Is ROTJ Darth Vader more powerful than Anakin?

Originally posted by TheNuisanceBird
Even if he did know he was fighting a younger version of himself it likely wouldn't matter. Just because he knows what to expect doesn't mean it'll be easy. I don't see Vader's formula working well against someone like Anakin.

🙂

Oh come on, we arent really using the Vader knows Anakins moves BS are we?

If you wanna walk down that road, then Vader cant do anything lethal to Anakin because it would effect his future self lol.

This thread is about which incarnation is the greater combatant. Not about which one would have the advantage in a time travel meet up.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Oh come on, we arent really using the Vader knows Anakins moves BS are we?

If you wanna walk down that road, then Vader cant do anything lethal to Anakin because it would effect his future self lol.

This thread is about which incarnation is the greater combatant. Not about which one would have the advantage in a time travel meet up.

^ Its basically the same line of retardation and completely missing the point of the thread, yeah Lmao

Originally posted by Darth Thor
^ Its basically the same line of retardation and completely missing the point of the thread, yeah Lmao

facepalm

Legends-wise. Yes.
Canon-wise. No.

Originally posted by CactusJoe
See, you're already walking down the dark path that is the straw man. I never said it would be an easy win for Vader. In fact, I never even said Vader would win for sure. Just that familarity with Anakin's prowess is an advantage he possesses. Your baseless opinion that it wouldn't matter also doesn't cut it when SW history has shown it does.

🙂

You completely missed the point.

Originally posted by TheNuisanceBird
You completely missed the point.

Originally posted by CactusJoe
No, you did, and now you don't know what the hell to say so you try and make me look bad. Nice try, chief, but it ain't working this time.

Not when you tried to push a straw man.

We were talking about Anakin's style being known to Vader being irrelevant and when I was explaining my point of view you made something else of it.

Anakin is definitely better, but still he doesn't stomp him like some may suggest he does.

Originally posted by TheNuisanceBird
Not when you tried to push a straw man.

We were talking about Anakin's style being known to Vader being irrelevant and when I was explaining my point of view you made something else of it.

Originally posted by CactusJoe
I was pointing out your straw man bro. Your entire post was based on me saying Vader would have it ''easy'', which I never said lol.

That was what I meant. I brought up something to support my argument and you went after it.

Apologies for not explaining it better for you. I will send you ILS and an unabused pig as a gift.

Originally posted by TheNuisanceBird
That was what I meant. I brought up something to support my argument and you went after it.

Apologies for not explaining it better for you. I will send you ILS and an unabused pig as a gift.

Originally posted by CactusJoe
Those are some awfully convenient gifts, thank you.

Service with a smile. Addition features include ILS saying "daddy" repeatedly at a rapid rate and screaming "f*ggot" at the top of his lungs while fracking the pig.

Dooku>Vader thanks to Force Lightning.

Maul>Vader thanks to better sober skills.

Originally posted by The Merchant
Maul>Vader thanks to better sober skills.

Nah. I'll bet Maul was drunk off his ass after having his plans ruined by Sidious. Had to cope with his depression somehow.

Originally posted by CactusJoe
You've been a braindead vegetable for years, my friend. I was addressing other already off-topic posts in this thread, so I'm excused. And no, it's not at all the same line of logic. Knowledge, familiarity, previous experience etc. is obviously important factors in vs. battles. On the contrary, by saying that Vader can't harm Anakin without harming himself, you project the entire SW timeline into the vs. battle. By that line of retardation, almost all vs. threads can't exist, because they would either affect the SW universe in a different way than has already happened, or they were dead by the time the opposite character existed.

facepalm

Yeah youre being super retarded.

Or at least youre being very silly over this point.

We are discussing who is the better/ more powerful combatant. If your point is Vader has better knowledge of forms in general
Then fair enough.

But saying Vader will win because he will remember all of Anakins moves is just facepalm

Originally posted by The Merchant
Dooku>Vader thanks to Force Lightning.

Maul>Vader thanks to better sober skills.

Flawed logic my friend

Originally posted by The Merchant
Dooku>Vader thanks to Force Lightning.

Maul>Vader thanks to better sober skills.

And Palpatine is Ommin level.

Originally posted by Darth Thor
Yeah youre being super retarded.

Or at least youre being very silly over this point.

We are discussing who is the better/ more powerful combatant. If your point is Vader has better knowledge of forms in general
Then fair enough.

But saying Vader will win because he will remember all of Anakins moves is just facepalm

Read my post again, you dimwit.

Originally posted by CactusJoe
As to this thread, Vader has a decent chance of beating Anakin imo. If nothing else, he possesses intimate knowledge of Anakin for obvious reasons, which is a fairly big advantage.

I never said Vader would beat Anakin. When TheNuisanceBird similarly failed to comprehend my post, I said the same thing.

Learn to ****ing read. Holy shit. I won't waste my time on you until you do.