Immortal Hulk vs Nate Grey · Comic Book 'Versus' Forum

cdtm Restricted

Originally posted by One Big Mob
So you're only speaking to me it seems.
One of Nate's best time manipulation showings had him running away from Ares and getting knocked out. In a thread with no BFR, we're saying X-Man beats a mega amped Hulk when lesser forms have punched through pretty much everything to continue fighting? When lesser Hulks have been shown completely out of lesser Nates' league.
Not Shaman Nate Grey, not Life Seed Nate Grey, just Nate Grey mind you. How dare people cater to Carver's needs thinking Hulk wins.

You tell him!

And if this was in Foreign Cinema, and someone made a Goku vs Hulk thread, he'd beat Goku too, because Hulk can punch through "just about anything."

No wonder Carv gets annoyed at the Superman hype train. Hulk could just punch the yellow solar energy right outta him, just like he'd punch Nate's time/reality manipulation powers!

carver9 Senior Member

Stop trolling CDTM.

cdtm Restricted

Originally posted by carver9
Stop trolling CDTM.

It's cute you don't realize OBM is the one trolling you.

One Big Mob Dead

Originally posted by cdtm
You tell him!
And if this was in Foreign Cinema, and someone made a Goku vs Hulk thread, he'd beat Goku too, because Hulk can punch through "just about anything."
No wonder Carv gets annoyed at the Superman hype train. Hulk could just punch the yellow solar energy right outta him, just like he'd punch Nate's time/reality manipulation powers!

Goku beats Hulk because he knocks him out with a jab. Sub-Ares Nate loses because there's no bfr, and his powers are shit to a degree that Hulk could likely just punch out of any sort of stasis he does.

Unless it's solar shit apparently.

Lol at Nate using reality manip on Hulk though. The reason why speed works is because it's always there and is natural as moving. Hulk needs one punch to win here. Nate's first reaction being a quickdraw on time manipulation isn't the same.

One Big Mob Dead

Originally posted by carver9
Wonder if Doomsday, Mongul or Shaggyman was in this thread would the deciding factor be different for most? Haven't seen any of these people overcome time stop (even though Hulk has). Interesting.

Good point Carver

Originally posted by CatL18
Round1: New 52 Superman vs Normal Nate Grey
Round2: Post Crisis Superman vs Shaman Nate Grey
Round:3 OWAW Superman vs Phoenix Nate Grey
Which will win?

Originally posted by carver9
Nate.

celeyhyga17 Yawning Void

Originally posted by carver9
Wonder if Doomsday, Mongul or Shaggyman was in this thread would the deciding factor be different for most? Haven't seen any of these people overcome time stop (even though Hulk has). Interesting.

Wasn't he wearing chronal armor?

carver9 Senior Member

Originally posted by One Big Mob
Good point Carver

I think Hulk is above Superman though. 🙂

Nate outright admitted Hulk is>him. Shaman Nate and any Nate above him would beat Hulk. New 52 Superman TP resistance was trash.

carver9 Senior Member

Originally posted by celeyhyga17
Wasn't he wearing chronal armor?

The armor wasn't in play for this showing.

One Big Mob Dead

He grabbed Khotto in one hand and punched through a TV to the future, and apparently it was his strength that fixed all the paradoxes in his timeline. Hulk was literally in the past though, not simply stopped. There's also the time storm shit. srug

X-Man's time manipulation wasn't to that degree though. Unless I'm mistaken, his only conventional time "stop" was attributed to telekinetic powers stopping everything around him, and his planck one was more of him hiding in time while Ares could bully him through all the locations he was seeing. It was him retreating, not stopping everything around him. Semantics, but it comes out to literally arguing something he never did and therefore powersets if you think he stops time against Hulk.

Obviously Hulk can be BFR'ed in time, but if you wrap him in that energy to halt him, he should be able to fight it if we're arguing Nate can stop him in the first attack he uses. Considering there's no BFR...

carver9 Senior Member

Talking about this scene...
https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/16636492/Indestructible_Hulk_13_015.jpg.html
https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/16636494/Indestructible_Hulk_13_016.jpg.html

One Big Mob Dead

Originally posted by carver9
I think Hulk is above Superman though. 🙂
Nate outright admitted Hulk is>him. Shaman Nate and any Nate above him would beat Hulk. New 52 Superman TP resistance was trash.

I forgot you wank Nate because of the Onslaught fiasco, my mistake. In your mind, Hulk beating Nate Grey is somehow a knock against Superman because Nate beats Superman as well. Makes sense to cement that in place.

*incoming Medusa Mask scans*

One Big Mob Dead

Originally posted by carver9
Talking about this scene...
https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/16636492/Indestructible_Hulk_13_015.jpg.html
https://www.turboimagehost.com/p/16636494/Indestructible_Hulk_13_016.jpg.html

He was wearing Chronal Armor... it's even attributed to helping him slow down the effects...

It wasn't all the armor, but it wasn't NOT there either.

MrMind Senior Member

Originally posted by One Big Mob
So you're only speaking to me it seems.
One of Nate's best time manipulation showings had him running away from Ares and getting knocked out. In a thread with no BFR, we're saying X-Man beats a mega amped Hulk when lesser forms have punched through pretty much everything to continue fighting? When lesser Hulks have been shown completely out of lesser Nates' league.
Not Shaman Nate Grey, not Life Seed Nate Grey, just Nate Grey mind you. How dare people cater to Carver's needs thinking Hulk wins.

lol no Bran I was not addressing you. I don't read your post

I was just getting sick of people giving Weapon H majority over Superman and the Flash earlier, this is just my way of venting

also I guess my mistake of thinkin Nate Gray is current since aka: OP forum rules unless specify otherwise but whatever shame on me for not reading through the thread of course

Rage.Of.Olympus Senior Member

Hulk would just punch his way out of a time freeze as lesser incarnations, much less Immortal Hulk. Did you guys read the last issue of Immortal Hulk?

*Time Freeze*

"Hulk is Hulk."

*Reverses time with a thunderclap*

This Hulk would beat the amped Nate Grey like he was Brian Banner.

DarkSaint85 Bonified abstract

Originally posted by carver9
The armor wasn't in play for this showing.

😂

Bentley Seitei

Originally posted by StiltmanFTW
Nate couldn't even handle Hank P[b]rym... [/B]

Scans please.

leonidas MWHAHAHAHA!

i'm still unsure how this would go down. tough to see nate winning without going fully exotic. he could tk hulk's mind--literally disassemble it via tk, then use his tk to prevent him healing. he could hold that long enough to get a win a guess. he should be able to use his tk control to fully interrupt any of hulk's bodily functions--heart, lungs, whatever, but once tk was released....

i don't see tp working, nor energy release. time stop would have been an option, but hulk....

he could left him from the ground and hold him--but that wouldn't last. nate's tk vs hulk strength wouldn't end well for nate.

i don't know, as versatile as nate is, and as much as i love the character, hard to see him winning without bfr. /shrug

DarkSaint85 Bonified abstract

What if he uses TK and grabs Hulk's heart and lifts him that way?

Completely hypothetical so don't jump down my throat about whether he's done it before.

My question is , is it possible.

MrMind Senior Member

Originally posted by DarkSaint85
What if he uses TK and grabs Hulk's heart and lifts him that way?
Completely hypothetical so don't jump down my throat about whether he's done it before.
My question is , is it possible.

DarkSaint85 Bonified abstract

If that happens....Would Hulk be able to do anything? Claw his own heart out? It's not like he can flex his muscles there or anything....

Or say, if he TK controlled his blood. It's not as if you can flex your blood cells, lol.