Let's do a discussion like we do in the tier thread, the topic will be a lot less controversial and only a handful of people here actually read comics anyways. It'd be a valuable resource.
We should probably start with some of the most well known characters before I start sharing my opinion on Kang and D-listers in general...
Originally posted by -Pr-Have it be based on voting like the tiers thread and only have votes that provide any decent elaboration be counted?
I like the idea in theory, but consensus would need to be reached, especially given that people can differ in what they believe to be great arcs. You could say "we can just add every suggestion", but that could get unwieldy quickly.
So I couldn't say "i like secret empire because cap is a nazi LOL" and have my vote be weighted the same as someone who provides a fairly in-depth reason for why All Star Superman should be in the list.
There will definitely be differences of opinion, like personally I think World War Hulk sucks balls but if three Hulk fans come in and provide some in-depth reasoning on why they think it's a good (or even just "essential"😉 read for Hulk fans I won't be butthurt about it making a list of Hulk required reading, nor should anyone really IMO. Bentley will have to sit there and stomach all of the Batman stories on the list. 👆
But as someone who wants more recommendations for comics to read I think it's a great idea. 👆
it would be good to have a read list that highlights the feats many of us tend to build off of, so we can see all the feats that get thrown around out of context too.
like the weird silver surfer stuff, the doomsday stuff, molecule man, sentry, source wall, etc. some of this stuff seems like base knowledge for some because there have been threads upon threads and scans too, but I think it would be cool and maybe garner more discussion and debate. tbf I dont read much DC outside of green lantern but I would/could read arcs I knew would be useful to debating on the forum.
Originally posted by -Pr-We can relate it in terms of quality , character growth, arcs and less feat driven.
I like the idea in theory, but consensus would need to be reached, especially given that people can differ in what they believe to be great arcs. You could say "we can just add every suggestion", but that could get unwieldy quickly.
I mean you can't really take for instance the red hulk series by jeph loeb and put it in the same boat as garth ennis's punisher. Yes quality is subjective but some things are neon lights.
Originally posted by Senor CageWhy? Because Dianna and Zatanna were able to trounce the Lords of Order AND repair the damage they cause to reality...with the insignificant portion of 'throwaway magic' Mordru gave them, lol? It was an insane battle... They were manipulating/shattering the comic book panels and shit.
Justice League Dark was pretty epic. Holy shit.
If they can do that, just imagine what Mordru himself is capable of...
Originally posted by Galan007
Why? Because Dianna and Zatanna were able to trounce the Lords of Order AND repair the damage they cause to reality...with the insignificant portion of 'throwaway magic' Mordru gave them, lol? It was an insane battle... They were manipulating/shattering the comic book panels and shit.If they can do that, just imagine what Mordru himself is capable of...
mmm