series like Avengers, and a plethora of other books, etc... You do know that right?

While on the other hand, scenes from the particular series in question(Trial/Rage) was actually printed in the actual meat of the handbook. Smh.

The attempt to obfuscate here is mind numbing.

https://m.imgur.com/xfBuEix

He stopped living with humans because his lover died of black plague as per Rage of Thor. And he had mjolnir in dark ages when it's shown recently that he wasn't worthy of mjolnir even in viking era.

https://readcomiconline.to/Comic/Generations-The-Unworthy-Thor-The-Mighty-Thor/Full?id=119977

To paraphrase, it contradicts pretty much everything in Thor mythos

Did you even read what you posted?

Jesus...……………………………….…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..………………………………………………………………...

😂

Originally posted by quanchi112
😂

Here Thor beats Surtur 2x outright, beats a clone complete with his own magic hammer created to kill himself and Odin, beat the combined armies of the dwarves and frost giants that included Ymir, and shakes Asgard and Midgard in the process while he was battling in Nidavelier. There is no way in Hel he is going to accept these feats.

Patter recognized.

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Like I said before... He did the same thing with Breaking into Comics the Marvel Way mini. That story had him beat the Hulk(Rulk?) outright in a flashback and beat a disguised Odin who had made himself 4x his strength...…. While unarmed... He couldn't bring himself to accept those so he goes and refutes the book.

Here Thor beats Surtur 2x outright, beats a clone complete with his own magic hammer created to kill himself and Odin, beat the combined armies of the dwarves and frost giants that included Ymir, and shakes Asgard and Midgard in the process while he was battling in Nidavelier. There is no way in Hel he is going to accept these feats.

Patter recognized.