Comic Book Questions & Discussion

Started by carver91,926 pages

Also want to show that even though the planet wasn't strong, a weakened Hulk and his companion destroyed the planet leaving nothing but the core...

https://ibb.co/Fqmf1vC
https://ibb.co/4KGrDjS

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
So in short, they had exhausted their supply of planets/moons and were scraping the barrel, using whatever was left.

Not talking about the lowest of scales. Weren't YOU the one who mentioned 'small' planets in the first place, not me?

Moreover, the initial size doesn't really matter. Jupiter is way larger than Earth, but it's core is like, mainly gas.

I don't have one for Superman, precisely because he has flight so it's not a like for like comparison. I was merely pointing out that a close analogy to Hulk's impressive feat, that of a flightless non magical mid herald brick who wasn't at 100%, was Lobo.

Who casually threw a neutron star around. Like I said, it's very impressive for that tier, not taking anything away. I'm not low balling or questioning the feat, am taking it at face value. I'm not inventing or adding anything - you cannot suddenly make up that they, for some reason, kept the largest densest planet around.

Since it's a mid herald ft, trans tier Thanos can do it as well? Throw around neutron stars?

Originally posted by carver9
Also want to show that even though the planet wasn't strong, a weakened Hulk and his companion destroyed the planet leaving nothing but the core...

https://ibb.co/Fqmf1vC
https://ibb.co/4KGrDjS

Well that core looks tiny, so thanks for that scan.

Originally posted by carver9
Since it's a mid herald ft, trans tier Thanos can do it as well? Throw around neutron stars?

Thanos? On pure strength? Maybe. We'd need showings with no magic or tech, personally I haven't seen those feats though.

Have to point out though that Thanos' greatest threat is from his intellect and resources (although not taking anything away from him, he's a powerhouse as well). His tiering isn't solely due to his strength (again, this is why I was using Lobo as he's a pretty one dimensional brick, right?)

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Well that core looks tiny, so thanks for that scan.

Thanos? On pure strength? Maybe. We'd need showings with no magic or tech, personally I haven't seen those feats though.

Have to point out though that Thanos' greatest threat is from his intellect and resources (although not taking anything away from him, he's a powerhouse as well). His tiering isn't solely due to his strength (again, this is why I was using Lobo as he's a pretty one dimensional brick, right?)

Yeah, it probably isn't listed as the strongest of cores like the other was. Kind of remind me of the planet Superman destroyed by leaping. Looking at it from a distance, it looked tiny AF.

So it's a maybe for Thanos even though you're listing the ft as a mid herald ft?

Originally posted by carver9
Yeah, it probably isn't listed as the strongest of cores like the other was. Kind of remind me of the planet Superman destroyed by leaping. Looking at it from a distance, it looked tiny AF.

So it's a maybe for Thanos even though you're listing the ft as a mid herald ft?

😂

Originally posted by carver9
Yeah, it probably isn't listed as the strongest of cores like the other was. Kind of remind me of the planet Superman destroyed by leaping. Looking at it from a distance, it looked tiny AF.

So it's a maybe for Thanos even though you're listing the ft as a mid herald ft?


😂. Omg carver, you slay me.

As to your other question, well I haven't personally seen Thanos do so, but I wouldn't be surprised if he could do it, he's Thanos after all. What's so difficult to comprehend?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
😂. Omg carver, you slay me.

As to your other question, well I haven't personally seen Thanos do so, but I wouldn't be surprised if he could do it, he's Thanos after all. What's so difficult to comprehend?

So it's not a mid Herald ft since Thanos doesn't have the showing, right? That's a high showing for Lobo whereas the Hulk ft is an average for him.

Originally posted by carver9
So it's not a mid Herald ft since Thanos doesn't have the showing, right? That's a high showing for Lobo whereas the Hulk ft is an average for him.

Lmao, uhuh.

I know you're just salty because you came in here all afire, thinking that it was the best feat ever, until I poured water all over your dreams.

As I said, it's a very impressive feat for the midherald tier - I can't really think of any other flightless non magical brick in that tier doing something similar. Lobo had a very similar feat, not my fault it outshone Hulk's by several orders of magnitude (planet/moon Vs a star). Lobo, who:

Originally posted by carver9
Also, Lobo is a weakling. He is 100% not top tier in strength.

