ESB Vader vs AOTC Mace Windu · Star Wars Versus Forum

xPRIMEx Senior Member

Is this canon or legends?

Forschbewithu Senior Member

Originally posted by DarthAnt66
Lucas also has Mace as a tier nine combatant, in league with Sidious.

Mace is an "8, bordering on 9" according to Gillard.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z2-iZNQrFBA

Start at 14 mins.

relentless1 Dark Overlord of KMC

ok, so Mace can legit can compete with Sidious ill give you Lucas' statement but it doesnt mean he could beat him necessarily and doesnt change the fact that Sidious controlled how that fight ended up right from the beginning

victreebelvictr Flowey's Only Friend

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Obi-Wan never said he can take Palpatine. He said LET ME face him (instead of facing my brother).
Then Yoda tells him straight thats a stupid and pointless challenge for him to take on.
End of you can quote all the dialogue and add all the speculation you like, but nothing changes the fact that Lucas himself has stated Mace can compete against Sidious. End of.
Doesnt make him =/> Sidious. But he is Capable of a win, and most certainly capable of putting u a decent fight.
Why deny/argue what came direct from the creators mouth? Twice no less.

Are you telling me that I do not think Windu has a chance. Of course Windu does, he was the strongest jedi of the council other than Yoda. If anyone else in the council(other than Yoda) Windu would have the highest chance. Not a big one, but a slightly larger than everyone else's chance.