Darth Caedus vs. Darth Plagueis (Sabers)

Started by Geistalt4 pages

Darth Caedus vs. Darth Plagueis (Sabers)

Who would win?

Plagueis overwhelms Plagueis with the Force!

...wot

Caedus probably wins in Dueling, but Plagueis overwhelms him with the Force, kind of like the Venamis scenario.

Caedus takes this.

Oh damn, I just realized the title is Sabers Only...

Sorry...

I do this a lot, I made a whole arguement in this one thread on how Luminara would lose to Qui-Gon Jinn...

It didn’t say Luminara, it said Lumiya... 😆

It's difficult to say. Plagueis is probably stronger in the Force from a mastery standpoint, but Caedus could be speculated to have more raw power due to his potential. He's also more experienced as a combatant, though both are probably comparably technically skilled, and has a greater pain tolerance.

Originally posted by The Ellimist
It's difficult to say. Plagueis is probably stronger in the Force from a mastery standpoint, but Caedus could be speculated to have more raw power due to his potential. He's also more experienced as a combatant, though both are probably comparably technically skilled, and has a greater pain tolerance.
You just made the same mistake as me, it is only Sabers! 😆

Spoiler:
Plagueis's strength in the Force would factor into his lightsaber combat.

Caedus stomps, lmao.

It's hard to say seeing that peak Plagueis never participated in a proper duel, but it's probably fair to assume that a scientist that loathed lightsabers would be at a disadvantage against a dueling enthusiast, assuming there isn't an overwhelming discrepancy in their capacity to augment their bodies. Which there shouldn't be.

Plagueis may not have liked lightsabers, but iirc he was still very, very good with them to the point where I'm not sure if technical skill is going to be a major factor - and you could easily argue that he's stronger in the Force than Caedus, though I imagine Caedus may have more raw reserves due to his greater potential.

How is Plagueis more powerful?

Better feats - midichlorian manipulation, unbalancing of the cosmic Force, accolades putting him as the strongest sith up to his time, etc.

Midi-manip is reflective of overall power and not just a neat ability? Jeez. The Unbalancing has been ripped apart so many times. There are multiple accolades? Not just one blurb?

I'd like to see how the unbalancing has been "ripped apart".

Caedus demolishes him in sabers.

Originally posted by RealistRacism
Midi-manip is reflective of overall power and not just a neat ability? Jeez. The Unbalancing has been ripped apart so many times. There are multiple accolades? Not just one blurb?

he didn't say it was reflective of overall power, he mentioned it in conjunction with other feats/accolades to pain plagueis as the more powerful. stop strawmanning the **** out of him lmao

Originally posted by The Ellimist
Spoiler:
Plagueis's strength in the Force would factor into his lightsaber combat.
Would that count?

Caedus.