I guess DC just operates on a different tier as per you? Weaklings who aren't top tiers on strength casually throw stars around, whilst the strongest there is in Marvel is jumping with a partial planet?

I did like how Demoness BFRd Hulk casually, though. But tell me, now that I've read the comic - how heavy was that core that he was sweating (whilst weakened) to throw? Back it up with proof, please. You can give me a high and a low end

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Lmao, uhuh.

I know you're just salty because you came in here all afire, thinking that it was the best feat ever, until I poured water all over your dreams.

As I said, it's a very impressive feat for the midherald tier - I can't really think of any other flightless non magical brick in that tier doing something similar. Lobo had a very similar feat, not my fault it outshone Hulk's by several orders of magnitude (planet/moon Vs a star). Lobo, who:

I guess DC just operates on a different tier as per you? Weaklings who aren't top tiers on strength casually throw stars around, whilst the strongest there is in Marvel is jumping with a partial planet?

I did like how Demoness BFRd Hulk casually, though. But tell me, now that I've read the comic - how heavy was that core that he was sweating (whilst weakened) to throw? Back it up with proof, please. You can give me a high and a low end

I've always disagreed with that Lobo ft and he is a weakling when you view all of his showings.

It's an impressive ft for all tiers. Anyways, the upper I would say is 151 billion trillion tons and the lower, I already mentioned it. Being generous, the weight of Earths core.

Demonish did bfr a Hulk who's dying.

Originally posted by carver9
I've always disagreed with that Lobo ft and he is a weakling when you view all of his showings.

It's an impressive ft for all tiers. Anyways, the upper I would say is 151 billion trillion tons and the lower, I already mentioned it. Being generous, the weight of Earths core.

Demonish did bfr a Hulk who's dying.

I asked for proof. Why would you range from 150 billion trillion tons to the Earth's core? Post scans or proof of this reasoning.

More importantly:

Shit just got real in Immortal X-Men #10. Don't know how long this has been brewing, maybe from the start? But Xavier finally takes the helmet off. And, major spoiler ahead (click at your own risk!!!):

Spoiler:
He's revealed to be a clone of Sinister
.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
More importantly:

Shit just got real in Immortal X-Men #10. Don't know how long this has been brewing, maybe from the start? But Xavier finally takes the helmet off. And, major spoiler ahead (click at your own risk!!!):

Spoiler:
He's revealed to be a clone of Sinister
.

Not Xavier? Can’t be? Why spit on the entire history of X-men like this.. I’m not a fan but I’m passed at this.

It's really slipped under the radar if so. Has Hickman always planned it thus????

Stilt, have you read the latest Punisher?

I wept.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
It's really slipped under the radar if so. Has Hickman always planned it thus????

I’m not sure. Hopefully X-men readers can shed some light.

Maybe post the last page of the comic 👆

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
More importantly:

Shit just got real in Immortal X-Men #10. Don't know how long this has been brewing, maybe from the start? But Xavier finally takes the helmet off. And, major spoiler ahead (click at your own risk!!!):

Spoiler:
He's revealed to be a clone of Sinister
.

It would actually explain a lot, wouldn't it...

Spoiler:
And there was a much earlier arc, after Messiah Complex, I think? When Sinister planned to get reborn in Xavier's body, something he prepped for decades ago.

Perhaps Krakoa re-created Xavier as he was, turning him back into a spawn point for Sinister?

I don't remember the details, but it was explored in X-Men Legacy, think it was Carey's run?

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
Stilt, have you read the latest Punisher?

I wept.

No. Need to catch up.

Has the Hand Punisher arc concluded?

It has indeed concluded. A major fan favourite, beloved character, gets affected by the events in the book.

Originally posted by Diesldude
I’m not sure. Hopefully X-men readers can shed some light.

Maybe post the last page of the comic 👆

Reading back, and after some discussion....maybe

Spoiler:
Sinister just infected the egg that hatched Xavier out (so similar to what Stilt was saying)
>

Added spoiler tags 👆

And I just got blueballed by this comic:

They don't even fight, lol.

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
They don't even fight, lol.

False advertising is what U.S.A. was built on.

Even their football ain't football... 😂